News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:1993 Murder She Wrote VR Episode by Dylan16807 on Saturday November 12, 2022 @02:20PM (#33576125)
> It's incumbent upon you to show your work first, before demanding somebody else do it first.

My math is right next next to that demand!

> My work that I'm showing you taught me that merely 2mm translational resolution and 1/6 degree rotational resolution would totally ruin the physics simulation and sense of immersion and realism

That's a much much smaller workspace, so at that scale it would be a fraction of a millimeter. I don't see why the degrees aren't enough though; that tablet looks to me like there's a small amount of jitter but enough to make it not matter.

But if you want to 10x the precision of everything I said, that's only 11 more bytes.

> Representing user input and object rotations and positions as precise floating point numbers is absolutely necessary when there is a physics simulation involved (see "good VR" prerequisite #3 below, "graphically and physically realistic worlds").

I can understand that, but even before worrying about diminishing returns, you can only throw so many bits at a bad input:

> It was determined that the translational accuracy of the [Oculus Rift S] was 1.66 ± 0.74 mm for the head-mounted display and 4.36 ± 2.91 mm for the controller, and the rotational accuracy of the system was 0.34 ± 0.38° for the HMD and 1.13 ± 1.23° for the controller.

> Kreylos estimated the precision of Lighthouse tracking to be around RMS 1.5mm and the accuracy around RMS 1.9mm.

So you could fit the full precision of those devices into 36-40 bytes, and that's before we even consider that most people are only tracking 3 points, not 6. Even with some extra precision, I already tossed on some more bytes and it doesn't really matter in the end whether it's 14Mbps or 20Mbps.

> But two decades later, the public and technologists have become so impatient that the new systems calling themselves VR have punted even on the core original criteria.

> Head-mounted systems like the Oculus Rift offer no way to reach in. In demos, visitors twiddle a 1980s style game joystick. And users don’t natively network — in an Oculus demonstration you don’t see the other users in the VR world — not even the other players sitting alongside you in the demo.

That's a real shame, and worth keeping in mind, but I was talking about taking the kind of VR immersion that is currently widely deployed and adding more people.

There are no comments on this comment yet.