News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Motorola PowerStack by spijdar on Sunday November 13, 2022 @07:48PM (#33588989)
The PowerPC port of Windows NT, apparently! https://www.itprotoday.com/compute-engines/motorola-powersta...

I believe the contemporary PowerPC port of Solaris 2.5.1 would also have a chance of working, as well as the OS/2 port. I think by 1996 there was a working Linux distribution with the nascent PPC port?

Re:The Motorola PowerStack by spijdar on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:31PM (#33589263)
So did Solaris! ... For some bizarre reason. I would love to hear an explanation for that, given SPARC is big endian only. I guess it was based on the x86 port?

My fun fact is all PowerPC processors except the 970 "G5" CPU can do little endian! And the Linux kernel is actually capable of running LE processes on a BE kernel [1]. There was a bug for a long time in Linux where the kernel signal handler assumed all 32 bit processes are BE, but after patching that, 32 bit "ppcle" executables work.

[1] Well, you can load mismatched endian processes, but syscalls and ioctls need data in the kernel endianness, so you would need a very weird libc and userland to actually use this

Re:The Motorola PowerStack by atdrummond on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:25PM (#33589223)
Yes, and as Spijdar notes below, so does the single point release of Solaris for PPC that come out in this era.
Re:The Motorola PowerStack by atdrummond on Sunday November 13, 2022 @07:50PM (#33589005)
The last two suggestions you offer (OS/2 and Linux) absolutely would be the case. I’m not sure about Solaris, at least officially. I’ve never heard of it in the PPC discussion groups in the 90s/00s.

EDIT: A trusted friend in this space (part of the MorphOS/Amiga PowerPC community) told me that one would absolutely be able to run the PPC Solaris port. The proper reference machine was actually the RS/6000 (see: https://virtuallyfun.com/2020/05/28/powerpc-solaris-on-the-r...), which ran on the 601, so the PowerStack I and PowerStack II would be absolutely capable of running said Solaris port competently.

Re:The Motorola PowerStack by inkyoto on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:37PM (#33589299)
Solaris could not run on RS/6000 as it had a completely different internal architecture, starting from the POWER (not PowerPC) CPU's, a proprietary IBM system bus and other proprietary, IBM made peripherals.

Solaris was ported to the PowerPC architecture (PPC 601 only, I think) and required a PCI bus to run on, but it was a one-off act and more of a mere curiosity rather than a serious investment, and the Solaris PowerPC port was quickly abandonded. Solaris could run on a Motorola PowerStack though as the PowerStack was essentially a PC with a PPC 601/603 CPU and with standard PC components (e.g. you could install a USB PCI card and attach a USB keyboard/mouse but I do not think AIX 4 had readily available PCI USB drivers, not initially anyway).

Re:The Motorola PowerStack by atdrummond on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:53PM (#33589403)
The initial point release could not run on the RS/6000. There are people who have successfully installed and used it in the following years; it does however require modifications and source that were created after the fact. I’ve personally installed Solaris on a PPC ThinkPad, which is even more different from a PowerStack than an RS/6000 is.

My mention of the RS/6000 was mainly to point out something which Spijdar explicitly called out, which is that these PowerPC ports (which wouldn’t be on most PowerStacks anyway as everyone I know ran Unix on them) targeted the PrEP/CHRP platforms explicitly. So just having a PowerPC chip of the right family isn’t enough.

Re:The Motorola PowerStack by inkyoto on Sunday November 13, 2022 @10:40PM (#33589982)
> The initial point release could not run on the RS/6000. There are people who have successfully installed and used it in the following years; it does however require modifications and source that were created after the fact.

I am curious about this. RS/6000's had had a microchannel bus and architecture until mid late nineties – when IBM started the transition onto the PCI bus in their RS6K workstations in the earnest (but not the servers), and – if my memory serves me well – the first few generations of new, PCI-based RS6k workstations had some hardware compatibility issues. Solaris also required Open Firmware to access the device tree and to boot up, and PReP proved to be a problematic replacement.

> I’ve personally installed Solaris on a PPC ThinkPad, which is even more different from a PowerStack than an RS/6000 is.

The PowerStack was effectively a standard PC with standard PC components inside, but with a PowerPC CPU and it came in a fancy, futuristic looking case which were the only two redeeming qualities / discerning features about the PowerStack. There was nothing else that was special about the PowerStack, and that was the point Motorola, Bull, Be and (to a certain extent) Apple and IBM were trying to make: we also make standard PC's, just like everyone else out there, that have a faster and a better CPU (PowerPC) compared to the Intel CPU. But then Motorola could not deliver, and IBM was not all that interested, and Intel dropped the Pentium Pro. Sun's own Ultra's 5/20/20/60 were, essentially, the same thing: a standard PC with a fancy CPU enslosed.

Re:The Motorola PowerStack by atdrummond on Sunday November 13, 2022 @11:47PM (#33590280)
If you email me, when I’m back in the states in a week I can look through my notes about the previous such installs we’ve done, check my PPC software library and determine any modified or alternate software packages, and boot up my personal RS/6000 and run through the process myself again and fully document it.

I am happy to share my findings regarding what all needs to be done to install Solaris on this particular system family.

Re:The Motorola PowerStack by spijdar on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:04PM (#33589102)
The Solaris port was literally for a single point release of Solaris (2.5.1), and was dropped the next update. Extremely bizarre, but it is widely mentioned within that single version, in the installer and everything. Apparently the code was later referenced to help port OpenSolaris 10 to PowerPC, the result of which is here: https://github.com/andreiw/polaris

Very mysterious, and since it's little endian, it only runs on these PReP/CHRP machines with LE-supporting firmware, like Windows used. I assume it'd work, if Solaris has the device drivers...

Re:The Motorola PowerStack by atdrummond on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:09PM (#33589138)
Correct - appreciate you adding the context about the PReP/CHRP reference systems. You can’t take the Solaris install and just run it on any PowerPC build, even if it is a 60x family machine.