News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NYC to Require Salary Ranges Be Included in Job Postings by zerr on Monday October 31, 2022 @02:53PM (#33410815)
If your client tells you secretly that the base salary range for the position is 200K-250K. And the prospective employee tells that s/he wants 150K. Would you disclose that s/he can ask up to 250K or would you rather make your client happy by getting them a bargain?
Re:NYC to Require Salary Ranges Be Included in Job Postings by andrewstuart on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:01PM (#33410974)
>> would you rather make your client happy by getting them a bargain

Recruiters are usually paid based on a percentage of the salary. It's actually in the interests of the recruiter that you are paid as much as possible, strictly speaking.

In reality, my goals as recruiter are:

* happy client

* find a new employee who the employer is super happy with six months down the track

* find a new employee who wants and enjoys this job, and will thus stay

* at a salary that the new employee is happy with, that will not have them looking over their shoulder thinking they have udnersold themselves

* at a salary that will ensure we are not beaten to the punch by another higher paying employer

* at a salary that fits the goals of the employer

The idea of "getting an employer a bargain" implies that I don't care about the job seeker. Believe it or not, I do. When someone comes to me who is a great developer, and is asking under market rates, I discuss that will them and let them know where I think market rate is for their skills and experience.

It might sound cliched, but my job is to negotiate a deal that everyone is happy with, and every gets what they want. Anything less will fail because the employee feels they are underpaid, or the employer feels they overpaid.

I believe the above approach to dealing with salary gets everyone what they want. And yes, I the more it is the happier I am, but it would be very much against my interests to manipulate that.

Re:NYC to Require Salary Ranges Be Included in Job Postings by humanrebar on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:29PM (#33411444)
> Recruiters are usually paid based on a percentage of the salary. It's actually in the interests of the recruiter that you are paid as much as possible, strictly speaking.

Seems like a recruiter is much more likely to double his compensation by spending half as much time per hire versus paying twice as much, given that salaries are relatively inelastic. Similarly, real estate agents are incentivized to get a pretty good price but mostly optimize for lower effort per sale.

Re:NYC to Require Salary Ranges Be Included in Job Postings by tschwimmer on Monday October 31, 2022 @05:33PM (#33413549)
Thank you! It's almost exactly the same as real estate agents or anyone who takes a small % of a transaction: they are incentivized to prioritize throughput above (and often at the expense of) anything else.
Re:NYC to Require Salary Ranges Be Included in Job Postings by scarface74 on Monday October 31, 2022 @04:44PM (#33412779)
> Recruiters are usually paid based on a percentage of the salary. It's actually in the interests of the recruiter that you are paid as much as possible, strictly speaking.

Similar studies for real estate agents who are also paid on commission shows that this is not true. It’s more about velocity than optimizing a single candidate.

https://freakonomics.com/2008/02/real-estate-agents-revisite...

Re:NYC to Require Salary Ranges Be Included in Job Postings by JAlexoid on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @03:00PM (#33425830)
And yet, I've been screwed over by recruiters many times.

Simply because recruiting is a very low barrier job - you get countless bad recruiters... even at reputable recruitment agencies - horrible child-recruiters.

Re:NYC to Require Salary Ranges Be Included in Job Postings by orev on Monday October 31, 2022 @02:55PM (#33410850)
Recruiters typically get paid a commission based on the final salary, so it’s in their interest to get you as high a salary as possible.
Re:NYC to Require Salary Ranges Be Included in Job Postings by jedberg on Monday October 31, 2022 @02:58PM (#33410915)
Much like real estate agents, their best interest is to close the deal at any price. They'll make more money getting the employer a bargain and a second req.

There is a reason real estate agents homes sell for more than anyone else's -- because they know the real value of the market and have an incentive to go high when it's their own home. Recruiters are the same.

Re:NYC to Require Salary Ranges Be Included in Job Postings by tech_tuna on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:41PM (#33411669)
Exactly, came here to say exactly this. BTW, I don't think this in inherently evil, it's just a conflict of interests. Employer. Employee. Recruiter.

Different incentives for all three parties.

Re:NYC to Require Salary Ranges Be Included in Job Postings by brianwawok on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:22PM (#33411297)
Bingo.
Re:NYC to Require Salary Ranges Be Included in Job Postings by throwaway292939 on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:22PM (#33411299)
This is incorrect. It's in their interest to get as high a salary with the least effort involved.

Obviously for them, being able to close more candidates at a "high enough" salary is preferable.