News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Visual Bibliography of Tree Visualization by arboles on Friday November 11, 2022 @04:09PM (#33566877)
Unlike the other comments, I don't think the site about tree organizations should be organized like a tree. The authors are well read in tree visualizations, in the site you can filter by "Dimensionality" or "Representation" or "Alignment", and you can combine these tags. The authors don't use trees because they know the limitations.

This reply isn't filed under the intended two posts it should reference because of limitations of how comments are structured on HN.

Re:A Visual Bibliography of Tree Visualization by froh on Friday November 11, 2022 @04:40PM (#33567235)
to the limitations on how comments are structured, as trees, not DAGs, and not just on HN but nearly everywhere: have you ever encountered a "forum" or "chat" eher you can kind of star merge several threads with a single reply?
Re:A Visual Bibliography of Tree Visualization by bursted on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:13PM (#33567593)
>>33567235

I can only think of Futaba-style discussion boards, that is, 4chan. On 4chan threads are linear, but you're supposed to reply to posts by mentioning their unique post nº. In my comment I'd wanna mention >>33566411 and >>33566389. You can mention as many posts as want. The posts get a backlink, so the thread is a navigable, true graph structure. Reading discussion on 4chan can be confusing as a deep chain of replies can branch out to mention a recent surface post, and to understand what's going on you have to both delve down focused reply chains but also be aware of incoming posts that are displayed cutting across any one discussion.

Here is a typical 4chan thread that demos this:

https://desuarchive.org/g/thread/87053939/#87081210

I chose to link a post where a picture visualizes a 4chan thread in a directed graph. Also, a screen above there's a "Thanks." to several other posts, in one post.

Re:A Visual Bibliography of Tree Visualization by jimmySixDOF on Saturday November 12, 2022 @02:20AM (#33570881)
Yes. One of the biggest ironies is that the very best approach to open forum discussion is applied to some of the least useful uses of the application. The UI is as slapped together and confronting as the conversations but the proper branching graph system could make everything from search to navigation to LLM AI digestion of huge messaging systems just work better.