News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by kennend3 on Saturday November 12, 2022 @07:30AM (#33572427)
> Whatever happened to them needing to represent the interests of the people?

As a Canadian, where Americans often come here in droves to buy cheap insulin i've often wondered the same thing.

https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/caravan-of-americans-cross-int...

Americans drive 1,000 KM just to get affordable insulin which in many cases is a life or death drug?

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by rufus_foreman on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:04AM (#33572646)
Human insulin is available without a prescription for around $25 a vial at Walmart. That is what most diabetics would have used 20 years ago before the drug companies developed analog insulin versions that are easier to use. Analog insulin is available with a prescription for around $75 a vial at Walmart. About 1 in 7 Walmart shoppers have diabetes.
Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by swores on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:31AM (#33572872)
That's still ridiculously expensive, no?

edit: yes, seems it is indeed - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33572721

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by harimau777 on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:49AM (#33573006)
I don't know if it's accurate, but this suggests that on average, diabetics use 2-3 vials per month. So that would be $50 to $75 a month.

However, it also mentions that some people need 50-60 units per meal and a vial contains 1000 units. Assuming three meals per day, someone using 50 vials per meal would spend $666.66 per month.

$666.66 per month would be prohibitively expensive for many people and even $50 to $75 could be a significant expense for people making minimum wage (depending on local minimum wage it could be equivalent to 7-8 hours of work before taxes).

https://4allfamily.com/blogs/diabetes/how-long-does-a-vial-o...

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by chewbacha on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:09AM (#33573172)
50 units per dose would be 20 doses per vial.

3 meals a day * 30 days would be 90 meals.

90 meals / 20 doses / 1 vial = 4.5 vials / month

4.5 * 25 = 112.5

I’m not seeing how we get to $666

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by clnq on Saturday November 12, 2022 @12:06PM (#33574905)
More context: the insulin dose diabetics take with meals is called a bolus dose. However, cells in the human body need glucose uptake constantly, 24 hours a day. So T1 diabetics also have to take a basal insulin dose either once daily as an injection or continuously on a pump. In addition to that, diabetics need to take correction bolus doses to lower their blood glucose when it's high not as a result of a meal, and sometimes they have snack or meals other than just the 3 meals a day. The basal and bolus ratio is around 50% : 50% for some people, although it depends on their doctor and a lot of different factors. So, to recap - there are food boluses, correction boluses, and basal doses.

Here's how I would do the math: 50 units per dose x 3.5 meals on average x 2 for basal = 350 units a day. Or 0.35 vial per day, and 10.7 vials per month. Assuming synthetic human insulin and not insulin analogue is used, that means about $270 per month.

However, some caveats:

- synthetic human insulin is not fast enough for most carbohydrates in meals, and it results in higher blood glucose spikes immediately after a meal than using an insulin analogue. The higher the blood glucose, the more insulin it takes to lower it the same amount. Moreover, we only have so many hours in the day, and slower acting synthetic human insulin needs time to work. So people using it are more likely to "overcompensate" and then eat a bit later to offset their dose. This is a very long-winded way of saying that a person might need slightly more synthetic human insulin than analogues, plus synthetic human insulin in general is less effective.

- In my calculations, I did not include correction bolus doses, insulin used to prime needles, and pump infusion sets (although probably very few people use human synthetic insulin in pumps anyways). I also did not include insulin that is spoiled in some way (refrigerator breakdowns, reserve insulin taken on trips that's not refrigerated, heatwaves, and so on).

- Most people use between 70 and 110 units of insulin per day, whether that's a combination of an insulin analogue and basal insulin injections, or using insulin analogue in a pump. I don't know how much synthetic human insulin is used per day on average, probably a bit more.

So I would say in practice, for someone who uses that much synthetic human insulin, the cost can be even $400 per month. For analogues, it would be much, much higher.

I think it makes sense for me to provide a source for all this - I care for someone with T1 diabetes and am somewhat connected with the broader T1 community.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by harimau777 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:29AM (#33582844)
Hmm, ya not sure how I messed up my math so badly. That's my mistake.
Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by rayiner on Saturday November 12, 2022 @10:43AM (#33574093)
People making minimum wage typically are eligible for Medicaid, which provides insulin for free.
Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by harimau777 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:32AM (#33582874)
In my state people making minimum wage make too much to qualify for Medicaid.
Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by clnq on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:46AM (#33572980)
Analogues are not only easier to use, but also allow for regimens and therapies (such as insulin pump therapy) that somewhat improve life expectancy and significantly improve quality of life.

The relatively inelastic demand of insulin analogues when synthetic human insulin is available shows how important analogues are to T1 diabetics.

Sometimes pharma companies try to allude to analogues being a luxury good compared to synthetic human insulin. But to T1 diabetics this notion is generally ridiculous. Analogue insulins allow them to regain a little bit more quality of life lost to the disease, and that should be a human right when insulin manufacturing costs are so low.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by tomohawk on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:04AM (#33572656)
As an American, you're welcome. Canada has price controls, which are effectively subsidized by prices in the US.
Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by likecarter on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:35AM (#33572900)
No, it's because our government negotiates on behalf of all Canadians. And we are a very big healthcare market (even with a small population) since we all participate in the health care system – since it's public.
Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by dboreham on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:48AM (#33572997)
Is that meaningfully different from price controls?

US government also represents a huge proportion of the demand but is banned through corruption from exercising similar price pressure.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by harimau777 on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:53AM (#33573054)
Doesn't that go both ways? Eli Lilly is a huge organization negotiating in favor of higher prices, so it makes sense that a huge organization (i.e. the government or insurance companies) would be needed to negotiate against them.

Even if there is a power imbalance between Eli Lilly and the Canadian Government, there would also be a power imbalance if it was instead Eli Lilly vs. individual consumers.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by bart_spoon on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:10AM (#33573182)
Eli Lilly actually doesn’t negotiate for higher prices. I’ve had somewhat more insight than the average person into how the dynamics of the insulin pricing work, and it’s a total abomination, largely born out of a lack of a universal public insurance option in the US.

Despite the skyrocketing costs of insulin over the decades, Eli Lilly’s profits per unit are mostly in line with inflation. This is because in the US system, there is a pervasive system of rebates that exists between pharmaceutical companies and insurers. Insurers often may only pay 10% of what the sticker price is for insulin. But the way these rebates get negotiated through third party firms known as PBMs create a system that incentivizes insulin that is marked up an incredible amount and then discounted to X, than simply pricing it at X in the first place. But this obviously screws over anyone without access to the rebate, i.e. those without insurance. And this system largely exists because the privatized nature of insurance in the US. If there was some kind of universal medicare in the US, undermines those incentives and the market would normalize immediately.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by wwtrv on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:50AM (#33573572)
> If there was some kind of universal medicare in the US

You don't even need that. Just more/better regulation would suffice. You have countries with fully privatized healthcare systems like Switzerland or partially privatized ones like Germany or Netherlands which have no such problems.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by djbebs on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:54AM (#33573612)
The problem is the regulation that mandates people have insurance or be punished for it...
Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by wwtrv on Sunday November 13, 2022 @03:20AM (#33581118)
> The problem is the regulation that mandates people have insurance or be punished

Which is the cornerstone of any universal healthcare system? It only works in other countries if the healthy subsidize the costs of those less fortunate.

Also Switzerland had compulsory fully private insurance. To be fair they do suffer from similar issues as the US. Healthcare prices are very inflated compared to the surrounding countries, accessibility to some services (e.g. dental) is poor for low income individuals etc.

Of course it helps that Switzerland is a quite homogenous, has low inequality and subsidize access for low income individuals. However inherently the system is not that different from the one in US (I mean Switzerland is closer to US than either is to Britain).

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by tomohawk on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:50AM (#33573016)
The negotiation goes like this: "Here's what we'll pay you for that. If you don't like it, we'll ignore your patents and intellectual property and manufacture it ourselves."

The companies would rather prevent Canada from funding competition, so they just jack up prices in the US to compensate.

If the US passed a law requiring sales of drugs in the US to match the lowest sale price in any other country, one of 2 things would happen.

The likely thing is that innovation would come to a standstill. Money goes to where it can make the most money. No money in drugs? No new drugs.

Or, the companies would get a lot more hard nosed about sales in countries with price controls, and there would be trade wars between the US and those countries. And then you would see higher prices in Canada.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by orra on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:57AM (#33573073)
> If you don't like it, we'll ignore your patents and intellectual property and manufacture it ourselves

Citation?

> so they just jack up prices in the US to compensate.

Pharmaceutical companies charge as much as they can anywhere, including in the US. They wouldn't entertain reducing prices in the US even if the Canadian market were different.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by tomohawk on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:04AM (#33573133)
Any time there are price controls, there is scarcity. That is, unless the price controls are subsidized in some way like in the situation we're talking about.

I like the innovative drugs that are being made, so I'm not in favor of price controls.

If you think drugs are too expensive, then do something about it. Create some useful drugs and sell them for a cheaper price.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by wwtrv on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:46AM (#33573533)
> Any time there are price controls, there is scarcity

That's not true. It would be the case for (close to) perfectly competitive markets with lower margins, like petrol, basic foodstuffs to some extent etc. It does not apply to markets controlled by oligopolies/monopolies. Especially pharmaceuticals where margins are extremely high and producers of some drugs would still be able to make a profit if they cut (list) prices by a magnitude or two.

Only argument against is that it might decrease available funding for developing new drugs, which might be a legitimate concern. But in no way would reasonable prices controls result in a scarcity of almost all currently available drugs.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by djbebs on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:52AM (#33573595)
It is objectively true though.
Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by kennend3 on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:57AM (#33573076)
Actually.. the negotion goes like this:

" When inventor Frederick Banting discovered insulin in 1923, he refused to put his name on the patent. He felt it was unethical for a doctor to profit from a discovery that would save lives. Banting’s co-inventors, James Collip and Charles Best, sold the insulin patent to the University of Toronto for a mere $1. They wanted everyone who needed their medication to be able to afford it.

"

There is no "IP in Canada for Insulin given UofT "owns" the patent.

Most of the price differences between US and Canada stems from the difference in patents and trademarks. Canada has far more "Generics" vs the US.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by tomohawk on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:02AM (#33573116)
Actually, the health system that Canada has did not start until 1947, and the product you are talking about is literally not the product under discussion.
Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by kennend3 on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:18AM (#33573251)
I posted i was Canadian.. you posted you are American and now you are attempting to teach me about the Canadian health care system?

This strikes me as odd.. but here we go...

Canada's healthcare system is the product of Tommy Douglas

https://www.cbc.ca/news/entertainment/tommy-douglas-crowned-...

" Tommy Douglas, the former Saskatchewan premier who is credited with being the founding father of Canada's health-care system, was named Monday night as the winner in the CBC's Greatest Canadian contest. "

Given Tommy Douglas was in office from 3 August 1961 – 24 April 1971 this "1947" date is unrealistic.

Most would agree this is what started Canada's health care system - Tommy's proposed "universal health care legislation in 1961."

Insulin has changed over time but the patents and the laws which govern prices in canada have been in place for a long time.

As i posted, most drugs are cheaper in canada because of the difference in US vs CA patents.

In the US you often find drugs being "reformulated" to renew the patents, this doesn't take place here.

perhaps something like this could lead to meaningful changes in the US?

https://www.fiercepharma.com/pharma/uspto-and-fda-commit-pat...

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by mcphage on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:26AM (#33573322)
> The companies would rather prevent Canada from funding competition, so they just jack up prices in the US to compensate.

If Canada raised their insulin prices, do you think Eli Lily would lower their prices in the US?

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by ehnto on Saturday November 12, 2022 @10:23AM (#33573899)
> The likely thing is that innovation would come to a standstill. Money goes to where it can make the most money. No money in drugs? No new drugs.

There are pharmaceutical companies all around the world, while it's true that the US currently has the largest market cap for pharma companies, it's not like the rest of the world is sitting on it's hands. Of the top 15 largest pharmaceutical companies in the world, 8 are in the US, and 7 abroad. But market cap is a poor metric for impact, especially in the US, where it seems the market can price a social media company with no profit at 44billion, I'm not particularly convinced by valuations on pharmaceutical companies who's share pricing rely on price gouging and a indentured customer base to stay high.

Another perspective is that while they're able to sell insulin at 40x cost, something they developed decades ago, what's their incentive to develop new drugs? In countries where companies are required to provide licensing for generics after a certain time period, they would be incentivized to continue developing new drugs in order to keep products on the shelves that are in the exclusive licensing window.

Regardless of any of the above, what you're essentially advocating for is fleecing US citizens to the benefit of the rest of the world. I'm just not sure how this could possibly be a good thing for the US.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by refurb on Saturday November 12, 2022 @10:25AM (#33573923)
Canada has a population of 35M.

United healthcare, the largest US insurer cover over 40M people.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by notwedtm on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:33AM (#33572885)
What a weird take.

Are you saying that if these for-profit corporations didn't charge absurd amounts to US citizens, then the drug would be unattainable for Canadians?

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by kennend3 on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:48AM (#33572998)
OMG, you cant honestly beleive this can you?

The US, out of its immense generosity is subsidizing canada?

News flash, Insulin was discovered here (canada).. so how exactly are you subsidizing a Canadian discovery?

How about this for a far more realistic explanation:

" When inventor Frederick Banting discovered insulin in 1923, he refused to put his name on the patent. He felt it was unethical for a doctor to profit from a discovery that would save lives. Banting’s co-inventors, James Collip and Charles Best, sold the insulin patent to the University of Toronto for a mere $1. They wanted everyone who needed their medication to be able to afford it.

"

https://www.vox.com/2019/4/3/18293950/why-is-insulin-so-expe...

Good god some of the comments you find here are just shocking.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by bart_spoon on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:58AM (#33573086)
It is tone deaf, I agree. But it should be noted that the insulin you are talking about is about $20 at Walmart these days, which given inflation going back to the 1920s, is incredibly cheap.

The insulin that is incredibly expensive these days, that people drive to Canada for, is analogue insulin, which was developed in the last several decades by the pharmaceutical companies and is far more efficacious and easy to use. It’s a completely different product, which is often missed when these discussions of the donation of the original insulin patent is brought up.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by ryan93 on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:51AM (#33573030)
The insulin people now use wasn’t developed there
Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by borissk on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:10AM (#33573179)
Healthcare around the world is subsidized by the insane prices people in US pay for their healthcare.
Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by Denisos on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:10AM (#33573181)
i agree
Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by kennend3 on Saturday November 12, 2022 @10:03AM (#33573689)
Care to explain why US drug companies are so profitable?

If High US prices was subsidizing others, where does the massive profit come from?

This is why drugs in the US cost so much reformulations to extend patents: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4865781/

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by borissk on Saturday November 12, 2022 @10:38AM (#33574036)
Say a big pharma company spends $100M on a new drug - R&D, trials, certifications in US. They sell it for $100 a tablet in US for a couple years, at which point they have paid off their investments and made a small profit. Now they negotiate deliveries of the drug to say Canada.

First Canada's drug administration confirms the drug is approved by the FDA and approves it for use in Canada without further test, trials, etc. Second as the production costs almost nothing any price the pharma company gets is almost pure profit. So the price in Canada ends up at $1 a tablet.

Now think what would've happened if US didn't exist. All the R&D, trials, etc. would have to be paid by all the other countries in the world. There would be far fewer new drugs being developed and they would cost a lot more.

Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by Naga on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:58AM (#33573087)
On the other hand, now Canadians drive to the United States to buy children's pain medicine because it is largely unavailable here.
Re:Eli Lilly stock fell by $20B because of a fake tweet abou... by moistly on Saturday November 12, 2022 @01:16PM (#33575518)
A temporary supply chain issue, versus a systemic healthcare issue. Really not comparable.