News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by dakial1 on Friday November 25, 2022 @08:34AM (#33742205)
As you guys seem to be confused on this so let me explain the rationale.

Brazil has a consumer law, that defines what companies can/can't do when selling to consumers. It has like, warranty minimums for durable goods (90 days), "no questions asked" return right for virtual purchases (7 days), etc... among those there is a very special one called "Venda Casada", which translates to tie-in/combined sale.

The "venda casada" article forbids the condition of an purchase to the necessity of purchasing another item (from whoever is selling it). For the Apple case, the judge understands that by removing the charger (and therefore selling as a separate product), Apple is forcing the consumer to purchase 2 items when acquiring an iPhone, as the charger is a must have item for a smartphone, and to make things worse, Apple has a proprietary charger so new customers and those migrating from other platforms (like android) will need to buy the charger.

The rationale is pretty similar to a TV brand selling a TV without the charging cable, since everyone has a TV, so they surely must already have a charging cable.

This is a law, it is not Brazil government/judiciary with some vendetta against Apple. Many companies have had decisions against them because of this.

I hope this helps make things clearer. Cheers!

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by mbalyuzi on Friday November 25, 2022 @08:43AM (#33742280)
Just wait 'till they discover that Apple Watches need an iPhone to work...
Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by jonhohle on Friday November 25, 2022 @08:47AM (#33742305)
Apple does not have a proprietary charger. It has a proprietary cable, which comes with the device. That cable plugs into a standard USB charger or port, even one’s that came with android phones.
Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by twawaaay on Friday November 25, 2022 @08:55AM (#33742382)
Apple says:

"When using electronic accessories with your iPhone, ensure that they are either genuine Apple products or that they have been certified as Made for iPhone under the MFi program. Certified items come with the "Made for iPhone" logo on them and/or on their packaging.

(...)

Using uncertified or counterfeit accessories may damage your iPhone and/or adversely affect operation. Apple's warranty does not cover damage caused by use with a third party product that does not meet Apple's specifications."

So you have to buy Apple charger to be able to use iPhone "correctly" and to preserve warrant.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by crazygringo on Friday November 25, 2022 @08:57AM (#33742401)
No, that's simply not true. A charger is no more an accessory than an electrical outlet is.

Obviously you can use any charger you want, and your warranty will be just fine.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by NikolaNovak on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:00AM (#33742422)
Are you saying that as a lawyer experienced in this area of law and location... or like my dad dispenses legal advice, because "it's obviously true (to him)"?

The OP quoted written Apple policy. If you want to persuasively negate it, it should have more than "Nope!" in response.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by crazygringo on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:07AM (#33742489)
Let's put it this way: in reality, how is Apple ever going to know what charger you used? Obviously it can't.

So in practice, which is all that matters, it can never void your warranty.

And let's keep in mind, the entire purpose of a standard USB-C port is that you can use any charger. Otherwise Apple would use a proprietary connector on its charger, which it has never done.

So let's just stay in the realm of common sense here, OK? :) No need to be demanding whether someone is a lawyer, sheesh.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by twawaaay on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:15AM (#33742558)
> And let's keep in mind, the entire purpose of a standard USB-C port is that you can use any charger.

What the stated purpose is is irrelevant. The reality is that not all usb devices or even cables are the same. If you don't buy Apple charger and cable you might be sorrily disappointed your phone charges at glacial speeds with the one that was laying around your house and worked perfectly for another device.

And if you don't know the many charging standards you might conclude the only way to resolve the issue is to actually buy Apple cable and charger.

My wife can't even name various USB connectors when she asks me if I have so and so cable. Forget about charging or transmission standards, this is something she cannot grasp. For her if the connectors fit they should be working properly. I also am of the same opinion but I also know that it is not how it works in reality.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by NikolaNovak on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:11AM (#33742522)
Fair enough; I should have said "as someone with legal expertise in this area", not "as a lawyer".

But I DO believe it's important to distinguish when one is dispensing legal experience (even if not advice), vs "common sense". Different people will have different preferences and fair enough, but for what little it may be worth, I tend to come to HN to read about (ridiculously frequent and that's what makes this place wonderful!:) people's experience in obscure areas ("I read that article and I worked on Apollo software, here's how it works!" "Yeah, my experience in 2km hole drilling is different...", "CRISPR is great but here's the extremely obscure yet fascinating cutting edge biotechnology area I'm working on" etc), less so about common sense exchange :-)

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by cesarb on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:18AM (#33742583)
> how is Apple ever going to know what charger you used?

I don't know if they do it, but it's very easy to have a communication channel between the device and the charger. For instance, my Dell laptop knows whether it's being used with a 65W charger or with a 90W charger, even though the plug and the voltage is the same in both cases.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by wisnoskij on Friday November 25, 2022 @10:30AM (#33743246)
They dont need to know. Famously apple used to deny warranty claims if their moisture sensor tripped. All they will do if see if the internal PSU is melted and say you used a offbrand charger, and that is your fault.
Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by wisnoskij on Friday November 25, 2022 @10:28AM (#33743226)
> And let's keep in mind, the entire purpose of a standard USB-C port is that you can use any charger.

That does not seem to be true. The standard is a lot more complicated than it used to be, but even back with micro amount of amps a charger can push varied wildly, I have seem chargers that could not even push more than what a device uses while on.

But like I said, it is even more complicated now. The rPI4 at launch with the brand new usbc power supply system only worked with specific chargers not because of amp limits but because the usbc spec.

Also this is ignoring the elephant in the room of the serious threat of cheap poorly made chargers that fry devices. Apple will not replace your device, or your house, if you buy some 10c charger from alibaba that catches fire the second you plug it in.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by marcosdumay on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:11AM (#33742519)
Are you claiming that the warranty doesn't have this condition?

Because yes, there is an entire level of bullshit on the requirement (the Brazilian Law also forbids that kind of bullshit), but if Apple claims that the charger is a requirement, how can they come and claim it's optional for the intent of not giving you one?

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by MerelyMortal on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:11AM (#33742520)
No, your assertion is not a logical deduction from the text you quoted.

The first paragraph does not list any consequenses for not using Apple accessories.

The second paragraph says that non-Apple accessories *MAY* damage the phone, and that specific damage is not covered under warranty.

Just be aware that in the U.S., the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act requires Apple to *prove* that you caused specific damage before they can deny the warranty coverage for that specific issue.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by twawaaay on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:44AM (#33742798)
> The second paragraph says that non-Apple accessories MAY damage the phone, and that specific damage is not covered under warranty.

I would hazard a guess that great majority of people in Brazil do not have either technical or legal knowledge to understand this. Or ability to read specifications and documentation with understanding.

They see officially and seriously sounding warning from Apple and they feel the have to go buy a charger and a cable or loose warranty.

> Just be aware that in the U.S., the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act requires Apple (...)

Except we are talking Brazil, not US.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by MerelyMortal on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:51AM (#33742870)
Are you a Brazilian speaking for a culture you

> we are talking Brazil, not US

I'm aware, that's why I stated "in the U.S.". I added parenthesis to help avoid further confusion.

> great majority of people in Brazil do not have either technical or legal knowledge to understand this

Are you a Brazilian speaking for a culture you are a part of?

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by ajdude on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:57AM (#33742933)
I just bought an iPhone yesterday, and the charger no longer comes with a standard USB A port. It comes with a lightning-to-usbC cable, which it suggests I plug into my MacBook to charge. I do not have a USB-C outlet, so I either need to get a USB A to USB C adapter or a USB-C charger port if I want to plug my phone into the wall.
Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by vinay427 on Friday November 25, 2022 @11:36AM (#33744056)
Yes, and this sounds completely compatible with the GP comment. USB C (PD) charging is the non-proprietary standard that virtually every modern smartphone uses.
Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by cassianoleal on Friday November 25, 2022 @08:49AM (#33742328)
> to make things worse, Apple has a proprietary charger

This is incorrect. Lightning is only used on the phone's end of the cable. The other end, which connects to the actual charger, is USB-C. This cable is included with the phone.

What the judges are saying is that they not only need to include the cable, but also the actual charger, which in this case is in fact USB-C.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by twawaaay on Friday November 25, 2022 @08:56AM (#33742389)
Apple requires that you use Apple-made or Apple-certified charger and reserves the right to void warranty if you do not.
Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by sorenjan on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:15AM (#33742554)
They seem to be ok with any USB PD capable charger.

> Fast charging works when you use an Apple USB-C to Lightning cable and one of these adapters:

> Apple 18W, 20W,2 29W, 30W, 35W, 61W, 67W, 87W, or 96W, or 140W USB-C Power Adapter

> A comparable third-party USB-C power adapter that supports USB Power Delivery (USB-PD)

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208137

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by twawaaay on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:34AM (#33742704)
Most people do not understand ANYTHING about charging standards. They only know that some chargers in they possession seem to be charging some of the devices quickly and some not.
Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by cassianoleal on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:00AM (#33742424)
Do you have a source for that?

I've found some references to potentially voiding the warranty by using a non-MFI cable. But again, the cable is included with the phone.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by philippejara on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:07AM (#33742487)
item c of "what is not covered by this warranty": https://www.apple.com/legal/warranty/products/ios-warranty-d...

Note that the same clause is present in the brazillian warranty.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by cassianoleal on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:13AM (#33742532)
> (c) to damage caused by use with a third party component or product that does not meet the Apple Product’s specifications (Apple Product specifications are available at www.apple.com under the technical specifications for each product and also available in stores)

This one? It doesn't say the charger needs to be certified, only that it needs to meet specifications, which can be found in the tech specs for each product.

The iPhone 14's specs [0] don't seem to mention any requirement for certifications.

I'm not saying you're necessarily wrong but so far I haven't found anything to support your claim. Could you please point me to where I can find the need for a certification?

[0] https://www.apple.com/iphone-14/specs/

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by philippejara on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:38AM (#33742745)
I didn't notice that detail, fair enough, however where are the charger specs on the linked page? can't find anything to compare. And the only spec for the charger I could find is wattage https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MHJA3AM/A/20w-usb-c-power....
Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by cassianoleal on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:47AM (#33742830)
I couldn't find any either. I assume this means any USB-C compatible charger is supported.

A sibling comment posted a link to a page talking about PD but that seems to be only a requirement for fast charging, not a hard requirement.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by twawaaay on Friday November 25, 2022 @08:52AM (#33742358)
I would add different countries set their protection laws largely independently, meaning the specific protections will be different.

US/EU are large enough so that our protection laws kinda become a possible standard for other countries and so we kinda got used to it actually being a standard.

Brazil has every right to set their own protection laws and in this case it absolutely does not seem to me it is in any way unreasonable.

At least not more unreasonable than US letting customers try stuff out and send it back for free which obviously is abused by large part of population and causes situations where people receive products that look suspiciously like they have already been opened and possibly even used by somebody previously.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by marcosdumay on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:14AM (#33742545)
Actually, this is copied almost verbatim from some EU countries. It's just that the EU market is different enough that the same law has different effects.
Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by crazygringo on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:02AM (#33742436)
So does this apply to AirPods as well? Because those aren't sold with a charger either, never have been.

My Apple Watch didn't either -- it comes with a charging puck that attached to a cable, but it doesn't come with a charger. Neither did my Magic Trackpad. Or Magic Keyboard.

Not including a charger is becoming more and more standard. I'm curious if Brazil is applying this law equally to all products that charge over USB, or if it's just selectively targeting flagship devices like iPhones?

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by marcosdumay on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:08AM (#33742497)
The law applies to every product. There is a decision to make over the charging medium details, but the one against iPhones apply to anything that charges over USB-C.

For other USB substandards, other rules may apply. The rules for USB-C also may change as the market matures.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by dakial1 on Friday November 25, 2022 @11:30AM (#33743972)
It applies. but I'm not sure if anyone is suing Apple over those or just the iPhones. Samsung was also fined earlier this year for the same reason.

But keep in mind that this is not "Brazil" targeting, someone needs to sue Apple in the court for this (the judge ruling and fine) to be applied. In this case it was a consumer association, that is getting some 10MM BRL (2MM USD) out of this (so this is probably the association interest, not consumer fairness), but it is in Apple best interest to respect the law and avoid professional litigators to go after them.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by vitorgrs on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @02:18AM (#33876783)
First people need to sue Apple for this. I guess no one is suing Apple over airpods.

Worth to remind that before going to court, there's consumer protection 'agency', known as PROCON, to resolve consumer issues before going to court.

This happened with Samsung. Samsung resolve the issue before going to court. They give a free charger if you ask for.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by jt2190 on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:03AM (#33742452)
“Venda Casasa” (Portuguese) https://pt.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venda_casada
Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by FoomFries on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:32AM (#33742682)
So you can’t sell a physical console game without the console? This seems to follow similar logic.
Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by kevincox on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:42AM (#33742778)
Also where does it end. Do they also need to provide you the wall outlet? And the wires to wire that outlet to your electrical panel?

It does seem that if it works with a standard USB or USB-C charger they should be fine not to include it to provide the consumer choice of what charger they want to use, be it Apple, third-party or an existing one that they had lying around.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by nzach on Friday November 25, 2022 @11:31AM (#33743977)
Not really. A game is content for your console, not a feature.

A better analogy would be selling a pre-assembled PC without an operating system. And this is illegal in Brazil, although this law isn't strictly enforced.

Re:Brazil seizes iPhones from stores due to free charger req... by dakial1 on Friday November 25, 2022 @12:21PM (#33744645)
The judge ruling is kind of a stretch of that law. Because it was first conceived to avoid forcing consumers to buy 2 items together (if you don't buy X I can't sell you Y), or putting quantity limitations (you can only buy 4 or more of X, otherwise I won't sell to you). Of course you can do promo combos (3 for the price of 2) but that shouldn't be the only option, the consumer needs to be able to buy the standalone product.