News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AWS and Blockchain by candiddevmike on Monday November 21, 2022 @08:00AM (#33692015)
What is the benefit of deploying something on a platform controlled by no one? Why not just run all of those things on a server you own?
Re:AWS and Blockchain by ChadNauseam on Monday November 21, 2022 @10:43AM (#33693796)
One benefit is that you can more credibly offer to keep your promises. I haven’t audited Uniswap’s smart contract code, but if I did I feel I could be pretty confident they won’t steal my money. Meanwhile, users of FTX depended on government regulation and pinky-swears to keep their money safe, but since SBF owned the platform he could do whatever he wanted.

disclosure: I work for a crypto company

Re:AWS and Blockchain by markdestouches on Monday November 21, 2022 @11:23AM (#33694312)
> One benefit is that you can more credibly offer to keep your promises.

We are yet to see a working example of that.

> Meanwhile, users of FTX depended on government regulation and pinky-swears to keep their money safe, but since SBF owned the platform he could do whatever he wanted.

These two sentences contradict each other. And no, there was no government regulation that insured FTX deposits. There was so little regulation, they didn't even keep their transaction history.

Re:AWS and Blockchain by ChadNauseam on Monday November 21, 2022 @01:32PM (#33696093)
> We are yet to see a working example of that.

I referenced Uniswap, which seems like it works to me

> These two sentences contradict each other. And no, there was no government regulation that insured FTX deposits. There was so little regulation, they didn't even keep their transaction history.

There's no public insurance for it, but if there were no regulations against doing what FTX did I'm not sure why their executives are fleeing the country

Re:AWS and Blockchain by habinero on Monday November 21, 2022 @02:47PM (#33696995)
Because "there are no regulations" is not permission to defraud others.
Re:AWS and Blockchain by ChadNauseam on Monday November 21, 2022 @04:03PM (#33697887)
The fact that fraud is a crime is a form of regulation, although it's clearly not sufficient on its own (just like how smart contract code being auditable isn't sufficient on its own)
Re:AWS and Blockchain by habinero on Monday November 21, 2022 @04:27PM (#33698198)
Sure, but it's not specific. I'm thinking more along the lines of requiring public SEC filings or prospectuses.
Re:AWS and Blockchain by markdestouches on Monday November 21, 2022 @09:08PM (#33700901)
Then you are arguing for allowing fraud and crime.
Re:AWS and Blockchain by oblio on Tuesday November 22, 2022 @04:57AM (#33703996)
Yeah, but if they're not personally affected, it's fine.

People who are affected are just dumb or they had it coming, anyway.

Re:AWS and Blockchain by dmitriid on Tuesday November 22, 2022 @12:17PM (#33708194)
> I haven’t audited Uniswap’s smart contract code, but if I did I feel I could be pretty confident they won’t steal my money.

Funny how there now have been multiple contracts which successfully passed multiple audits, have survived bug bounties, and still had errors in them.

But sure, do tell me how you can audit and instantly spot all the issues in a smart contract.

> users of FTX depended on government regulation and pinky-swears to keep their money safe, but since SBF owned the platform he could do whatever he wanted.

FTX was deliberately set up ouside of government regulation, and with no oversight.