Re:Ask HN: Is this iPhone app too trivial/commonplace to pro...
by KevinMS on Saturday December 17, 2011 @01:08PM
(#3364699)
Thats interesting. My first 4 or 5 attemps had a checked item disappear (actually animated it to go back to the main list). Then I found myself accidentally checking items off by mistake and being annoyed I couldn't recheck them easily. So I decided since my lists were always short, I would just grey them out so the unchecked ones would stand out. At least thats my reasoning at the time.
Oh, and as a compromise, to remove checked items from the list, you just cycle the list button, and that cleans up the list, so I was hoping you'd get the best of both features. 1. A less twitchy list. 2. The ability to clean up the list.
I see elsewhere in this thread that you present a use case -- make that clearer.
It was surprising to me that the ONE thing this had the potential to offer over pen and paper isn't a feature -- the thing I hate about pen and paper is that when I scratch out something I've put in the cart, it doesn't go away.
See tadalist for what I mean -- when I check something, it is grayed out AND pushed to the bottom of the list. This is a huge feature that I think you're missing (for me at least).