It's a set of group policy settings that can be used to manage and prevent almost all of the "phoning home", and it documents what is done etc.
https://learn.microsoft.com/en-gb/windows/privacy/manage-con...
It would be interesting to then do a private CA intercept (a la mitmproxy) on the resulting system to validate whether this correctly stops everything.
My gut feeling is that they don't straight up lie, but that they for sure are leaving things out. Also putting good faith on microsoft is just something I'm not able to do no matter how much I try.
Don't you need to buy the enterprise version to completely turn off telemetry?
Except the fact that they get informed every time you run any software on your Mac, and they even used to send that over HTTP, in the clear (I'm hoping it's changed). The reported purpose is to check software signatures live, for security or something. I personally think code signing isn't of a huge benefit for the user, and there is no need for live checks (instead of cache or Certificate Revocation Lists) to be performed. The only reason i can think for Apple to implement it this way is to collect data on what you do with your device ostensibly for "security", but it might just be a negative way of looking at things.
I don't believe that's true for all telemetry data; there's an option between enhanced & core/basic or similar, but it cannot be disabled.
I use windows as my daily driver for both work and home and what kills me, and your argument IMO, is that forced updates turn on new features and old ones that I've disabled, and dark patterns put your typical user in a state where the only available option appears to be enabling the function. Cortana is a great example of this, if you accidently run it while disabled (how is that even possible?) you cannot exit, and the UI implies you need to continue, which gets you to enable it. You can't quit, only minimize to the tray, then the dialog pops up frequently. You need to end the process from the process explorer, which most users are not going to do.
I used to buy all windows computers directly from the Microsoft store because they were optimized to run windows as well as possible, so had no bloatware or add-on garbage. now Windows itself includes all these features and add-ons, which seems so short-sighted.
Moreover, Microsoft and Apple can do essentially anything they want to. They have an unassailable stranglehold on the desktop OS market.
I believe Apple's true stance on this is, "we will protect your data from third parties, but in exchange, you have no privacy with us"
On top of that, you can use network-level tools to block your data from leaving your home. This could be something like a pihole that blocks the relevant domains, and/or a firewall that blocks them entirely.
At least on paper, Apple does seem to be doing better on privacy. They are private by default. Again, this all depends on how much you believe they aren't lying. There are also edge cases with them. For example, iMessage is encrypted end to end, but if you make an iCloud backup of your iMessages, those are not completely protected.
If someone is that paranoid about the OS being the point of failure their privacy, open source OSes are available for them to use. I'm personally not concerned about using Windows, MacOS, iOS, or even Android as long as I am thorough about configuring all the settings in the OS and my network appropriately.