Re:The Zelda Test (or Why no Zelda Clones?)
by sage_joch on Monday December 19, 2011 @03:23AM
(#3368956)
As an aside, I could never understand why A Link to the Past was consistently ranked higher than Secret of Mana in gaming magazines, top 100 lists, etc. Secret of Mana seemed vastly superior in almost every way.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Zelda Test (or Why no Zelda Clones?)
by epaga on Monday December 19, 2011 @03:49AM
(#3369005)
My 6 year old son just played through it on our Wii and I was reminded how awesome Secret of Mana is. I started a new game myself and was sucked in instantly.
Excellent game.
Re:The Zelda Test (or Why no Zelda Clones?)
by impendia on Monday December 19, 2011 @08:10AM
(#3369489)
I enjoyed Secret of Mana a lot, but,
(1) the combat was unsophisticated, for the most part you kind of button mashed;
(2) the magic spells mostly all did the same thing;
(3) the world didn't have a lot of topography, and mostly you used the cannons to jump from one area to another;
(4) there were not a lot of puzzles in the dungeons, and those that existed were not as sophisticated as in Zelda.
I admired SOM for its lush visuals, dazzling soundtrack, expansive world, and compelling story. But to me it did not have the feeling of getting the small details right. Zelda, in contrast, was pitch-perfect on the small scale (IMHO).