News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by Timja on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:24PM (#33398273)
A replacement could be just a protocol.

If you signed your message with "This is a reply to msg 33398198 by Timja. Signed: twblalock", then nobody could take this converstion away from us again. I could copy it and put it on any server. Owned by myself or run by some service provider. And it would always be clear to everybody that this conversation really took place between the two of us.

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by twblalock on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:26PM (#33398292)
Yeah but who would use a system like that outside of a small hardcore contingent of techies?
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by Timja on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:29PM (#33398321)
The interface could be just like Twitter or Hacker News.

In fact, users could use any service they like.

It would not matter what client you use to reply to me. Your reply would appear on Hacker News, because HN would follow the protocol and accept properly signed comments relayed to it.

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by dd36 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:17PM (#33398808)
It already exists: newsgroups.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by augustuspolius on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:36PM (#33398997)
The messages would still need to be stored somewhere, right? Is SMTP a decentralized protocol in this sense? You can send a message from any client... however most people still use centralized solutions, not their own mail servers.

In your example HN would still need to retrieve and store billions of messages, handle user authentication, discovery, aggregation, additional data handling (e.g. you want to attach a video, or go live). They will need to monetize _something_. So we are back to square one, just with a much more inconvenient client setup process (like we do right now setting up pop3/smtp/imap).

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by holler on Monday October 31, 2022 @12:56AM (#33402225)
What incentive would Twitter or Hacker News have to support the protocol?