News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by ahoy on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @01:54PM (#33791583)
This is imprisonment without conviction, no matter how you gussy it up.

It's unsurprising. NYC elected a cop as mayor, and his only idea for solving the city's problems is more policing. It hasn't worked in the past, and it won't work now, but the media and real estate classes here keep demanding it anyway.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by asdff on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @01:57PM (#33791613)
The alternative is these people continue to live and die on the street without care where they are frequently targeted for exploitation or abuse, not freedom
Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by jibbers on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:17PM (#33791874)
Surely there are other alternatives.
Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by version_five on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:38PM (#33792182)
I hope you can appreciate how little value this kind of comment adds. I used to work with someone who would make this exact comment "surely there must be X" in discussions, and it is far less helpful than saying nothing. Either you have an option, or a criticism or some other insight, or you have nothing to add. "surely" means nothing.
Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by toomuchtodo on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:26PM (#33792011)
Propose them.
Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by tiahura on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:00PM (#33792452)
Your house.
Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by FollowingTheDao on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:17PM (#33791873)
I would agree with you if I did not experience the "care" they calling to provide in these psychiatric for-profit hospitals. Let me tell you about abuse...

Why not just give these people free housing with assisted care on location? If we can survive on the street we can surly survive in a residential setting.

What will happen is they they will pump us full of drugs to sedate us and just keep sucking money out of the state and federal government so that these hospital owners can buy another house in Bermuda.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by baremetal on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:33PM (#33792106)
you mention abuse, then don't give any examples.

surely giving anti-psychotic drugs isn't tantamount to abuse in severe cases.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by asdff on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:43PM (#33792247)
On the street gang members might force you to pimp yourself or sell drugs, and use your addiction to meth or fentanyl or threats to your life as their hold over you. They might light your tent on fire with you in it.

https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2018/07/tent-fires-are-o...

For these people who have severe mental illness, free housing with assisted care on location looks a lot like a mental institution. Without oversight they are liable to walk out of care and be back on the street. For some homeless, that's how they are on the street today. They might have gotten a delusion that leads them from disappearing from their families, and sometimes they find them years later living on the streets in a state of complete dissociation with reality, other times they never find them.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by tcj_phx on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @11:28PM (#33797034)
> What will happen is they they will pump us full of drugs to sedate us

The agony induced by haloperidol was used by the Soviets to help their dissidents realize the gulags were much better places than the psycho prisons.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by ugh123 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:26PM (#33791989)
So whats your solution to both 1) homelessness and 2) many homeless (not all) that menace pedestrians and businesses on a daily basis?
Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by FollowingTheDao on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:31PM (#33792073)
> So whats your solution to both 1) homelessness

Houses.

> many homeless (not all) that menace pedestrians and businesses on a daily basis?

Houses.

You see, the answer is simple but there is just no will to do it because people do not care about the mentally ill. We scare people for no reason but their own ignorance. I would say 90% of the mentally ill would have a great remission of their symptoms if they had stable housing.

I am homeless, all I need is a simple fcking studio but even making a lot of money from disability I cannot afford one anymore and I get shut down by people who do not want to rent to me because I am on diability.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by tiahura on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:04PM (#33792518)
Maybe it’s a dumb question, but why don’t you find 2 or 3 other people in your same situation and pool resources as roommates? 4 disability checks might be enough to allow you to afford a better home and landlord?
Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by rmah on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:15PM (#33792651)
This may sound flippant but...

Poor people who are not mentally ill often do exactly that. Even some drug addicts can sometimes get together to rent a place to crash. But we're talking about the severely mentally ill here. They are unable to band together. I imagine that this is sort of by definition... those who's mental illness illness is mild enough that they can help themselves by working together... just do it. The remaining are on the streets.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by dionidium on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:43PM (#33793017)
But now we're full circle, because you're describing somebody who needs a lot more than just a government-provided house.
Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by carewell on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:38PM (#33792945)
In sorry about the situation you are in.

Can we agree that different people have different urgent needs? I agree with you that you need a house. A mentally unstable person who can’t take care of themselves needs mental help. A person with hard drug addiction destroying them needs physical and mental help. Not all problems can be solved with free housing, just like not all problems can be solved with involuntary hospitalization.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by RHSeeger on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:41PM (#33792982)
> You see, the answer is simple but there is just no will to do it because people do not care about the mentally ill.

That is unfair, as it implying that throwing houses at the problem will magically fix it. Houses would help, for some (many) cases, but it's a lot more complicated than that. Nor is it simple to supply those houses, and lack of doing so isn't just "not caring". It's hard. It's really hard.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by unethical_ban on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:43PM (#33793015)
Isn't disability a protected class for renting?
Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:00PM (#33791655)
Without federal action for adequate funding for adequate mental healthcare providers nationwide, I do not see what other choice any state/county/city in the US could have.

Same with healthcare or housing or any other population wide benefit policy where benefit recipients can migrate in and net payers into the system can migrate out.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by purpleblue on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:19PM (#33791906)
It's getting help when they are mentally incapable of getting help for themselves. Do you honestly believe letting them suffer on the streets is better for them? If so, you're a monster.
Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by djohnston on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:59PM (#33792449)
It actually did work in the past. The reason cities are so overrun with homeless crazies these days is because we let them all out in the 80s and 90s.
Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by taolegal on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:06PM (#33792550)
> NYC elected a cop as mayor, and his only idea for solving the city's problems is more policing

I don't notice much difference with him compared to de Blasio, except de Blasio was universally not liked. Adams is better but surprisingly by not much.

> It hasn't worked in the past

Considering the 70s were a complete mess & a generation afterwards it didn't feel like that, whatever happened in-between seems to have improved things. And that improvement definitely did come from police to some degree.

Crime was at a historic low until recently with the advent of "defund."

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by unethical_ban on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:47PM (#33793057)
Except few places have defunded their police. I would bet NYC has not. In many places it seems the cops are somewhere between understaffed and simply pouting and not doing their job unless it's exciting. Anecdote: I had about $2,500 of electronics stolen from my car on video in a parking lot, and the cop did not go back to check for full footage or imply anything would be done about it. Didn't even check to see if there were plates in the back of the car!

By the way, "defund" was also about using some paramilitary police funding to fund social services and mental health calls like the ones that may be dealing with the people in this discussion.

Finally, recall that "defund" kicked off at the same time as a global pandemic and major economic shock, an affordable housing shortage, a wage shortage and a drug epidemic.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by taolegal on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @10:00AM (#33801636)
> the cops are somewhere between understaffed and simply pouting and not doing their job unless it's exciting

so are you pro-worker or not (I suspect you are pro-worker), cause it sounds like you're hashing out anti-worker rhetoric against your enemies

I hear this all the time from ppl, it's this automatic talking point that cops don't do their job, so we should just push dangerous slogans like defund - when cops are desperately needed in actually dangerous neighborhoods. It's a very privileged sentiment.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by unethical_ban on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @10:32AM (#33802089)
There is a difference between an actual strike with specific demands, and "quiet quitting" as a police officer. What do police demand? From their unions, it seems they just want continued immunity from murder charges when they negligently kill citizens.

If the rail workers threatening a strike had a history of disabling crossing guards on railroad crossings to hit cars without warning, and their union didn't want conductors to get fired for that, I'd be against the railroad union, too.

Again, "defund", this scary slogan, attempted to wrap a lot of ideas up, most of which did not directly mean "eliminate the role of law enforcement". And, like I said and you failed to refute, substantial police budget cuts are quite sparse. So what's dangerous besides something that hasn't happened? What's dangerous other than cops quiet quitting to protest things that haven't happened?

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by taolegal on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @12:09PM (#33803764)
The problem of course is public sector unions. Even FDR (one of the biggest union icons) thought the idea of a public sector union is dysfunctional nonsense, it makes no sense that they should exist.

Public sector employees are represented by the public in voting. The idea that they should bargain with the public is ridiculous when they are the public elected by the public. Any additional "protection" will dangerously insulate them from reform & accountability to the will of the public.

Public sector unions are fundamentally anti-democratic.

With a union, they're able to hold other citizens hostage. It's disgraceful and exactly why they're able to get humongous budgets for doing nothing, as you seem to admit.

Mind you this happens with teachers and other public sector employees. Pretty much inevitably.

Of course, the people who get up-in-arms about police never extend their logic to their own sacred cows.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by unethical_ban on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:57PM (#33805769)
A debate on the utility of public unions would be interesting to me, you being up a good point.

We should probably nationalize our railroads, too, but that's a different discussion.

We've gone off the rails (!) but we might agree more than disagree. My stances:

Homelessness: housing needs to be more affordable, income inequality should be reduced through progressively higher taxes, and funding for mental healthcare and public safety should be increased.

Cops: major reforms required but they are a necessity in society.

Unions: reasonable for private sector, debatable for public sector, dangerous in the case of law enforcement.

Oh, and the root of our failures in government is the two party system which lowers morale for the public, promotes political extremism and encourages fear-based politicking instead of solution -based politicking.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by rhaway84773 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @04:05PM (#33793287)
Crime is still lower than it was a decade ago. And as another comment pointed out, almost no City in the US defunded the police. NYC certainly did not.
Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by taolegal on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @09:59AM (#33801619)
they did enact bail "reform" which is why so many criminals get back on the streets and are murdering people
Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by dionidium on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:40PM (#33792970)
> This is imprisonment without conviction, no matter how you gussy it up.

This is begging the question. You have to explain why you think that's bad, not merely describe what's happening.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by bsder on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @05:03PM (#33794009)
> This is imprisonment without conviction, no matter how you gussy it up.

We could force the state to put these people in front of a judge or jury if you prefer. California does--and my experience is that these people seem to get reasonable aggressive representation from the state.

It unfortunately won't change much.

There aren't enough beds--that's the simple truth. So, this isn't going to put even a dent into the situation.

Re:New York City Will Hospitalize More Mentally Ill People I... by mancerayder on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @11:04PM (#33796896)
This is sensationalism. There are people letting themselves rot on the streets, it's more than an inconvenience to the society, it's a danger to themselves. They're not going to voluntarily do anything in many cases.

The trope about "the Mayor is a former cop" makes for good political talking points but it's meaningless otherwise. In what way has NYC become any different since Adams took the helm?