Re:Theranos Founder Elizabeth Holmes Is Denied a Bid for New...
by notch656a on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @03:15PM
(#33523691)
I always thought it was interesting feds don't have jurisdiction over most murder as it doesn't fit into one of the constitution approved uses of the government, but somehow merely sawing down a shotgun barrel or feeding crops you grow to your own animals is considered 'interstate trade' and thus subject to federal law. As if murder doesn't have effect on interstate trade at least as much as Filburn's crops did.
That does not follow, at all.
The US Attorney's office cannot bring charges against violations of state law, and medicine is largely regulated by the individual states in the US. Additionally, the evidence in a particular case might make it easier to prove some charges than others. That's not a value judgement that one crime is "worse" than another. That's just reality.
The Feds prosecuted Al Capone for tax evasion -- not because anybody thinks tax crimes are more serious than murder, but a) that's what they had jurisdiction over and b) it is what they could prove in court.