Re:Tunneling Internet through WhatsApp to get around network...
by aleixrodriala on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:17PM
(#33568995)
Side project tunneling a TCP port through WhatsApp, can be useful on airplanes or any WiFi/carrier that has unlimited social network data limits. Appreciate feedback :)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Tunneling Internet through WhatsApp to get around network...
by vital_beach on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:40PM
(#33569131)
any CFAA concerns when used in the wrong place and found out (airplanes)?
Re:Tunneling Internet through WhatsApp to get around network...
by aleixrodriala on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:47PM
(#33569173)
I'm not encouraging anyone to use this by saying this but WhatsApp traffic it's encrypted and the traffic through the socket its also encrypted, I guess you can't get in trouble for sending and recieving lots of weird messages? Again, intended for educational usage
Re:Tunneling Internet through WhatsApp to get around network...
by fragmede on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:56PM
(#33569230)
that's a lot of words to say "yes, an overzealous prosecutor could try and make a case using the CFAA", but that's because the CFAA is a bullshit overly-broad law. that it's bullshit doesn't change the threat to the prosecuted, unfortunately.
Re:Tunneling Internet through WhatsApp to get around network...
by aleixrodriala on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:02PM
(#33569260)
you are totally right
Re:Tunneling Internet through WhatsApp to get around network...
by odo1242 on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:58PM
(#33569235)
not CFAA concerns, but you'd probably be in violation of the WhatsApp TOS: "… (d) interfere with or disrupt the safety, security, confidentiality, integrity, availability, or performance of our Services; …"
disclaimer: IANAL
Re:Tunneling Internet through WhatsApp to get around network...
by aleixrodriala on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:59PM
(#33569246)
Yes, in the own project there is a disclaimer that using this software might get your WhatsApp account banned so use with caution, and anyways is just a fun project for educational purposes. But good to know ofc
Re:Tunneling Internet through WhatsApp to get around network...
by jamal-kumar on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:53PM
(#33569508)
I remember trying this (Also in Latin America with Zuckerberg's creepy old "internet.com" initiative to make his services free in the third world, which is a done and over with promotion by now at least in Costa Rica) and realizing that ICMP/DNS tunneling was faster and more reliable, you can only get like half-duplex TCP over whatsapp messages and then the frames are limited if you're going to fit them in per message to like 1,024 characters (Though it seems you got more in there?)... DNS or ICMP tunnelling further works on things like getting a foothold for checking your email in some far flung airport network with a broken/sketchy payment gateway, you REALLY need to check your email, and where that passes but nothing else does. Then there's the risk that they decide to ban your SIM chip as you mention, which is like a 2$ mistake in such regions but if you do it on your main number you're risking having to tell everyone "yeah i tried to hack whatsapp and they blocked my old number haha" because that's what they've funnelled everyone into using out there with this free data transfer deal on that platform.
By the way your implementation looks way nicer than what I was working with before.