Re:Study urges caution when comparing neural networks to the...
by tobyjsullivan on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:37PM
(#33459516)
This is definitely what I was thinking about when I started my comment. I torpedoed my own point with the comment about the model being "too useful". Your explanation is much better.
When I said "I can't stop," I was referring more to this tendency to borrow models to explain unrelated systems. It's just a thing my brain wants to do and I can't help it (and again, I seem to convince myself that it's somehow accurate or useful even if, rationally, I'm quite sure it's not).
Re:Study urges caution when comparing neural networks to the...
by colechristensen on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:53PM
(#33459682)
Yup, unrelated things do indeed often look and behave in similar ways. Humans are just a little bit overdriven to find patterns and end up finding some that don’t exist. It’s a useful trait for finding difficult patterns and there’s probably a stable point to maximize benefits which lands on finding a few too many.
Re:Study urges caution when comparing neural networks to the...
by JJMcJ on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:45PM
(#33459607)
Or how the Matrix movies came out and suddenly "Are we living in a simulation?" became an immensely important philosophical question.
Re:Study urges caution when comparing neural networks to the...
by goatlover on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:32PM
(#33460592)
It isn't really that much different than, "Are we living in a dream?", of the movie Inception that's been asked since antiquity. Is the world some sort of illusion? How would we know?
These "just so" stories are attractive but it is quite important to realize a metaphor which is intuitive and you perceive as useful is nothing at all like the process for finding real scientific truth. There is also a lot of introspective value to modeling the world as being controlled by mysterious gods who are pleased or appalled at your behavior and that's why good and bad things happen. Perhaps useful for some people but nothing at all like truth.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-so_story