News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by __pache__ on Sunday November 13, 2022 @04:11PM (#33587378)
wait, why are CO2 emissions "bad?" it might even literally take 20-25 years to "pay off the CO2" used to make, deliver, and install the solar panels...

to me it seems like our CO2 emissions are not bad and the effects on climate are very minor. this is playing out in real time as we make dire predictions that never seem to come to fruition. the world is ending in 12 years, said someone popular in ~2016. Well, halfway there, lady!

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by Mistletoe on Sunday November 13, 2022 @04:19PM (#33587445)
There’s nothing we could say to change your mind since you’ve already ignored all the science that exists.
Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by __pache__ on Sunday November 13, 2022 @04:21PM (#33587456)
...maybe you're projecting?
Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by aperson_hello on Sunday November 13, 2022 @05:51PM (#33588218)
Making and installing solar panels doesn't cost anywhere that much CO2. Best numbers I see suggest payback in ~3 years assuming they're produced with coal power (and the numbers are better if they're produced with cleaner power, though electricity is fungible, so I'm not sure if that really makes sense to do). As a quick gut check, look at unsubsidized solar install costs - they're significantly lower than the cost of the electricity they generate in the 5-10 year range in almost all lower and middle latitude places...

Also, idiots stating unscientific garbage (like the world ending in 2028) doesn't mean that there's no science behind it... Just that there was an idiot making up BS.

Edit: it was a 2019 quote, not a 2016 quote. So we have all the way until 2031 until the world "ends"... Still an idiotic quote

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by __pache__ on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:08PM (#33589124)
> Making and installing solar panels doesn't cost anywhere that much CO2.

...source?

Solar is unreliable, you _need_ another system, so you have to install 2 systems now. It _will_ be cheaper/less co2/etc.etc. to just install and use 1 system.

The real solution to reducing overall CO2 is clearly Nuclear. Do you disagree with this?

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by aperson_hello on Monday November 14, 2022 @01:55AM (#33590942)
Nuclear should be part of the solution. Solar is just too cheap not to do be part of it too. Since there are on demand sources (natural gas peakers, batteries, etc.) and because solar isn't replacing clean sources at this point in time, solar (and wind) can and should be part of the energy mix!

Here's one source. Plenty more if you Google it https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy04osti/35489.pdf

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by __pache__ on Monday November 14, 2022 @03:28PM (#33600526)
what should I be looking at in this source? how does it scale? you can scale nuclear/hydro very easily for millions of people .. they inherently scale.

solar does not, you need tons and tons and tons and tons and tons of panels. it does not scale. this seems so self evident. like people are holding their hands over their ears and eyes, ignoring the obvious...

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by Schroedingersat on Monday November 14, 2022 @06:50PM (#33603144)
How much new net renewables capacity was installed last year? What was the largest capacity of nuclear ever installed in a single year?

Solar is scaling just fine. Installing 5-20 panels per person is hardly prohibitive. It's like claiming wheat can't feed people because it needs trillions of grains so we must stop wheat farming and only eat novelty sized pumpkin and elephant.

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by aperson_hello on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:23AM (#33619978)
Solar absolutely scales - in the factory...
Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by Schroedingersat on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:38PM (#33588549)
EBPT for PERC panels is 3-12 months. Far lower than nuclear and slightly lower than wind.
Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by __pache__ on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:12PM (#33589151)
what does that even mean? how does this scale? is it the same cost at 1000x the demand to support things? ugh... this is so disingenuous. a nuclear install might support millions of people but the same solar would be insanely huge AND require multiple backups/batteries..

it is so clear solar/wind is worse than nuclear.

it is increasingly clear that our co2 output isn't that scary. we are "greening" the Earth. Sea level rise is well within normal bounds. Everything is _great.._

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by Schroedingersat on Sunday November 13, 2022 @09:29PM (#33589629)
Weren't you just asserting expertise on the contents of a solar cell and energy content of generation? How do you not know the relevant terms or name for the dominant variety? Did you even know there were different types before you made up numbers?

Energy payback time. Passive Emitter Rear Contact photovoltaics They're made of sand and a tiny bit of silver. The amount of silver used total is going down per year in spite of production going up, and there are technologies being commercialized to make it use less silver than a nuclear reactor.

Similarly LFP batteries only require a few dozen times as much energy to produce as one charge. Sodium uses even less, only requires abundant materials and is scaling up now. Then there are all of the other storage and load shifting methods.

You'd have to increase uranium mining 5x to meet last year's renewable capacity additions, and 8x for next year's. The mines would make more land uninhabitable than the solar panels would cover (even if they weren't compatible with other land use). Trying to make a puny backwards imitation of a star with a few tiny scraps of left over supernova dust is woefully insufficient. Getting energy directly from the source is the only place there's enough available unless we want massive degrowth.

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by __pache__ on Monday November 14, 2022 @01:11AM (#33590684)
> Weren't you just asserting expertise

Was I wrong about something ?

> Energy payback time.

Right. This doesn't scale as close to as well as nuclear ..........

> You'd have to increase uranium mining 5x

??? if things actually do become expensive, welcome to breeder reactors bro

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by Schroedingersat on Monday November 14, 2022 @03:29AM (#33591478)
> Was I wrong about something ?

Extremely.

> Right. This doesn't scale as close to as well as nuclear ..........

Using extremely generous assumptions about high grade ore, and old, much simpler reactors you can come in slightly under that for about a month. https://world- nuclear.org/information-library/energy-and-the-environment/energy-return-on-investment.aspx

EROI is significantly worse than solar because of ongoing energy costs for fuel and O&M. Especially if you use ore that is typical rather than the low hanging fruit. A perc module is around 60-120 depending on where it is placed. NPP is 15-60 depending on where its uranium comes from, how it is enriched and whether it uses reprocessing.

>> Mining: Ranger ore in 2008 was 0.26% U head grade. Energy: 273 GJ/t U3O8, 322 GJ/tU, including significant development work. (Note that if ore of 0.01% U is envisaged, this would give 1638 TJ/yr, 70 PJ total for mining & milling, hence total 108 PJ for the centrifuge option, thus inputs become 3.3% of output and energy ratio becomes 30.) All Ranger inputs are thermal (it generates own electricity). The Schneider 2010 figure for mining & milling is similar to Rössing.

> ??? if things actually do become expensive, welcome to breeder reactors bro

You can't start a breeder reactor without fissile material so new capacity still needs just as much (they don't exist so can't say for sure, but about double per GW by fairly generous estimates, actually). Additionally most of the concepts need about 2-10% of annual Beryllium production per reactor.

You have to fit something into the industrial capacity of the world before you can start gaslighting about costs that consistently go up or about costs of technologies that don't exist and might maybe start figuring out the hard bit of extraction and refuelling in ten years.

Expanding Uranium mining 5x would require processing a billion tonnes of ore per year. For reference Iron Ore production is about 2.5 billion tonnes. You'd need at least 30 million tonnes of sulfuric acid (world production is about 180 million).

Then for the reactors you'd need the most of the world supply of chromium. For a PWR you'd need half of the indium, and significant amounts of Zirconium, Cadmium and silver. Reliable Molten salt reactors don't exist and there's one MSR with okay capacity factor, but no information about how kuch noble metal they need is available.

This is just to match renewables now mind you, not where they will be when you finally open your mines (which takes years or decades).

The idea that Nuclear could scale to match renewables in under 50 years is laughable. Which is why fossil fuel shills butt into every conversation to claim renewables can't work and must be replaced with it.

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by __pache__ on Monday November 14, 2022 @03:30PM (#33600542)
> > Was I wrong about something ?

> Extremely.

Can you concisely explain this without writing a book obfuscating your arguments..?

> You can't start a breeder reactor without fissile material

Who said otherwise? We stopped the breeder reactor journey mostly because fuel is so cheap. This will become more relevant over time, if necessary, due to natural market forces. dude, what? stop trying to obfuscate the obvious..

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by Schroedingersat on Monday November 14, 2022 @06:19PM (#33602821)
So you're both willfully ignorant about the technology you're pushing and unwilling to have it spoon fed to you? Wow.
Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by nl on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:27PM (#33604499)
I think this quote from @__pache__ says a lot:

> it is increasingly clear that our co2 output isn't that scary. we are "greening" the Earth. Sea level rise is well within normal bounds.

Someone making those claims isn't really arguing in good faith.

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by Schroedingersat on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:04PM (#33604733)
Of course not. But it's fun watching them have a tantrum when they run out of lies and I've learnt a lot of cool new things from looking up the lies.

It also helps distribute reality in contrast to the usual talking points. Most people don't know that nuclear is very limited in scale and actually and quite poor from a land use and energy perspective if it were to be expanded, or that the overwhelming majority of radiation comes from sourcing fuel.

I've seen a few bystanders go 'oh shit, you only get 100-500mW per kg of mining?' Or 'wait, none of the breeders have actually done the thing?'

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by nl on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:53AM (#33605792)
I think the nuclear stans (your term, which I like) usually don't know a lot about what they are promoting.

Anything a nuclear plant can do a long distance transmission line can do better, with already proven technology

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-high-voltage_electricity...

I like this quote:

For example, a recent report by researchers from the Earth System Research Laboratory published in Nature Climate Change found that a UHVDC transmission line in the US could cut emissions by as much as 80% by harnessing Wyoming’s abundant wind power potential and transporting the electricity to California.

https://www.power-technology.com/analysis/chinas-mega-transm...

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by Schroedingersat on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @01:21AM (#33605922)
There are probably places where a NPP is the best and cheapest choice to reduce emissions and worth the downsides, but not many and forcing them into places with excellent renewable resources is idiotic.

Unless and until the budget and plans for around 5TW net of renewables is allocated, then starting any new nuclear is just a way of delaying the death of fossil fuels.

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by nl on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @01:00AM (#33605825)
> what does that even mean?

EBPT = Energy payback time.

> how does this scale? is it the same cost at 1000x the demand to support things?

It scales wonderfully. Increased demand means the costs go down.

Re:Solar panel waste may not be nearly as bad as we once tho... by Schroedingersat on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @01:11AM (#33605876)
At 1000x the demand that would be triple the total cumulative output of every nuclear reactor ever in newly installed production every year. Which is probably about 20x as many solar panels as could reasonably be created in a year with current production ready technology.