Apart from having insider knowledge in how cryptocurrency exchanges operate and their data, how could you possibly know this?
One address on the blockchain can belong to one or more users, just like one user can have one or more addresses on the blockchain, so being able to compare feels impossible even if you had insider knowledge/data.
Bitcoin on a centralized exchange cannot be traded for goods and services until explicitly withdrawn, unlike most brokerage accounts where cash is cash and many will even give you a debit card so you can spend directly from the account. This strongly decouples bitcoin and most other cryptos from the total money supply.
When you're on Binance and you send them one BTC as a block chain transaction, you are receiving one Binance!BTC that does not exist outside of that walled garden.
Just look at FTX - some 1.8B in BTC liabilities but zero BTC assets
This splitting hairs over "true" ownership ignores the fact that the original investor analysis done by GP here premised on chain transactions is still semantically wrong.
that still leaves us with "most".
everyone knows the theoretical issues and incompleteness of this statistics collection - since there is no single public or verifiable stat to use - its pretty new to be a person that chooses assume its more likely that people are having distinct addresses on chain, than assume its more likely they're on an exchange
kind of funny how we go full circle here, but okay. hope that helps your reasoning. this article has no way of making its claims either, so there's really no point of appealing to either authority or bolster any opinion.
The issue of one's "private" data then becoming part of a public dataset could be alleviated with deidentification, plus a better acceptance that when companies accumulate data about you, it's generally going to get exploited in some way or another.
Every cryptocurrency exchange would have to go bankrupt before you could make sweeping statements like that if so.
Is consistently proven to be a myth.
I'm curious: What is your source for this statistic?
For comparison: There were about 40M non-zero addresses earlier this year. See eg https://news.bitcoin.com/number-of-addresses-holding-btc-tap... [The current number is on Glassnode: https://studio.glassnode.com/metrics?%3Bm=blockchain.UtxoLos...]
FTX is one of the larger exchanges, and FTX bankruptcy headlines say they "may have 1 million creditors". See eg reuters.com/technology/ftx-officials-contact-with-us-regulators-filing-2022-11-15/
An exchange, when depositing or withdrawing to a user or another exchange, uses a ton of address, sometimes leaving behind very small amounts. Same with users. I'm sure 75% of non-zero address have very, very little BTC in them.
>I'm curious: What is your source for this statistic?
They have no reason to.
Unless the investor is specifically working on some HFT arbitrage scheme between exchanges, then they don't even need to move crypto out of the exchange.
Also given the complexity of rolling your own wallet, it's just a risk that's not worth it when KYC exchanges are relatively stable.
"You aren't a real real estate investor if you buy the brooklyn bridge from a guy on a streetcorner in Harlem" is true because the claim on the bridge was never credible, not because you never physically took possession of the bridge itself. You could argue that the exchange's IOU was never credible, but that's different from saying that any BTC-based IOU is made of lies.
If I buy some shares in a company that does things with [X], I think it makes sense to say that by doing so I'm "investing in [X]", even if I don't e.g. have the necessary license needed to directly own any [X].
But those addresses probably include most of the estimated 20% (or more) of Bitcoins that are lost (because they were usually lost when Bitcoin was less valuable).
In those cases the address hasn't lost money, but the person lost it all.
Sure, agree. But I don't think that's the topic here, the general harm/good done by cryptocurrencies, the submission is talking exclusively about profits or the lack of them rather.
If I invest 100 USD in Facebook and the stock gains double its value, I now have profits, no matter how bad Facebook is for the world.
And it seems there isn’t much to show on the good side, for all these negative externalities.
Bitcoin as represented in the white paper was never portrayed as an investment vehicle.
It's fairly useless as far as currencies go. It literally fails at the first requirement: it's not a reliable store of value.
But yeah, it also has the problem where if you go to a store, find out that it's cash only, walk to an ATM to take out enough to cover a transaction, only to discover that your cash has undergone a flash crash and isn't enough to cover the cost by the time you get back to the store.
Edit: after reading my comment I realized it might not be clear that bitcoin is astonishingly bad at imitating currency. Almost without exception trading it for goods and services is impossible.
There are certain circumstances where I think it may make sense for someone to pick an alternative currency; I'm not arguing it is superior to the rest of them.
> Several crypto coins are a bad store of value over 1 week but a decent one over a couple hours.
What kind of (real world) transaction would need to rely on a cryptocurrency for value stability over a couple of hours time-span that wouldn't be served by fiat currency, which provides the same stability guarantees over that same time-span?
There is also a strong real world value in countries where local currency is less stable and secure than crypto. Not all places have access to USD or foreign currency.
There are interesting examples coming out of Argentina. Imagine living in a country where year over year inflation is ~100% and the government may periodically seize assets in your bank account.
I think it could make a useful underlying tool to enable this but to be used directly by end user customers it'd be a tough sell.
I've used Wise to transfer USD <-> CAD, if they use crypto to enable that (I don't think they do, but I guess they could), I couldn't really care less.
I don't think your run of the mill consumer is going to want to use crypto to do the same thing. With smaller amounts the difference in cost is probably negligible, with larger amounts you could theoretically save more to make the effort worth it, but you have higher pressure to have more "traditional" assurances that nothing goes wrong.
In what ways do cash bank transfers not work for international transfers or irrevocable payments?
Why would they do that? I've never had that happen to me when I send an international transfer.
But it's always been for innocuous things like "reimburse relative for vacation rental expenses"
Yes I was made whole but it was unpleasant and I happily would have eaten the ~.30 of litecoin transaction fees and 0.1% crypto exchange fee to avoid that. Not to mention the wire cost me $15 in the first place and not everyone has ready access to a bank with free wires.
Depending on which country it is going to, that seems like an amount large enough to legitimately trip over some checks. In the US itself, last I heard all domestic transfers over 10k get reported.
Getting locked out of your own money can cause major damage. I'm lucky that I was able to dig up another 100k. Someone else could have lost their 50k and be liable for hundreds of thousands more in liability to the seller.
In any case ACH can be clawed back and it is my understanding in some exceptional circumstance a wire can too. The point never was crypto is always superior, it may be conventional is better 99.9% of the time but that 0.1% means a use case remains.
If you dollar cost average your acquisition of Bitcoin it smooths out the conversion risk and if anything the value against USD goes reliably up over a 3+ year window.
Anytime someone speaks crypto to me now I feel like Adam Sandler floating past Clint Howard’s window in Little Nicky: I don’t want to be part of this, they don’t want me to be part of this, and all I can do is wish them luck while they tell me they don’t need it.
If someone bought Bitcoin a year ago and wanted it to be a store of value, it is certainly not "whatever the holder wants it to be" for that person
A lot of currencies are not a good store of value the last 18 months.
They also seem to be a lot better at buying Bitcoin and Euros and S&P500, but a bit worse at buying lettuce.
It was not.
Only a fool uses a currency that's experienced 5000% deflation?
Bitcoin is a long failed currency, I can't believe there are people still trying to push that notion.
Volatility is one thing, but deflation to a nonsensical degree means that using it as a way to pay for goods and services is heavily discouraged because of things like... having your $20 pizza be worth $165,000 if you had just not bought it.
You're making my point. It's not functioning as a currency anymore, it's an investment vehicle.
It'd be like if Forex was the main way that dollars got moved.
What the paper finds (and we can certainly quibble with any paper) is evidence that the majority of people who bought Bitcoin in the 2015-2022 period did so in patterns that suggest that they're interested in an investment asset, not in a currency.
Every trade has two sides, and transactions cost fees.
Someone can (and should) have multiple addresses. And most retail investors will actually keep the bitcoins in an exchange in order to not lose an obscene amount of money to fees when trading. So there isn't an 1:1 correspondence between addresses and people.
However, realizing the profit is a different thing. That will work only for a few who invested early and deinvest early. Basically, btc is a pyramid scheme, the only difference to other pyramid schemes is that this fact is not obfuscated. Every investor knows that he is buying a fundamentally worthless good, but is hoping that someone else will eventually pay him a higher price.
That works well until the market is saturated and no one is willing to buy btc any more. Then, the price collapses.
Thus: even if most investors today have made profit, that simply means that the bottom of the pyramid has not been reached. At that point, most investors will have made loss.
> the report did assume that a user purchased bitcoin when they downloaded a crypto app.
Look directly at the blockchain, and instead find 49.4% of the addresses were in profit as of the time this article was published: https://www.yahoo.com/now/majority-bitcoin-addresses-now-los...
It looks like "inevitably" is more evitable than inevitable used to be.
[If anyone has a Glassnode subscription, the real-time readout is here: https://studio.glassnode.com/metrics?a=BTC&class=Addresses&m...]