News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trolls (2008) by _delirium on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @04:42PM (#3353729)
I like honest discussion also, but also enjoy discussion that's "playful" in various ways, especially when it's on the gray-area border between serious and trollish. You can get interesting sides of people when they have something of an alibi because they aren't "really" saying something (but aren't "really" not doing so, either).

I do think it's probably better if it's in areas where there's at least tacit agreement that those are the local discussion norms, though. If you post somewhere like SomethingAwful's FYAD (though I haven't taken a look in a few years), or 4chan, you can hardly claim to be surprised or misled by the conversational norms. On HN, the local culture prefers a different style of discussion, and I like that in its own way as well. Though I also liked some subset of Slashdot trolls in their heyday, even though they weren't officially welcome at Slashdot: OGG THE CAVEMAN, the BSD Troll, and a few others were some of the more interesting posters, some mixture of net-art and actual discussion.

Re:Trolls (2008) by scott_s on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @04:50PM (#3353775)
Playful discussion requires familiarity and trust. Trolls poison trust.
Re:Trolls (2008) by angersock on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @05:27PM (#3353988)
Even in the most openly hostile troll communities (FYAD, /b/, etc.) there is a solid "trust": you will be trolled.

This idea of trust is a very strange thing, to me. If I present an argument or point logically and it is accepted, then there is no problem. If I do so and it is rejected logically, there is no problem. If I do so and are assailed with noise and rubbish, then it is usually pretty clear that it's just garbage and to be ignored.

If I seek affirmation and reassurance from people online instead of flesh-and-blood folks I can talk to directly, I being to wonder if this is actually an okay state of affairs. If my support group could be replaced with a bunch of clever Python scripts, Markov models, and machine learning algos, I would suggest that something is deeply wrong--and that is exactly the sort of inscrutable interface forums provide.

Only when you start to "trust" the personas you encounter online and become invested in your model of them do you actually run the risk of getting hurt. Treat it like a game, learning what you can when you can and ignoring the rabble, and things go best.

:)

Re:Trolls (2008) by scott_s on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @05:40PM (#3354045)
The kind of trust I'm talking about is trust in honest discourse. If I don't trust that others on a forum will engage with me honestly, then I am less likely to engage with them honestly. As a consequence, the overall discussion on the forum degrades.
Re:Trolls (2008) by _delirium on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @05:43PM (#3354057)
I don't strictly disagree, but imo you're trying to generalize a personal preference for discussion styles into general observations, by using normative and inflammatory (is "inflammatory" like "trollish"?) terms like "poison" and "degrades", as opposed to "I don't like".
Re:Trolls (2008) by libraryatnight on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @06:17PM (#3354182)
But when a community has set a precedent and an expectation for trust and respectful discussion, it is poisoning and degrading that community to come in and disrupt it intentionally for your own amusement. If you dump toxic waste into a pool, you've poisoned the pool, accusing the fish of just not liking it doesn't work.
Re:Trolls (2008) by _delirium on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @06:19PM (#3354186)
He appears to be arguing that it's bad even when the community doesn't have that precedent/expectation, though (my examples were of communities where various varieties of "trolling" are expected/normal, like SA's FYAD, and 4chan's /b/). Plus, ecosystems are complex; Slashdot's is a bit of a mix. You can't napalm the "intruders" and accuse everyone burnt by napalm of just not liking it!
Re:Trolls (2008) by scott_s on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @07:17PM (#3354403)
Then preface everything I say with the places I want to spend my time behave as:
Re:Trolls (2008) by libraryatnight on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @07:03PM (#3354355)
lol, good point :)
Re:Trolls (2008) by angersock on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @05:54PM (#3354104)
Out of genuine curiosity, how would you define "honest discourse"?

Online forums are, by definition, right there on the 'net along with Google and Wikipedia and other resources, so flat-out misrepresentation of facts seems somewhat difficult. If somebody chooses to be irrational, they are readily identified as such, right? So where does honesty fit in all this?

Re:Trolls (2008) by billswift on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @07:33PM (#3354447)
Every time I have seen (or heard in person), "I would like to participate in and read honest discussion", it has been someone who turned around and accused anyone who disagreed of "trolling" or of being "close-minded". I have found it a waste of time arguing with them, if it hadn't been the general topic of this thread, I would have just ignored the comment entirely.
Re:Trolls (2008) by scott_s on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @07:25PM (#3354432)
Honest discourse is when both parties are willing to work to understand each other, and not just trying to "win." Both parties default to the most reasonable interpretation of what the other says - having all of the facts available doesn't help much if you spend most of your time clarifying what you're trying to say.
Re:Trolls (2008) by _delirium on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @04:51PM (#3353788)
I guess I just frankly disagree with that, though perhaps we have some different definition of "trolls". I haven't seen more trust (and community) in a forum than in the more playful/trollish forums I've been part of. Too much seriousness, on the other hand, I think poisons intellectual discussion.
Re:Trolls (2008) by libraryatnight on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @05:07PM (#3353869)
HN is a good example, I'm not afraid to post an idea, a response, or understanding, here. I know that if I'm wrong, but I presented my thought well with reasoning, I'll receive an honest and intelligent response as to why I am wrong or why someone differs in opinion. That's trust. Trust in a community to respect each other.
Re:Trolls (2008) by Tsagadai on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @07:52PM (#3354512)
Trust on the internet is dangerous. You should exercise your judgement and not let it be impaired by a perceived absence of trolls. There are trolls, flamebaiters, astroturfers, bots, vested interests, paid posters and spammers everywhere on the internet. Once upon a time, appeal to authority arguments actually influenced most of the population. Let us not go back there, it is better for us all if we don't trust everything we see and hear.

I'm a very trusting person. I don't lock my doors, for instance. But I exercise, or at least I like to think I exercise, a healthy scepticism without falling into paranoia. You can never really know or understand what everyone else's motivations and intentions are and you should remember that fact at all times.

Re:Trolls (2008) by jarin on Wednesday December 14, 2011 @04:46PM (#3353755)
FYAD isn't what it used to be, but I agree that it's part of what made SA great. Not necessarily the actual content of FYAD, but the fact that it kept everyone outside of FYAD in check. The other forums did a great job of keeping the post quality high (no AOL speak, etc.), and FYAD did a great job of making sure they didn't get too full of themselves. Even if you were the most popular poster ever, there was always one forum that you would never, ever be accepted in.