News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on Human-Level Play in Diplomacy Combining Language Models with Strategic Reasoning. Parent comment

Re:Human-Level Play in Diplomacy Combining Language Models w... by fddr on Tuesday November 22, 2022 @05:01PM (#33712164)
Do you actually think it would be a good thing if an IRB was required for this type of thing? Sure, it's "human experimentation" but the likelihood for any serious harm is basically zero.

It goes with the zeitgeist to argue for what makes the life of big tech companies hard, but they are big enough that they can afford things like that. It's smaller companies and academics that would end up not being able to innovate as much

Go down that road and you end up with an IRB evaluation requires for an A/B test that changes the color of a button

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Human-Level Play in Diplomacy Combining Language Models w... by andreyk on Tuesday November 22, 2022 @05:19PM (#33712367)
Agreed. This is using an AI to play a game, IRB seems like overkill. I guess the only potential problem is if it went off the rails and spouting toxic language, but that presumably was not a real possibility.
[ Parent | on HN ]