News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter features Mastodon is better for not having by nnopepe on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:34PM (#33398983)
mastodons biggest shortcoming remains the lack of e2e encrypted DM's. Giving volunteer internet janitors access to your private messages is a recipe for disaster
Re:Twitter features Mastodon is better for not having by VectorLock on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:41PM (#33399050)
The internet is awash in encrypted private messaging systems, why does Mastodon need one too?
Re:Twitter features Mastodon is better for not having by stevage on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:26PM (#33399582)
Because of the friction starting a public convo, going to DM, then negotiating which private messaging system to then switch to again. Most people won't bother.
Re:Twitter features Mastodon is better for not having by pavlov on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:48PM (#33399127)
Agreed. IMO the Mastodon DM system doesn’t need to do much more than to enable: “Here’s my handle on messaging service X, let’s continue there.”
Re:Twitter features Mastodon is better for not having by Kye on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:07PM (#33399342)
It's slow-going, but there is work on it: https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon/pull/13820

I think the official iOS app (and soon, Android) took priority due to its much greater impact on adoption. Encrypted DMs are a great idea, but all three people who know WTF that is aren't enough to make it a top item. Meanwhile, so many people in 2022 see the lack of an official app for something as a deal breaker. It's weird to me on my nice laptop and 24 inch screen, but a large and growing number of ordinary people are mobile-first or exclusively mobile. Pinning a web app to the home screen makes them feel like they're living in the weird long-ago times of the 2000s.

Re:Twitter features Mastodon is better for not having by Karunamon on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:49PM (#33399137)
Having person-to-person messages be unencrypted is irresponsible in 2022, the same way offering a web service for public consumption without TLS is. Encryption should be the default and the user should not have to even consider the threat of their messages being read by unauthorized parties.
Re:Twitter features Mastodon is better for not having by tptacek on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:08PM (#33399347)
The most irresponsible thing you can do is make a security promise you can't keep. Mastadon's usage is overwhelmingly browser-based; achieving reliably end-to-end security between users of browser-based apps remains an open problem. Taking a short step back from that: if you're going to try to give people secure messaging, you should have that goal from the start. Matrix is a good case study in what happens when you don't do this.

You can still high-horse Mastodon: just tell them they shouldn't have private messaging at all. That seems like a reasonable take.

Re:Twitter features Mastodon is better for not having by xypage on Sunday October 30, 2022 @10:30PM (#33401414)
Since matrix is an open standard and everything would it be possible to build a matrix client into mastodon? That would be really interesting, if it became a plug and play messaging client for open source projects that include some sort of DMs.
Re:Twitter features Mastodon is better for not having by politician on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:04PM (#33399308)
> the user should not have to even consider the threat of their messages being read.

Could you clarify whom you hope that a message should be able to be read by?

- the intended recipient(s)

- parties involved in the intermediate storage system

- middleboxes / parties in the transmission path

- unintended recipients that the intended recipients forwarded the message to accidentally

- unintended recipients that the intended recipients forwarded the message to maliciously

Re:Twitter features Mastodon is better for not having by Karunamon on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:07PM (#33399341)
Whichever follows the principle of least astonishment.

1 is obvious and I think it is bad faith that you are asking.

Re:Twitter features Mastodon is better for not having by politician on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:21PM (#33400100)
I just included it as a default case. If you want to assume malintent, that's on you. The more interesting cases are the last two because they reveal that messaging cannot be made private because you cannot prevent the counterparty from leaking information.
Re:Twitter features Mastodon is better for not having by yogthos on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:48PM (#33399118)
There are plenty of actual chat apps out there like Signal or Matrix that you should be using for this sort of thing. Neither Twitter or Mastodon are the right tool for this.