Re:The Rise of Influencer Capital
by nonrandomstring on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @01:41PM
(#33613173)
It took me a while reflecting on engineering and design practice to
come around to understanding planned obsolescence as a potentially
positive thing.
Imagine designing a very high quality metal chain. However, some of
the links need to be made of an inferior strength plastic, perhaps to
stop them corroding. It's therefore not worth designing the rest of
the chain to a higher tensile quality than the weakest links. To do so
would actually be very wasteful.
One must distinguish genuine design efficiency, which is a kind of
designed obsolescence, from strategic sabotage. That's what most
digital goods contain; remote kill switches, countdown timers,
deliberate weak fuses, remote updates that remove features, embedded
DRM and all manner of user-hostile shitfuckery that amounts to no more
than vandalism.
Imagine designing a very high quality metal chain. However, some of the links need to be made of an inferior strength plastic, perhaps to stop them corroding. It's therefore not worth designing the rest of the chain to a higher tensile quality than the weakest links. To do so would actually be very wasteful.
One must distinguish genuine design efficiency, which is a kind of designed obsolescence, from strategic sabotage. That's what most digital goods contain; remote kill switches, countdown timers, deliberate weak fuses, remote updates that remove features, embedded DRM and all manner of user-hostile shitfuckery that amounts to no more than vandalism.