News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by notch656a on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:55AM (#33611711)
The headline is a pre-supposing statement, that relies on a false notion that people are all using bitcoin as an 'investment' rather than for other reasons such as a currency. Only a fool is using most currencies as an investment, except perhaps as part of some hedging scheme.

Bitcoin as represented in the white paper was never portrayed as an investment vehicle.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by SR2Z on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:01PM (#33611805)
The overwhelming majority of people with Bitcoin are speculators.

It's fairly useless as far as currencies go. It literally fails at the first requirement: it's not a reliable store of value.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by klyrs on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:36PM (#33612371)
That isn't the first requirement. The first requirement for a currency is that you should be able to spend it without a ton of friction. Whatever bitcoin is, it can't do that.

But yeah, it also has the problem where if you go to a store, find out that it's cash only, walk to an ATM to take out enough to cover a transaction, only to discover that your cash has undergone a flash crash and isn't enough to cover the cost by the time you get back to the store.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by jeffbee on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:18PM (#33612083)
That's the first requirement of currency? I feel like you might have made that up. It seems to me that the general character of a currency is that it is a widely-accepted medium of exchange. There are loads of currencies around the world that serve their purpose without being an even slightly good store of value. The Turkish Lira, for example, has lost 90% of its value against the Dollar in 15 years, yet it is still the going currency in that country.

Edit: after reading my comment I realized it might not be clear that bitcoin is astonishingly bad at imitating currency. Almost without exception trading it for goods and services is impossible.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by samatman on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:27PM (#33612246)
I like to say a currency: should be a store of value, could be a unit of account, and must be a medium of exchange.
Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by notch656a on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:07PM (#33611893)
For most cases I would not consider it the best option. However I have used bitcoin codebase based coins for transactions where the time-span was short enough that it was a reliable store of value. Reliable store of value really depends on how long you intend to hold it. Dollars are a terrible store of value over 100 years and decent over 2 years. Several crypto coins are a bad store of value over 1 week but a decent one over a couple hours.

There are certain circumstances where I think it may make sense for someone to pick an alternative currency; I'm not arguing it is superior to the rest of them.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by danans on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:21PM (#33612147)
> However I have used bitcoin codebase based coins for transactions where the time-span was short enough that it was a reliable store of value.

> Several crypto coins are a bad store of value over 1 week but a decent one over a couple hours.

What kind of (real world) transaction would need to rely on a cryptocurrency for value stability over a couple of hours time-span that wouldn't be served by fiat currency, which provides the same stability guarantees over that same time-span?

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by toqy on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:58PM (#33612640)
Buying drugs and other illegal things online
Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @01:07PM (#33612758)
International transfer is a good use, as is irrevocable payment for purchased goods.

There is also a strong real world value in countries where local currency is less stable and secure than crypto. Not all places have access to USD or foreign currency.

There are interesting examples coming out of Argentina. Imagine living in a country where year over year inflation is ~100% and the government may periodically seize assets in your bank account.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by bentcorner on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @02:21PM (#33613662)
> International transfer is a good use

I think it could make a useful underlying tool to enable this but to be used directly by end user customers it'd be a tough sell.

I've used Wise to transfer USD <-> CAD, if they use crypto to enable that (I don't think they do, but I guess they could), I couldn't really care less.

I don't think your run of the mill consumer is going to want to use crypto to do the same thing. With smaller amounts the difference in cost is probably negligible, with larger amounts you could theoretically save more to make the effort worth it, but you have higher pressure to have more "traditional" assurances that nothing goes wrong.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by danans on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:07PM (#33614301)
> International transfer is a good use, as is irrevocable payment for purchased goods.

In what ways do cash bank transfers not work for international transfers or irrevocable payments?

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:25PM (#33614531)
International wire transfers can take 1 to 5 days, and Banks can seize or reverse the funds.
Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by danans on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:13PM (#33615096)
> and Banks can seize or reverse the funds.

Why would they do that? I've never had that happen to me when I send an international transfer.

But it's always been for innocuous things like "reimburse relative for vacation rental expenses"

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by notch656a on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:30PM (#33615307)
I had a domestic wire temporarily seized for 2 days because a bank wanted to KYC me a second time, even though I'd already KYC to open the account.

Yes I was made whole but it was unpleasant and I happily would have eaten the ~.30 of litecoin transaction fees and 0.1% crypto exchange fee to avoid that. Not to mention the wire cost me $15 in the first place and not everyone has ready access to a bank with free wires.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @05:08PM (#33615748)
I had a 100k wire held for 30+days. It was in the middle of escrow and I had to borrow 100k so that the purchase didn't fall apart.
Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by danans on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:57PM (#33616992)
> I had a 100k wire held for 30+days.

Depending on which country it is going to, that seems like an amount large enough to legitimately trip over some checks. In the US itself, last I heard all domestic transfers over 10k get reported.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:25PM (#33617232)
I dont particularly care about what is reported. What I care about is being able to move my money when I need to. In this specific instance, it was a domestic transfer.

Getting locked out of your own money can cause major damage. I'm lucky that I was able to dig up another 100k. Someone else could have lost their 50k and be liable for hundreds of thousands more in liability to the seller.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by notch656a on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:27PM (#33614550)
Something like Wise works most of the time but if you have a cousin in Papau New Guinea in the jungle with a cellphone and no bank account IDK how the hell you would send them large value in under an hour without losing your shirt. Maybe there is something and if so I'm interested in what it is (know someone else there with lots of money who really trusts you?).

In any case ACH can be clawed back and it is my understanding in some exceptional circumstance a wire can too. The point never was crypto is always superior, it may be conventional is better 99.9% of the time but that 0.1% means a use case remains.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by lrvick on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @02:49PM (#33614064)
I use Bitcoin as a currency all the time. It is cash for the internet. If used correctly, it is the only reliable way to buy things online without giving a central company like Visa or Mastercard a log of everything you buy and where you buy it.

If you dollar cost average your acquisition of Bitcoin it smooths out the conversion risk and if anything the value against USD goes reliably up over a 3+ year window.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by lupire on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @05:57PM (#33616381)
Currencies, as the name hints, are used to transmit value, not hold it beyond the short term.
Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by highwaylights on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:07PM (#33611904)
The great thing about Bitcoin is that it’s whatever the holder wants it to be, and nothing they don’t want it to be, while at the same time being the opposite of that to someone else, depending on what argument their trying to make and whether or not they’ve personally lost money.

Anytime someone speaks crypto to me now I feel like Adam Sandler floating past Clint Howard’s window in Little Nicky: I don’t want to be part of this, they don’t want me to be part of this, and all I can do is wish them luck while they tell me they don’t need it.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by thrwy_918 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:37PM (#33612382)
> The great thing about Bitcoin is that it’s whatever the holder wants it to be, and nothing they don’t want it to be

If someone bought Bitcoin a year ago and wanted it to be a store of value, it is certainly not "whatever the holder wants it to be" for that person

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by jpadkins on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @01:44PM (#33613210)
If someone bought US Dollars($) a year ago and wanted it to be a store of value, it is certainly not "whatever the holder wants it to be" for that person.

A lot of currencies are not a good store of value the last 18 months.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by vkou on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @02:12PM (#33613550)
Strange, US dollars seem to be as good at making both my mortgage payment, and paying my taxes this year as they were last.

They also seem to be a lot better at buying Bitcoin and Euros and S&P500, but a bit worse at buying lettuce.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by notch656a on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:09PM (#33611932)
I personally lost a couple dollars on litecoin but saved 10s of dollars in transaction fees by not using a credit card. So the fact I lost money, technically, doesn't mean I didn't come out ahead versus the alternatives.
Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by highwaylights on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:11PM (#33611974)
I had to work out in my head there how many transactions you’d need to make to have saved 10s of dollars on credit card fees, and then whether or not that was worth the hassle, let alone the loss of purchase protection.

It was not.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by tromp on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:00PM (#33611794)
The disinflationary emission set it up to be a speculation vehicle. For use as a currency, a fixed block subsidy, i.e. linear emission would have been far preferable.
Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by BoorishBears on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:38PM (#33612397)
> Only a fool is using most currencies as an investment, except perhaps as part of some hedging scheme.

Only a fool uses a currency that's experienced 5000% deflation?

Bitcoin is a long failed currency, I can't believe there are people still trying to push that notion.

Volatility is one thing, but deflation to a nonsensical degree means that using it as a way to pay for goods and services is heavily discouraged because of things like... having your $20 pizza be worth $165,000 if you had just not bought it.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by landemva on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:00PM (#33616427)
I have used btc as a hedge against my government and the uncontrolled judicial system, and it has been phenomenally successful. Not everyone lives an upper-middle class existence with good rule of law.
Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by BoorishBears on Saturday November 19, 2022 @04:47AM (#33668669)
So you used bitcoin for speculation.

You're making my point. It's not functioning as a currency anymore, it's an investment vehicle.

It'd be like if Forex was the main way that dollars got moved.

Re:Vast Majority of People Who Invest in Bitcoin Inevitably ... by aetherson on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @01:35PM (#33613094)
This is actually exactly backward. What the paper is trying to quantify is how many people are trying to use bitcoin as an investment, versus how many are trying to use it as a currency or other financial tool (the whole thing about how many of the investors are underwater is a small point of the paper that Gizmodo is fixating on because of Gizmodo's preexisting hatred of crypto).

What the paper finds (and we can certainly quibble with any paper) is evidence that the majority of people who bought Bitcoin in the 2015-2022 period did so in patterns that suggest that they're interested in an investment asset, not in a currency.