Re:Blender Apps
by smcnally on Thursday November 03, 2022 @05:07AM
(#33448631)
While Blender already lets you make workspaces as sparse as you like them, Apps focused on specific usage can make complex 3D + ffmpeg + python options more approachable. A ‘.blendx’ focused on Resizing video, Making quick cuts, Exporting to GIF, MP4 other formats would be handy, e.g.
Blender Python API is a horrible mess, and it's more an automation API (similar to say selenium) than a Web API in the browser. Which means Blender makes it completely impossible to customize some functions, without having to write C++ and recompile the whole source. All you can do really is script the interface and automate operations.
GODOT is very good at creating apps on the other hand. I've seen many cool authoring tools made with it, a bit similar to Adobe Air in its time.
So it's a nice idea,but Blender Python API needs to completely be refactored for it work.
> “As an architect, I want to send a client a project so that they can navigate around and experience it by themselves.” In this case, the app should be easy to run even if the client has never heard of Blender or 3D software before. You could prepare the scene, add basic navigation controls, and bundle the project .blend files together with Blender itself.
Sounds oddly like the Blender Game Engine, that was removed in 2.80...
Re:Blender Apps
by smcnally on Thursday November 03, 2022 @02:38PM
(#33455418)
200MB for the core + video, image, material assets does sound large. Checking the last 10 phone apps I updated showed they were @ 150MB - 300MB -- Not a great precedent, but bundle size is unlikely to faze people if the app provides them utility.
So this opens up a ton of possibilities for distributing content creation tools.
But the licensing is problematic.
>General Public License
Unlike making a 3D modeling app in Unity , you have to open source your Blender derived app.
Up until I read that line I assumed it exported some binary which could be closed sourced. I personally want content creation tools, but I respect programers don't want to work for free.
Re:Blender Apps
by Mikeb85 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @01:21AM
(#33447336)
> Up until I read that line I assumed it exported some binary which could be closed sourced. I personally want content creation tools, but I respect programers don't want to work for free.
This is for artists, not programmers. And art assets don't have to follow code licenses. Ie. You have to share your code but you can keep copyright to your assets.
Re:Blender Apps
by Mikeb85 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:33PM
(#33459475)
No it's to share visualisations and stuff, similar to a game, but let's face it - the code is going to be incredibly basic, generic and not worth protecting.
Re:Blender Apps
by poulpy123 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @02:14AM
(#33447658)
The licence isn't problematic, a blender app is a customized version of blender so of course it inherits the blender licence. If someone wants a closed blender there are many alternatives
Seems like Godot already does what Blender Apps does much better:
- Godot is great at importing Blender models/scenes.
- Blender is GPL, Godot is MIT.
- Godot produces much lighter .exe files. Blender Apps are at least 200MB.
- Godot has web export, too.
Godot still has stability issues that can affect larger projects (presently over 7000 open issues on Github[1]) but for smaller demos and art things Godot usually is pretty solid.
Re:Blender Apps
by andrewflnr on Thursday November 03, 2022 @03:36AM
(#33448101)
Blender apps as described here seem to be for an entirely different class of use cases. Basically stripped-down versions of Blender itself rather than games, art or whatever. Blender used to have a "game engine" that was more like what I understand Godot to be, but IIRC scrapped it.
> Basically stripped-down versions of Blender itself
Okay, that makes sense. The video on the linked Blender Apps page shows this really simple app where one drags models around and then drags materials onto the models to give the model that material. So something simple like that would work better in Godot. But Blender's 3D modeler is way more powerful than Godot's but has a very steep learning curve so distributing a simpler version of Blender's modeler could definitely make sense.
Re:Blender Apps
by asfodelsu on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:31AM
(#33449519)
Something like a BIM architecture app will be a good idea. Blender makes some progress on this, but an architect or a civil engineer needs an architect gui.
I also hope some day the blender UI becomes a separate gui toolkit for non graphics app. Like a file manager
[Media Viewer by Blender Studio](https://studio.blender.org/blog/media-viewer-by-blender-stud...) looks solid. I want to see more of the ‘Review’ / ‘Annotation’ tools.
GODOT is very good at creating apps on the other hand. I've seen many cool authoring tools made with it, a bit similar to Adobe Air in its time.
So it's a nice idea,but Blender Python API needs to completely be refactored for it work.
> “As an architect, I want to send a client a project so that they can navigate around and experience it by themselves.” In this case, the app should be easy to run even if the client has never heard of Blender or 3D software before. You could prepare the scene, add basic navigation controls, and bundle the project .blend files together with Blender itself.
Sounds oddly like the Blender Game Engine, that was removed in 2.80...
But the licensing is problematic.
>General Public License
Unlike making a 3D modeling app in Unity , you have to open source your Blender derived app.
Up until I read that line I assumed it exported some binary which could be closed sourced. I personally want content creation tools, but I respect programers don't want to work for free.
This is for artists, not programmers. And art assets don't have to follow code licenses. Ie. You have to share your code but you can keep copyright to your assets.
- Godot is great at importing Blender models/scenes.
- Blender is GPL, Godot is MIT.
- Godot produces much lighter .exe files. Blender Apps are at least 200MB.
- Godot has web export, too.
Godot still has stability issues that can affect larger projects (presently over 7000 open issues on Github[1]) but for smaller demos and art things Godot usually is pretty solid.
[1] https://github.com/godotengine/godot/issues
Okay, that makes sense. The video on the linked Blender Apps page shows this really simple app where one drags models around and then drags materials onto the models to give the model that material. So something simple like that would work better in Godot. But Blender's 3D modeler is way more powerful than Godot's but has a very steep learning curve so distributing a simpler version of Blender's modeler could definitely make sense.
I also hope some day the blender UI becomes a separate gui toolkit for non graphics app. Like a file manager