Re:John Resig: JavaScript as a First Language
by gliese1337 on Wednesday December 21, 2011 @08:43PM
(#3379960)
Seeing as how one of the arguments for teaching JavaScript first is that it lets you teach about prototypical inheritance before the students get used to class-based inheritance, the complexity of simulating a class in JavaScript is probably not the best objection to using it instead of CoffeeScript. If you teach them CoffeeScript, then you will teach them class-based inheritance just like everywhere else, and miss out on the prototype paradigm.
Re:John Resig: JavaScript as a First Language
by latchkey on Wednesday December 21, 2011 @08:55PM
(#3379994)
I'm ok with missing out on the prototype paradigm. To me, it is a wart for JavaScript. There has been a ton of discussion on why libraries like DateJS, which pollute the Date prototype, are bad.
http://stackoverflow.com/questions/4823682/javascript-namesp...
Re:John Resig: JavaScript as a First Language
by wwweston on Thursday December 22, 2011 @03:23AM
(#3380867)
The discussion you're linking to doesn't appear to discuss either general problems with the prototype paradigm or specific problems with adding properties/methods to the Date prototype.
The closest it seems to come is a warning about not trying to modify the prototype of an object through its __proto__ property (or, I suppose, .getPrototypeOf), which isn't the same thing.
Re:John Resig: JavaScript as a First Language
by Cushman on Wednesday December 21, 2011 @09:17PM
(#3380040)
Personally, I treat the `class` keyword as a useful (and powerful) macro for constructing prototypes.
I imagine if someone thought they were building a 'real' class-based program for too long, they'd be in for a few surprises later on.
One other line item is the encapsulation of classes in CS. Doing that in CS is natural and easy to explain to a first year programmer. Accomplishing the same thing in JS is far more boilerplate and much harder to explain why you have to fight the language to accomplish something as simple as a class.
Sure, you probably shouldn't learn CS without at least a general understanding of JS, but I definitely think that CS is the next logical step for the second semester.