News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by marshray on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @02:07PM (#33613488)
There really is very, very little carbon in the atmosphere, famously ~410 ppm. (Yes, that little bit is enough to absorb significantly more heat from the sun).

So, whatever capture system you use, you'd need to move a lot of air through in order to produce a small amount of something like liquid hydrocarbon fuel.

It will require thousands of times more air, by mass. Since the output fuel product is hundreds of times more dense, it would require a crazy large volume of air to extract the carbon necessary to fill a fuel tank.

A corn field combined with a methanol fermentation and distillation facility is an example of a machine that does that. Very large.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by PaulHoule on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @02:39PM (#33613930)
The advantage of attempting it mechanically is that you might use less water and less fixed nitrogen. Water consumption is directly linked to how plants absorb CO₂ from the atmosphere, see https://ripe.illinois.edu/blog/difference-between-c3-and-c4-...
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by photochemsyn on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:35PM (#33614662)
Plants pull 100 gigatons of carbon out of the atmosphere every year and convert it to biomass (essentially, oxy-ammonia-hydrocarbons like sugars, proteins, fats, etc.). Humans pull about 6 gigatons of carbon out of the ground each year and pump it into the atmosphere.

The reason this cycle doesn't exhaust the atmospheric pool, of course, is that animals and fungi (more the latter) break down biomass into CO2 and release it back into the atmosphere.

That's not what I'd call 'very very little carbon'.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by lazide on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:51PM (#33614847)
On a planetary atmosphere level? It’s still tiny.

Literally .0441%

Getting anything at that concentration out is… generally not easy.

Doable! But not easy.

That it’s chemically low reactivity makes it even harder.

Plants have spent billions of years evolving to do it, and from an energy perspective aren’t very efficient at it.

Unless we want to burn even more oil trying to power the process or just make a tiny dent in it, we’ll need to not only figure out a somewhat efficient way to do it, but also figure out how to generate a massive amount of power without burning oil to power it.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by ravenstine on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:58PM (#33614929)
For even more perspective, human breath can be easily composed of somewhere between 20,000 ppm and 40,000 ppm, and tens of thousands greater than that with enough energy expenditure. (I know this because I've actually measured this myself with research grade NDIR CO2 sensors)

441 ppm can be "a lot" depending on the gas and the expected effect. You don't want to breathe in 441 ppm of chlorine gas. But CO2 being fairly non-reactive makes 441 ppm of it relatively minuscule in contrast to the other predominant atmospheric gases. It's also nowhere near enough to cause outright catastrophe.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by pencilguin on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:33PM (#33615332)
441 ppm CO2 turns out to be quite close to enough to cause global catastrophe.
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by lazide on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:39PM (#33615415)
Eventually. But no one is going to keel over dead due to suffocation today because of global CO2 concentration, which is ‘outright’.

Pretty sure global minimum temperatures above 100F would also count as ‘outright’.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by pencilguin on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @05:26PM (#33615995)
There are already places where being without a cooling method other than sweating would be fatal, at least one day of the year.

In many more places, crops are failing.

People necessarily leaving these places will need to go where other people already are.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by lazide on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:46PM (#33617392)
That happened before too, and has been (at lower frequency) for all of recorded history, near as we can tell. As noted, not an outright catastrophe right now.

The discussion is about avoiding it becoming one, and relative impacts. Humanity isn’t going to be dead tomorrow because of this, but may be in more pain in a decade or two, and longer term even more so.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by pencilguin on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:29PM (#33617700)
Regional collapses have happened. This will be the first global collapse.

If it happens, it will be much earlier than you hope, as millions, then tens of millions, then hundreds of millions force their way across borders, and fascist governments ride that into power and then start a global thermonuclear war. The refugees will only be fleeing crop failure and increasingly murderous kleptocratic government.

It is already starting. Lots of governments are flirting with dictatorship, and many have got there already. US and Brazil have drawn back a hairspreadth from the brink, but for how long?

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by lazide on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:27PM (#33618081)
You might want to slow down and breath a little.
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by TedDoesntTalk on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @12:22AM (#33619245)
I favorited that comment. When I feel anxious about something, I’ll read it again and realize anxiety can always be worse.
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by sooyoo on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:22AM (#33619967)
Just like the people who were entering the Capitol about 20 months ago.
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by pencilguin on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @09:27AM (#33623483)
It is a fact that almost half the US voting population is ready and willing to vote in somebody who would arrange never to leave office. Numerous billionaires support that outcome.
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by lazide on Friday November 18, 2022 @03:42PM (#33661811)
I'm not saying that you're wrong (or right). There is a LOT of scary stuff going on right now, for a lot of people.

I'm just asking you to slow down a bit, and take care of how you are now.

Otherwise, you'll never get to the point of any of the other stuff mattering anyway - and likely make it a lot worse for yourself in the meantime.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by ravenstine on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @11:41AM (#33626046)
Really? Thanks an amazing claim! I'm sure you can provide us some evidence to support this.
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by Schroedingersat on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:28PM (#33617693)
Multiple Megatonnes of many different materials are mined at much lower concentration, and that requires digging up rocks. CO2 has many properties that make it fairly easy to select for.

We've already figured out that last part, it's called putting a few tens of square km of solar panels and heliostats (don't need it all to be electricity) in egypt or bolivia. A square metre nets you enough energy for several tonnes per month.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by lazide on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:50PM (#33618214)
Sounds easy and we’ve got it all worked out at scale. Problem solved then?
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by Schroedingersat on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:55PM (#33618241)
Maybe. Just maybe there's a middle ground between something being unfathomably difficult and impossible because big number bad, and being trivial?

There are lots of potential avenues for stuffing the genie back in the bottle with a small fraction of the energy we got out of releasing it. All that's lacking is the political will to hold the fossil fuel industry accountable, stop them doing more damage, and confiscate the proceeds of their crimes to start undoing the damage.

This last part isn't helped by reactionaries constantly screaming 'big number mean impossible' and 'der entropy'. Almost as if the goal of such discourse is to prevent solutions.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by lazide on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:08PM (#33618333)
Who are you talking to exactly?

I never said anything of the sort, nor did anyone else near as I can tell?

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by Schroedingersat on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:22PM (#33618420)
You were concern trolling to try to shit on the best plan we have for a planet that remains habitable by vaguely gesturing about how hard it is with no context.

Then you sullenly implied I was saying it was trivial when I contextualised the actual scale involved.

This is part of the standard reactionary fud playbook.

Now you're playing the victim and trying to imply that's never what you meant.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by lazide on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:25PM (#33618832)
Literally completely false.

You might want to re-read the thread and actually follow the site rules this time?

Feel free to read my prior comments if you want to see how completely false your perception seems to be of my motivations too.

My point is this takes time and treasure, and it isn’t yet solved - and incremental improvement helps, because if we were to try to actually do things at scale with our current level of knowledge, we lack the infrastructure to do so without burning more oil.

Which will slowly change over the next couple decades and centuries, but not without a lot of fallout first due to the speed of change.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by Schroedingersat on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @12:33AM (#33619298)
I looked at your previous comments and retract my accusation. Apologies.

Most of the time when someone mentions CO2 air concentration it's as a prelude to pushing CCS or some vague idea about producing 100s of kW of energy per person using nuclear abundanceand I pattern matched a little preemptively.

This doesn't excuse your rhetoric about it not being urgent though. The damage may take effect later, but it is being done right now.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by lazide on Friday November 18, 2022 @12:17PM (#33658001)
Thanks for acknowledging that, it isn’t easy.

You might want to recheck again though on that urgency claim. I never said that either.

To recap some discussions in other threads, what I’m pointing out is due to the sheer size of the problem, this will take decades to centuries to get under control (if the models are right, barring some truly revolutionary technology), no matter what.

Depending on the level of force used, it can and likely will lead to large scale war, which burns even more oil based on the way military operations are run now (and for the foreseeable future).

Even if we did things at the urgency level of the Manhattan project with infinite resources - unless we burned more oil. Even then, probably.

This is a heavily overloaded train that has been building up speed for 150+ years.

As to if any individual should be panicking or calm about this is up to them, but I personally find panic to put someone in a place where they are easily misled and results in bad and poorly thought out decisions which can often make it worse.

Which tends to be why folks go to fascism when they’re overloaded and scared, IMO.

As to if this discussion is useful or not? I don’t know. But I figured I’d throw it out there.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by ravenstine on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:52PM (#33614864)
You mean ethanol, right? I don't think it's produced by fermentation, at least not without a secondary process that removes the other hydrocarbon.

That aside, yes, plant biomass to alcohol is a carbon-neutral tech that has already existed for a really long time. Let plants take carbon out of the atmosphere, ferment the starches and sugars into fuel alcohol, feed the remaining cellulose to animals, burn the fuel, eat the animals, and return most (but not all!) of the carbon back to where it came from. It's really an incredible process, but obviously its existence is a threat to the oil industry. If you've ever noticed the propaganda that ethanol is bad for engines and worse for the environment, well, just follow the money.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by pencilguin on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:27PM (#33615264)
It takes a very great deal of hydrocarbon fuel to produce the ethanol going into our engines. When EVs displace gasohol-burning cars, the ag production, 30% of the maize crop, can go back to feeding people (or, more likely, feeding chickens); and we may hope the fuel used will be synthetics from atmospheric feedstocks.

Brazil's sugar cane operations seem to produce more fuel than the process consumes.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by marshray on Thursday November 17, 2022 @03:14PM (#33644963)
D'oh! Yes, ethanol. Thanks for the correction!
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by nine_k on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @05:37PM (#33616160)
But there are CO₂-rich exhausts in chemical plants and power plants, with concentrations well above 50%. This is where the capture could work efficiently. These likely produce a sizable portion of the carbon dioxide surplus.

Capturing carbon from a jet engine will remain problematic, or slow. Maybe we should just grow more trees, extract solid carbon from them (by burning or otherwise), and bury it in old coal mines.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by lazide on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:41PM (#33617365)
Even more efficient than carbon capture from power plant exhaust?

not pulling the carbon out of the ground and burning it

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by nine_k on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:58PM (#33618268)
You have to do something to the existing power plants, before you build out enough solar, wind, batteries, and nuclear. It capture is cheaper then rebuilding the plant, it may make sense to run it until the end of its planned service life.

Certain things produce CO₂ as a part of non-power-generating chemical processes, like steelmaking, or producing cement for concrete. If the CO₂ can be captured economically, it would be a great win; there are few known remotely viable alternatives.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by Schroedingersat on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @12:30AM (#33619284)
You're forgetting all the lifecycle emissions and the whole 'if capture is cheaper' part given that running a coal plant without CCS is more expensive than replacing it with new solar panels in many areas already.
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by rbanffy on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @05:52AM (#33621224)
> It makes zero sense economically to expend a huge amount of energy to pull the carbon out of power plant exhaust and do something with it, when we can generate the energy without releasing the co2 in the first place.

It kind of makes sense, if energy is cheap enough. If we have surplus energy, we can remove enough CO2 from the atmosphere to stop or even revert climate change. If we can desalinate water with that surplus energy, we can even use that extracted carbon to increase the amount of biomass on the surface.

Both climate change and fresh water supply are solvable with abundant cheap energy.

Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by machina_ex_deus on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:45PM (#33616872)
This comment is inaccurate, the way CO2 traps heat isn't from the sun, but the thermal black body radiation from the surface.
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by marshray on Thursday November 17, 2022 @03:15PM (#33644980)
Do you have a link to something where I can read more about this?
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by __MatrixMan__ on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:59PM (#33617496)
Home furnaces burn a lot of natural gas and put the water in the sewer and the CO2 in the air. I wonder how much tweaking the sewer system would need to start acting as a CO2 return system also. If it were a closed loop system you could at least be carbon neutral, and stockpiling methane for the winter is easier than stockpiling electricity.
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by stephen_g on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:05PM (#33617911)
I think the upgrade to far, far more efficient heat pumps would be small compared to the cost of that...
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by _hypx on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:03PM (#33618689)
Direct carbon capture makes sense whenever you have a high concentration of CO₂ emissions. The most obvious are cases where you can get pure carbon, not CO₂. Other times, it might be also worth capturing the CO₂ from something burning. Direct carbon capture from the air will probably be the most expensive solution, but it is still doable. You figure that eventually it will be subsidized.
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by puffoflogic on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @01:52AM (#33619786)
The other problem with carbon capture (if you could overcome the low concentration issue somehow) is that the result of the tragedy of the commons isn't just "oops the temperature went up by 2°", it's "oops we killed off all plant life on Earth simultaneously and now nearly every living thing on Earth will be dead within a few years".
Re:Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen more efficie... by marshray on Thursday November 17, 2022 @03:18PM (#33645018)
It took centuries to increase atmospheric CO2 to problematic level.

If we are so lucky as to have to worry about overcorrection, I'm confident we'll be able to find the 'off' switch to whatever solution in time.