News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by z92 on Thursday December 15, 2011 @07:45AM (#3355909)
The real news is IE share, worldwide, is now only 40%!
Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by guelo on Thursday December 15, 2011 @08:18AM (#3355982)
So we're trading a browser from a company with a desktop monopoly for one with a web search monopoly. I'm trying to get excited here. It's a shame Firefox couldn't win, but it's tough going up against a determined multibillion dollar behemoth, especially when they get to leverage their monopoly (sound familiar?) by advertising on one of the world's most popular webpages, google.com, for free.
Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by jrockway on Thursday December 15, 2011 @08:45AM (#3356061)
Chromium is as functional as Chrome and it's 100% Free Software. That's why you should like the Chrome family over IE; you can open up the hood and play with the little bits inside. With IE, you're stuck with whatever Microsoft is nice enough to give you.

Also, Bing advertises on Google too. And Google has basically paid for (and continues to pay for) Firefox's development.

If there's someone to hate here, it certainly isn't Google.

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by kenjackson on Thursday December 15, 2011 @12:21PM (#3356983)
I think your biases are showing here. No one said anything about hating anyone. It's about companies (with fudiciary obligations which aren't to the customer) are taking very strong dominating positions in key technologies.

Being Free Software really isn't a concern to most people. Try being a small company that tries to block aggression from Google or Microsoft. Will it matter that Chrome is free? It's not like you can go in and say, "Here I changed Chrome. All users now use this version." For 99.999% of users free software is meaningless.

What would make Chrome much more interesting is if they gave maintanance of it over to a standards body or even a university. At this point "free software" is just nice window dressing.

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by jrockway on Thursday December 15, 2011 @03:02PM (#3357658)
Yes, they must be. I think Free Software is cool, and I am not upset that Google pays people to write it. I resisted using Chromium for a long time because I thought the Firefox folks were "fighting the good fight". But honestly, their software engineering practices suck compared to Google's and their product is, as a result, not as good. The great thing about freedom is that you can use both. Or you can take the good features from Chromium and put them in Firefox. Or you can make your own web browser.

You can also advertise it on Google as much as you want; they sell ads to pretty much everyone (including themselves).

In the end, I don't feel like Google is wronging me.

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by riffraff on Thursday December 15, 2011 @04:37PM (#3358143)
could you expand on why you think mozilla's engineering practices suck ? I have sometimes had a similar feeling, but I have too little competence to be a judge of that.
Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by jrockway on Thursday December 15, 2011 @05:48PM (#3358434)
Because they are not as rigorous as Google's. At Google every commit is read and reviewed before it lands in source control. And they have an entire team dedicated to building the testing infrastructure, so they can do things like testing Flash against every possible input to see if there are any security holes. (There were.) Google is all about being super careful about every line of code. I don't know for a fact that Mozilla isn't, but the quality of the code that I've read in each browser makes me think Google has a better process. But I could be wrong.
Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by bzbarsky on Thursday December 15, 2011 @10:15PM (#3359247)
> At Google every commit is read and reviewed before it lands > in source control.

Something Mozilla has been doing for 12 years.

> And they have an entire team dedicated to building the > testing infrastructure

As does every browser developer.

> so they can do things like testing Flash against every > possible input

http://www.squarefree.com/2010/07/14/fuzzing-talk-at-the-moz...

Jesse and company have been writing lots of other fuzzers that aren't public yet as well...

Seriously, what you described above (pre-checkin code review and fuzz-testing) are all standard industry practices for web browsers and have been for years.

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by ootachi on Thursday December 15, 2011 @11:47PM (#3359458)
You could have verified the assumption that Mozilla doesn't do code review in 5 minutes here: http://hg.mozilla.org/mozilla-central/

What do you think the "r=" lines are?

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by jsight on Thursday December 15, 2011 @08:52AM (#3356091)
Actually, we are trading a browser from a company with a desktop monopoly and an internet monopoly for an environment in which said monopoly has ~40%, another monopoly has ~30%, an independent player has ~20%, and a bunch of smaller players (including Mobile) share the rest. And both the ~30 and ~20 are platform independent, largely FOSS systems.

This certainly seems like an improvement to me.

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by magicalist on Thursday December 15, 2011 @01:28PM (#3357287)
exactly. Mozilla has often been great for pushing the web forward, but it's still made up of humans, so if they "win", it is unlikely to be an improvement for users or the web.

It's almost ridiculous how lucky we are to in fact have three major market-share holders with largely compatible platforms competing for our attention.

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by chrislomax on Thursday December 15, 2011 @08:25AM (#3355994)
I too would have liked Firefox to win but I think it's nothing to do with advertising the reason for Firefox declining and it's simply that Firefox has lost it's mojo. From version 4 they killed their browser.

They may have redeemed themselves recently but I wouldn't care to look, Chrome picked up where Mozilla left off. Chrome is a fantastic browser and I never have issue with it. Firefox 4 and 5 used to crash at least once per day. If it wasn't crashing then the ram usage was spiralling out of control.

I would rather put my trust in Google than Microsoft, I believe that Google have the interest of a faster more up to date web than Microsoft do and I go with their values.

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by wizard_2 on Thursday December 15, 2011 @08:49AM (#3356082)
I live in Chrome and Firefox all day for web development. Firefox is playing catch up but they didn't kill their browser. Maybe just starved it for a while. And while I agree I'd rather google then microsoft have browser dominance, they're not perfect and shouldn't reign supreme.

In the past month, Google has advertised on the new tab page for their chrome book using a mechanism for emergency updates (in some cases people can't close the ad), and started a fight in the chromium community about supporting Dart directly. Neither one is a major offence but both exhibit they have their own interests at heart.

Spdy is another good example. (I like Spdy, and I think its a good idea, but...) SPDY™ is trademarked to Google. It currently has no rfc. (Just a mostly empty draft. http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-agl-tls-nextprotoneg-00.htm... ) It was developed internally and not opened to comments. They control the largest implementations both server and client side. And while they're selling it as a way for everyone to make the web faster, they still have full control. (Apache support is here, nginx doesn't support it, Amazon uses it heavily for the kindle fire.)

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by j_col on Thursday December 15, 2011 @08:41AM (#3356050)
> I would rather put my trust in Google than Microsoft, I believe that Google have the interest of a faster more up to date web than Microsoft do and I go with their values.

As someone who is deeply concerned with Google's dominance of the Web (and increasingly mobile), I would dearly love for you to list out your reasons for trusting them, so that I can change my mind. In the meantime I'll stick to Firefox, loss of mojo or otherwise.

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by chrislomax on Thursday December 15, 2011 @09:10AM (#3356160)
Can I ask a question, what phone do you have?
Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by j_col on Thursday December 15, 2011 @09:12AM (#3356170)
HP Pre3 (unlocked) with webOS.
Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by chrislomax on Thursday December 15, 2011 @09:17AM (#3356189)
So do you generally stay away from dominant companies who are the ones innovating?
Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by j_col on Thursday December 15, 2011 @09:39AM (#3356278)
You don't think webOS is innovative because it isn't dominating? Therefore you believe there is a relationship between domination and innovation? I'm sorry, but I disagree. Brand loyalty, marketing, and just plain inertia factor into all of these technology choices that we make every day, including what browser we use. I choose not to use Chrome, not because I think its dominating, but I do not share your trust in the company behind it (and you have yet to explain why you do).
Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by chrislomax on Thursday December 15, 2011 @10:03AM (#3356393)
Although I should have mentioned this in an earlier response, you have actually twisted my words. I actually said

>I would rather put my trust in Google than Microsoft, I believe that Google have the interest of a faster more up to date web than Microsoft do and I go with their values.

Not I trust Google over every company in the world. And I state my reasons for trusting Google over Microsoft. Because I think they are more in tune with the values of what I think the web should be about.

Yes I also think the more domineering companies are the most innovative. Do you think if WebOS was so innovative and fantastic HP would have canned it? Would HP (or google) be anywhere near the level of phone we have today if it wasn't for the iPhone?

You're right in that it has a lot to do with marketing and Google would not have got Chrome to where it is today without their ability to market it but if it was crap then there would have been no uptake? They don't get a 25% browser share from developing something that doesn't work?

Look at Google Wave, massive marketing, everyone looked forward to it and it was rubbish. It's not all about marketing or love for a brand. It's a mixture of everything. I also don't start dismissing a companies products because they are getting too big, I don't want the next best thing, I was the best tool for the job. Regardless of who it is (within realms of common sense)

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by icebraining on Thursday December 15, 2011 @09:34AM (#3356252)
I'm a Google fanboy, but I'm not sure if I want them to have a majority in the web browser space.

While they do move faster than MS, they also seem to have an habit of working on something internally, then one day they announce the feature in Chrome, dump a library to the other browsers and expect them to just integrate it. And since they control the biggest websites, there's immediately an unfair pressure; "Oh, you don't want to use SPDY? Well, then your browser will be slower on Google sites than Chrome" (they don't say - or probably even think - that, of course, but it's true)

Mozilla talks a lot about their development and seems to be more interested in a better web, and not just a better browser.

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by wycats on Thursday December 15, 2011 @12:01PM (#3356901)
SPDY is not a good example. Google published the SPDY protocol before they rolled it out across all their properties, and Firefox has implemented it:

https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=528288

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by chrislomax on Thursday December 15, 2011 @10:44AM (#3356562)
I kind of agree but I think in another respect they have looked at an ageing protocol and made it better. They may not have consulted with everyone but it also doesn't mean that everyone will implement or agree with what they are doing.

They are not forcing SPDY on people but I am looking forward to an integration into IIS when it does happen.

They have created something in a hope that it does standardise the way we make web requests.

Microsoft actually did this without telling anyone years ago, at least google is open about it.

http://osdir.com/ml/mozilla.devel.netlib/2003-01/msg00018.ht...

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by icebraining on Thursday December 15, 2011 @03:44PM (#3357857)
Sure, but being better than a convicted monopoly abuser isn't a badge of honor ;)
Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by seanp2k2 on Thursday December 15, 2011 @04:30PM (#3358110)
It could be worse -- Oracle could have a popular browser. Error: OHTTP 419: please insert coin to continue request.
Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by seminal on Thursday December 15, 2011 @05:17PM (#3358299)
LOL
Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by mike-cardwell on Thursday December 15, 2011 @08:42AM (#3356052)
"I too would have liked Firefox to win"

"They may have redeemed themselves recently but I wouldn't care to look"

These two sentences feel contradictory to me. If you want Firefox to win, at least give it a try once every few versions.

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by chrislomax on Thursday December 15, 2011 @09:08AM (#3356150)
Although they seem a contradiction my argument is that they took on a development life cycle that was far above their means.

I would have loved Firefox to come out on top as for me they changed the web when they introduced tabs but they have been slow on innovation since. I feel Chrome gave them a kick and they responded, companies shouldn't operate like that, innovation should continue regardless.

I say I wouldn't care to look because I have moved on, Chrome goes above and beyond what I want from a browser, speed and stability. If Chrome starts to go in the direction of how Firefox went I would have no issue in trying another browser. I don't have time for allegiance to a browser, I just need it to work.

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by lukeschlather on Thursday December 15, 2011 @12:06PM (#3356915)
If any individual browser wins, we've lost the browser wars. As long as chrome and firefox are roughly even and together over 50% I'm content. Honestly I'm not sure I would want it any other way.
Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by mzarate06 on Thursday December 15, 2011 @09:02AM (#3356123)
So we're trading a browser from a company with a desktop monopoly for one with a web search monopoly. I'm trying to get excited here.

Despite your sentiment, this is still moving the web forward. We all benefit from browsers built by vendors that have a genuine passion for the web. I'd argue that most believe Chrome is built from such passion more so than IE.

Since you brought up Firefox - I've always been on their side, up until I started living w/pain due to their decision to drop support for WebSQLDatabase. I'm now rooting for Chrome!

Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by ootachi on Thursday December 15, 2011 @11:45AM (#3356832)
Firefox never supported Web SQL. There was no support to drop.
Re:Chrome 15 Is Now World’s Most Popular Browser (Version) by mzarate06 on Thursday December 15, 2011 @06:56PM (#3358669)
You're right, my mistake. I should have said "to not support" instead of "to drop support for".