News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by Sakos on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:23AM (#33607858)
I'm confused by all the comments here. Why is everybody so focused on the cons of dealerships instead of the cons if manufacturers own and run all the dealerships and the potential consequences, or even why it was regulated to be this way in the first place.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by ceejayoz on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:48AM (#33608479)
Would you like to highlight some? Why was it regulated this way? I can't find a great explanation, and "because it makes a lot of money for locally powerful business owners" seems to be the most common explanation floated.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by Sakos on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:58AM (#33608587)
I'm not familiar enough with the topic to be able to contribute meaningfully. It feels like most people here aren't, it's mostly anecdata with a tinge of libertarianism.

At most I can say I'm vaguely aware that early in US history there were a lot of issues around monopolies/oligopolies (see company towns) that lead to antitrust laws and by extension laws regarding dealerships. But I'd have to do more research to be able to say anything more concrete.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by mdorazio on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:40AM (#33608995)
I've worked for several OEMs and have talked to dealers about this a bit. Here's a quick run-down.

No domestic OEM sprang into existence with billions of dollars in the bank to spin up a nationwide network of showrooms and repair centers. As they were growing production slowly, they had to rely on small businesses around the country to sell their products for them, which also significantly improved capital when they were growing (dealers bought from the OEM, then sold to customers, potentially thousands of miles away from factories). Over time, these businesses became franchised by the OEMs to allow them to exert some control over the customer experience, standardize parts and repair work, etc.

So that's why dealers became a thing in the first place. The tricky bit of the history is why the state laws in favor of dealers came into existence. It's very fuzzy, but in effect the Detroit "big three" became very large and powerful, with enough money to start stepping in with company-owned dealerships. The local franchised dealers, who by that time had also become quite embedded in communities and politics, thought that this was unfair since the OEMs could undercut local dealers on price, thus they lobbied their states to put in place anti-competition laws. And they were successful.

That's about it. As far as I've ever been able to tell, customer experience and monopoly prevention never really factored into it other than as dubious arguments by the dealers themselves. Now here we are ~70 years later and the market has changed significantly, but the protection laws are still there.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by fallingknife on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:13AM (#33609358)
The manufacturer is necessary and the independent dealership is not. So I will always have to deal with the cons of the manufacturer. If you would like to defend independent dealerships, then tell me how exactly I would be worse off without them instead of just mentioning undefined "consequences."
[dead]
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by int_19h on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @09:33PM (#33634199)
> How do you deal with the threat of manufacturers edging out all private dealerships so that they're the only option?

That's what we have anti-trust for.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by Sakos on Saturday November 19, 2022 @05:36AM (#33668956)
Theoretically, sure. I wouldn't realistically rely in that even in the EU.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by mensetmanusman on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:56AM (#33611719)
Should Apple be forced to go through Best Buy?