Re:The good delusion: has effective altruism broken bad?
by nl on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @01:25AM
(#33619600)
> EA now has a significant contingent that is most focused on very unlikely far future outcomes because they would be incredibly bad for an unimaginably vast number of people if they did occur eg unbounded utility. That's pascal's mugging!
Indeed! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pascal%27s_mugging
(Although the term itself comes from the EA community)
Re:The good delusion: has effective altruism broken bad?
by UniverseHacker on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:38PM
(#33629284)
I am very confused about why the rationalist's, who first identified the concept of pascal's mugging seem to have a huge number of initiatives which seem to be examples of falling directly into the pascal's mugging trap.
With all of these examples, and pascal's mugging itself, there is an obvious error: there should be a practical upper bound on the adverse outcome you're concerned about, at which all higher values are effectively the same to you.
Re:The good delusion: has effective altruism broken bad?
by cscurmudgeon on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @03:29PM
(#33630052)
> I am very confused about why the rationalists, who first identified the concept of pascal's mugging seem to have a huge number of initiatives which seem to be examples of falling directly into the pascal's mugging trap.
The original rationalists were true rationalist. And the recent ones? I am not so sure.
The movement is based on the same ideas and values and it's running into the same problems. These similarities don't inherently discredit the movement, but not having a clear awareness of these faults in their framework and a plan for avoiding them is very worrying.