…
> And then there's the prospect of the Taiwanese not even WANTING to fight their own brethren.
You make a lot of confident assumptions here which you cannot know for sure.
Not to mention given that China has been at peace for decades now, to disrupt their economic growth and prosperous gains in standards of living to go to war would be a hard sell to the average Chinese citizen, regardless of how much control the government might exert over drumming up support for war. One could speculate that they would at least make it seem like a defensive conflict.
And Xi has sworn to unite Taiwan with the mainland at whatever the cost. We have to decide whether it's worth fighting a nuclear war over because the invasion is going to happen between now and 2027.
> And Xi has sworn to unite Taiwan with the mainland at whatever the cost.
In that, he is no different from every single Chinese leader since 1949.
2027 is a red herring borne out of inaccurate intel and failed understanding:
He's trying to do something about it at least, but Apple has already signaled that only 25% of iPhones will be made outside of China by 2025. That will leave the company completely vulnerable if were to be cut-off from its Chinese suppliers. I predict the company will simply go bankrupt if that were to happen.
So he's bluffing to prevent China from invading, that's only logical. If push comes to shove, however, he'll pull back from the brink. Taiwan simply isn't worth fighting over, even if it would mean losing influence in Asia.
And I've become convinced the Taiwanese will not fight their own kind, no matter how much they hate the Communists.
That's the second time you've made that claim, and it's just as implausible as it was the first time. Companies go bankrupt because of debt. Apple has approximately zero debt, and approximately one gazillion dollars of assets. Losing China's manufacturing would cripple Apple's income. Bankrupt them? No, that's not a logically plausible outcome.
> And I've become convinced the Taiwanese will not fight their own kind, no matter how much they hate the Communists.
That's the second time you've made that claim, too, with no more supporting evidence than you gave the first time. You're convinced? Great, it's good for you to know your own mind. But the rest of us care whether your claim corresponds to reality, and how convinced you are is not supporting data.
Putin has claimed all along that Ukrainians were "their own kind", but the Ukrainians didn't see it that way...
There's no company that could survive such a financial shock. Yes, they have some money in the bank, but that won't save them.
Look, it would be very damaging. I don't deny it. Bankruptcy, though? No. You're being an alarmist.
> And I've become convinced the Taiwanese will not fight their own kind, no matter how much they hate the Communists.
Well I guess all we can do is wait and see if these predictions of yours come through.
You talk about defending yourself, but you can just keep still and do nothing. As I expect you will.
A nuclear war is a certainty when there's a confrontation between nuclear armed powers. If we lose, we use nukes. If they lose, they'll use nukes. Ergo: it's inevitable there will be an all-out nuclear exchange.
Were you referring to the Taiwanese people? The Taiwanese army? The Taiwanese government? The specific person that said they would defend themself?
Do you also feel that a nuclear war is inevitable between Russia and the US because of what is happening currently in the Ukraine?
Whether the US joins the fight is very much still up for debate. Whether “the Taiwanese” will fight - is probably better left for actual Taiwanese people to comment on.
A nuclear war is not inevitable in Ukraine because the U.S. isn't a combatant. But I do believe this conflict could easily spiral out of control and lead to a nuclear confrontation between Russia and NATO.
If the U.S. were to intervene in Taiwan it would mean a direct confrontation between two nuclear armed powers which, as I claimed before, will inevitably lead to an all-out nuclear exchange.
> And then there's the prospect of the Taiwanese not even WANTING to fight their own brethren. Sure, they want to remain independent if they can, but if China decides to invade their armed forces will simply throw away their arms and go home. Do we want our soldiers to lose their lives for a people that hasn't even demonstrated their will to fight for their independence? Fuck that!
For the US, the war over Taiwan is not about Taiwan. It is essential to understand this. It is why the US will definitively go to war. If China takes Taiwan, US influence and interest in the entire region falls like dominoes.
The threat to US hegemony is more important than the market value of a few companies.
Losing Taiwan may give us a bloody nose, but it's certainly not an existential threat.
What Biden says about intervening is just bluff. And China knows this.
And then there's the prospect of the Taiwanese not even WANTING to fight their own brethren. Sure, they want to remain independent if they can, but if China decides to invade their armed forces will simply throw away their arms and go home. Do we want our soldiers to lose their lives for a people that hasn't even demonstrated their will to fight for their independence? Fuck that!
China is attempting to put its tentacles everywhere, making it extremely costly for Western nations to completely decouple from China economically.
For example: Apple is so deep in bed with China that if an invasion were to occur the company would simply go bankrupt. Bankrupt! We're talking about a company with a market valuation of almost $2 trillion!! It would be very hard for the Biden Administration to make that choice. And that's just one U.S. company. There are probably dozens like them in the same boat.
From what I gather Volkswagen would face an existential threat if it were banned from selling its cars in China. No way, the Germans would allow that, no matter what the U.S. says.
No, there will not be a nuclear war over Taiwan. Merely a few pinpricks in terms of sanctions.