News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by Dah00n on Sunday November 20, 2022 @02:29PM (#33684329)
That wasn't necessary.
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by doublerabbit on Sunday November 20, 2022 @02:36PM (#33684435)
Where's the streaming media?
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by jenscow on Sunday November 20, 2022 @02:46PM (#33684537)
Not on IRC. Some would call that a feature.
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by Gigachad on Sunday November 20, 2022 @06:05PM (#33686500)
This goes back to the previous comment. IRC users and other IM users are in different universes now. Stuff that is considered core functionality like push notifications, embedded images and videos is probably never going to work in IRC.
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by superkuh on Sunday November 20, 2022 @08:12PM (#33687490)
People who use IRC see it as the text communication component of the platform that is the internet. When we need to do media we use the appropriate protocol and simply paste an address in chat (or DCC send it). Building everything into one protocol is just asking for problems (both legal and social).
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by u801e on Sunday November 20, 2022 @11:01PM (#33688581)
> Building everything into one protocol is just asking for problems (both legal and social).

That's what's been happening with HTTP. Now browsers are bloated and take a lot of system resources to run.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by throwawaylinux on Sunday November 20, 2022 @09:26PM (#33687946)
All incoming IRC messages are like push notifications aren't they? Or do I have my webology terms confused? IRC clients can certainly pop up a notification or make a sound or blink an icon when they encounter certain messages (e.g., your nick is mentioned), if push notification now means a more intrusive type of alert.
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by Gigachad on Sunday November 20, 2022 @10:43PM (#33688473)
Push notifications are a specific thing where your OS can briefly wake up, check for notifications for all services, and then sleep again. It’s how you can have 10 IM apps but still be notified of messages on all of them despite none of the apps actually running unless they are actively on the screen.

IRC is unable to do this because it requires a constant active connection which is something that was fine in the desktop era but is not usable on battery powered devices.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by aidenn0 on Monday November 21, 2022 @12:33AM (#33689168)
Constant TCP connections work great on Android as long as there is no traffic.

Conversations.im works this way and has minimal battery impact. iOS doesn't allow this, because it's easy to get wrong.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by throwawaylinux on Monday November 21, 2022 @02:14AM (#33689754)
> Push notifications are a specific thing where your OS can briefly wake up, check for notifications for all services, and then sleep again. It’s how you can have 10 IM apps but still be notified of messages on all of them despite none of the apps actually running unless they are actively on the screen.

Ah, I didn't know that's what push notifications were. Sounds like a regular old pull aka refresh but I have no idea about web stuff.

> IRC is unable to do this because it requires a constant active connection which is something that was fine in the desktop era but is not usable on battery powered devices.

I think at the scale which devices are already waking up to check things, it's unlikely to be a problem for most. Phones don't actually sleep for hours (or probably even minutes.

That said, IRC's heavyweight connection does seem clunky, if your connection drops momentarily it's unlikely you wanted to lose track of conversations you were currently participating in. Although that can be solved with logs / archives pulling what you missed, it seems better solved at a core level (maybe it is, I haven't looked at IRC for a decade or more).

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by _flux on Monday November 21, 2022 @03:03AM (#33690049)
In particular frequent disconnect/reconnects seem to cause stress to others in IRC, sometimes even resulting in bans, when it ultimately just shouldn't matter.
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by Gigachad on Monday November 21, 2022 @03:41AM (#33690290)
I remember my irc bouncer broke once and I had received a network ban for join/quit spam.
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by Springtime on Monday November 21, 2022 @02:41AM (#33689927)
Textual (macOS client) has had both image and video inline embedding since at least 2014 (in fact it was ironically used for the longest time as the main client of the dev behind Hexchat, another IRC client). KiwiIRC (web client) also has embeds IIRC.
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by gsich on Sunday November 20, 2022 @02:54PM (#33684611)
Links work.
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by doublerabbit on Sunday November 20, 2022 @03:01PM (#33684680)
not without ssl
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by cassianoleal on Sunday November 20, 2022 @03:30PM (#33684930)
What does this even mean? If a link has TLS, it will have TLS. If it doesn't, it won't. Like anything on the web.
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by doublerabbit on Sunday November 20, 2022 @04:28PM (#33685536)
If I have a website that does not require SSL, I don't need an SSL cert. I don't need a screaming firefox window blaring "ThIs SiTe MaY Be InSecUrE" because IRC back in the days you shared links without https. Why does a .jpg need SSL?

IRC is a dead feature. Until someone creates a drag-dropable image uploader to the client, IRC is dead. You can add as many features as you wish to the server, but without a client, there is no connection to hyperspace.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by kelnos on Sunday November 20, 2022 @04:34PM (#33685612)
> IRC is a dead feature.

I think all the people who use IRC daily would disagree with you on that.

I do agree that IRC is stuck in the dark ages when it comes to feature support, and even just features in the spec. I dislike Slack, but whenever I use Slack for a while, and then switch to IRC for something else, I miss seemingly-simple things like being able to easily share images, react to messages with emoji, start subthreads in messages (a feature of Slack's I initially hated, but eventually came to appreciate).

I get that it's difficult to add these sorts of things to IRC in a reasonable way, especially when we're talking about degrading gracefully for clients that don't support newer features. But IRC is pretty much the definition of an open, federated protocol failing to avoid ossification.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by doublerabbit on Sunday November 20, 2022 @05:22PM (#33686103)
> I think all the people who use IRC daily would disagree with you on that.

What people? I've used IRC for the past 15 years. It is dead. I was the generation to make it alive. You have stale, and chaos. It's old, musky and old.

I have no issue with IRC its a robust, reliable protocol. But it's just stale. Its old. "We will invent this" where is it?

Who recently has made an attempt at a half-good browser?

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by 6510 on Sunday November 20, 2022 @06:31PM (#33686712)
You are right and you should fix it.
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by doublerabbit on Sunday November 20, 2022 @07:05PM (#33687002)
i'll add it to my todo pile
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by palata on Sunday November 20, 2022 @07:39PM (#33687248)
Actually I used Matrix for 2 years and went back to IRC recently when I realised that the really cool channels I cared about where on IRC. A few are on Discord (which I really don't like). To me, Matrix seems to be in the middle, and I don't find anyone there.
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by progval on Sunday November 20, 2022 @05:27PM (#33686140)
> easily share images, react to messages with emoji, start subthreads in messages

You can do all this on IRCCloud (which is currently the only IRC client to support them, sadly). However, like you mentioned, other clients won't see reactions or threading.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by doix on Monday November 21, 2022 @01:12AM (#33689420)
> I do agree that IRC is stuck in the dark ages when it comes to feature support, and even just features in the spec. I dislike Slack, but whenever I use Slack for a while, and then switch to IRC for something else, I miss seemingly-simple things like being able to easily share images, react to messages with emoji, start subthreads in messages (a feature of Slack's I initially hated, but eventually came to appreciate).

I like that IRC doesn't have those things. IRC is great because most clients have very high information density. Look at this screenshot [0], look how many messages fit on the screen.

Compare that to something like slack. Every message has a bunch of upper and lower padding, an avatar, space for reactions etc. If someone links an image, it can use up half your screen to render it. If someone links something, suddenly there is a preview wasting space.

[0] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/98/XchatScr...

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by tpxl on Monday November 21, 2022 @07:49AM (#33691944)
> Compare that to something like slack. Every message has a bunch of upper and lower padding, an avatar, space for reactions etc. If someone links an image, it can use up half your screen to render it. If someone links something, suddenly there is a preview wasting space.

FWIW, slack and discord have 'compact' modes where information density is about the same as the screenshot you posted.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by gsich on Sunday November 20, 2022 @04:34PM (#33685609)
There is no such screaming window. Please test.
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by cassianoleal on Sunday November 20, 2022 @04:45PM (#33685737)
> I don't need a screaming firefox window blaring "ThIs SiTe MaY Be InSecUrE"

So your problem is with your own choice of browser? This is not related to IRC or web links.

> Until someone creates a drag-dropable image uploader to the client

Create one yourself, then? IDK, I don't feel the need for it. I use IRC with a web client and it satisfies my needs.

> IRC is dead.

It's definitely not dead. I use it daily, as do lots of other people. Just because it doesn't have certain features that you want, it doesn't mean it's dead. It just means it's not for you.

> there is no connection to hyperspace.

I think you're mistaking Star Wars for the Internet.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by doublerabbit on Sunday November 20, 2022 @05:21PM (#33686091)
> I think you're mistaking Star Wars for the Internet.

Never seen the movie. Take a joke.

> IRC is dead.

What Network #Channel have you been in that has active conversation? Please let me know the last 95% of channels are unattractive.

> Just because it doesn't have certain features that you want, it doesn't mean it's dead. It just means it's not for you.

You just don't get it.

> So your problem is with your own choice of browser? This is not related to IRC or web links.

No. My problem is how corporate entities are shoving web standards in to our faces and your too blind to care.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by cassianoleal on Sunday November 20, 2022 @05:40PM (#33686272)
> What Network #Channel have you been in that has active conversation?

Just a few examples. On Libera.chat:

#proxmox, #btrfs, #docker, #go-nuts, #homeassistant, #linux, #networking, #openwrt, others

On OFTC:

#asahi and its ancillary -dev and -gpu, #openwrt, #turris, ...

I also have friends who I talk to in servers and channels outside of these.

> You just don't get it.

I don't get what? Your arguments are all over the place, it's kinda funny really...

> My problem is how corporate entities are shoving web standards in to our faces and your too blind to care.

You were complaining about Firefox's dislike of websites without TLS. This has nothing to do with IRC, which is what this whole discussion is about.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by doublerabbit on Sunday November 20, 2022 @07:03PM (#33686983)
> You just don't get it.

Your missing the point on the fact that IRC is all text. All you could ever do send links. It worked but sucks from now future on.

Nowadays where do you host those links? Github? Sure. But the FAFF of setting up a github static wank account. find some lets encrypt cert bot owned by google which expires every six months. Your going to do all that for one IRC Link?

In the days before tumblr, the simple days of MSN/Yaho. When IRC was active and flourishing. You could just send a link from your own server, a server in your bedroom. Sitting on your home 56k IP on a http server without needing any cert, any annoying messages, cookie banners to a user.

Those days are over. I know, but it hasn't gotten easier. IRC it's sitting right there, the diamond.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by cassianoleal on Sunday November 20, 2022 @07:34PM (#33687211)
You really lost me, mate. You sound like "old man yells at cloud".

Just in case you didn't get the reference, here's a link you can easily share on IRC: https://i.kym-cdn.com/news_feeds/icons/mobile/000/019/234/3a...

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by doublerabbit on Monday November 21, 2022 @08:15AM (#33692121)
Exactly. You just don't get it.

never mind, you'll feel it one day.

Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by gsich on Sunday November 20, 2022 @07:40PM (#33687258)
There is no need for TLS if you don't want it. Firefox and Chrome don't show a nagging window if your stuff is only reachable via HTTP. Have you even tried that?
Re:IRCv3 2022 Spec round-up by kuroguro on Sunday November 20, 2022 @03:00PM (#33684672)
HN is also text only and it's the way I like it.