There is a big one: the employer/employee is not a balanced relationship, the employer clearly has more power over where things go. So it's absolutely normal to protect the employee from being asked too much, especially when said employee doesn't benefit from the overtime.
There is a big bias towards taking companies as important citizens whose needs must be catered for, but it's taking more and more importance when the actual citizens aren't listened to. It is important to put companies back to what they are: a social construct for exploiting people and make profit from their work.
Sure it is, they want my labor, I want to sell my labor. We agree on a price.
If my price changes, or they are unwilling to buy it any more I find a new person to buy my labor.
I was looking for a job when I found this one, and I will be looking again when I find my next one.
No.
Not when they hold an employees ability to meet basic human needs and their access to Healthcare over their employee's heads.
At-will employment is ideologically built on the equal splitting of the power between an employer and employee. The reality is as far from equal as can be.
For certain types of jobs it's still the most effective method out there.
Not saying it's worth doing, or a good job, but they're out there, especially in the smaller towns.
I personally can’t see a good reason why it should be illegal outside the rare edge case where there is only a single employer in a geographical region, and even that unfortunate situation should probably be remediated with a different type of government intervention.
Employers should be able to be unreasonable and shoot their business in the foot, no?