News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:#proofInAToot by LeoPanthera on Sunday November 06, 2022 @03:18PM (#33496631)
If you just want to read posts on Mastodon, you don't need to sign up at all.

You only need to sign up (just once) if you want to follow people, or post yourself.

You can read all (public) posts on all instances either way.

Re:#proofInAToot by robswc on Sunday November 06, 2022 @03:35PM (#33496786)
Interesting.

So I swear this is not on purpose, but I went to try to see what thing I would be interested in. I searched "Mastodon Technology" and it leads me here:

https://mastodon.technology/about

It says it's shutting down though? So they can just shut down and if you don't migrate your account in time, you're SoL ?

I do understand a bit more now. I remember being interested in it around 2019 and it was a bit confusing then.

Your comment clears it up quite a bit.

Re:#proofInAToot by rolenthedeep on Sunday November 06, 2022 @04:00PM (#33497085)
Yes, but if Twitter shut down, you wouldn't have any more options.

That server got too big for its admin team to handle. The general sentiment around mastodon is that it's sad, but it isn't a bad thing. The admins did their best, but it's in everyone's best interest to shut it down gracefully rather than let it fester. All the users will migrate to new communities and continue on.

Mastodon has a problem with scaling individual instances. It works best when there are a lot of relatively small instances. Once you get too many users, server resources get tight FAST. My instance has gone down three times for upgrades this week, and the admin has had to suspend new user registration because the server just can't keep up.

Re:#proofInAToot by appletrotter on Sunday November 06, 2022 @04:41PM (#33497572)
> The general sentiment is… it isn't a bad thing

The general tone has seemed very defensive

Re:#proofInAToot by rolenthedeep on Sunday November 06, 2022 @05:39PM (#33498251)
The discussion I've seen frames it something like this:

Servers rise and fall, it's part of the life cycle here. The admins couldn't handle the size of the server, and it was causing a rapidly degrading experience for everyone. Shutting down the server was mostly in the best personal interests of the admin, but people seem to be respecting them for that. They did the responsible thing by shutting down new registration, making very loud announcements, and giving everyone as much time as possible to migrate their accounts.

In other words, any instance will shut down sooner or later, and the way the admin handled this particular case is the most respectful way to treat the users.

Sad that it happened, but much respect for handling it as gracefully as possible.

Re:#proofInAToot by appletrotter on Sunday November 06, 2022 @07:26PM (#33499396)
> any instance will shut down sooner or later

Just another thing for users to be worried about.

Re:#proofInAToot by easrng on Sunday November 06, 2022 @08:48PM (#33500037)
I've moved twice so far (didn't like the (lack of) moderation on the first instance I was on, the second one is shutting down in a bit and they gave everyone advance notice so we all moved off) and it's very painless, not worrying at all.
Re:#proofInAToot by rolenthedeep on Monday November 07, 2022 @08:23AM (#33505468)
No, not any more than you worry about Twitter shutting down.

And when Twitter does eventually shut down, all of those users will lose their accounts and followers forever with no recourse. When a mastodon server shuts down, you click the 'migrate account' button and continue like nothing happened.

Re:#proofInAToot by appletrotter on Monday November 07, 2022 @11:42AM (#33508237)
Twitter has never shut down before. As has been said, instances go down all the time.
Re:#proofInAToot by robswc on Sunday November 06, 2022 @04:18PM (#33497293)
>Yes, but if Twitter shut down, you wouldn't have any more options

That's totally fair. You're also SoL if you don't agree with their policies, etc. So I'm definitely not a fan of the way that works.

>Mastodon has a problem with scaling individual instances

That's unfortunate to hear. Seems like a "core" issue though... I mean, if it approaches anywhere near the number of DAU twitter has... no idea how that would work, logistically.

Seems it would have to come full-circle where hosters have incentive beyond "hobby" and "clout" reasons.

Re:#proofInAToot by rolenthedeep on Sunday November 06, 2022 @05:57PM (#33498450)
There are a lot of things to complain about in the core of mastodon as a piece of software. That's a big part of why there are so many alternatives built on the same protocol.

The idea is that by spreading the users amongst many smaller servers, everyone has a pretty responsive experience while still being able to (hypothetically) interact with as many users as on Twitter.