Re:Rate Hikes Are Affecting the Economy
by eastAligned on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @12:41AM
(#33431517)
Probaby just a simple way to renove standard clickbait formats; I think in this case "The effect of rate hikes on the economy" would be the desired title.
Re:Rate Hikes Are Affecting the Economy
by silisili on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @12:48AM
(#33431536)
Maybe it's just me, but 'How rate hikes' feels like it would be a more approachable article.
'The effect of rate hikes' sounds more scientific, like a link to some economics paper I'd likely not make much sense of.
Re:Rate Hikes Are Affecting the Economy
by simonebrunozzi on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @01:04AM
(#33431621)
I agree with you. When I post, I quite often correct the title that HN culls, because otherwise the sense of the title becomes quite different.
We do it because leading hows are most often linkbait. It works well on balance.
However, literally all the attention goes to the failure cases. When successes aren't counted and failures are, it's unsurprising that a system seems not to work well. This is a problem with title edits in general.
Maybe it would help if we built software for users to suggest title edits.
My first instinct was, even before skimming the actual article, to comment a snarky “well, yes that’s kind of the point.” But then I decided to click on the link and see that the actual title of the article is “__HOW__ Rate Hikes Are Affecting the Economy,” which actually makes sense and denotes something completely different than it does when the “how” is omitted.
Can anyone explain why HN’s submission script does this? Because IMO it is more of a nuisance than having any perceived benefits. I understand that it is perhaps just a mechanism to shorten titles, but I think the feature should be removed (no pun intended!)