Re:A Message from Lunny on Gitea Ltd. and the Gitea Project
by jolheiser on Sunday October 30, 2022 @12:16PM
(#33395729)
I didn't read this as open core.
The previous point from the quote was that the project remains MIT. The following point was that contracts favorable to those conditions would also be preferred and recommended.
At sounds like some contracts might need bespoke functionality to me.
Re:A Message from Lunny on Gitea Ltd. and the Gitea Project
by dachary on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:26PM
(#33396507)
The previous blog post is more explicit and reads Open Core:
> An enhanced enterprise version
But that's a general problem with these two blog posts. They leave much to interpretation. Except for one thing: Gitea Ltd is in control of the domains & the trademark and won't give them back. The days of a community led project are gone. Just like that.
It will be a pleasure to welcome you in the upcoming fork. Wouldn't you like to participate in a democratic Free Software project instead of working for free and help VC make tons of money?
Re:A Message from Lunny on Gitea Ltd. and the Gitea Project
by Master_Odin on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:01PM
(#33398641)
Except the community never really owned them, it was only Lunny who did. He could have at any point used his ownership of these things against the community. The situation hasn't changed much in that regard except that I guess everyone trusts Lunny the person more than this ltd he's created.
This gives no guarantee that everything in these "special versions" is contributed back. Might as well just say "Open Core". If that's not the case then this needs additional clarification.