News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by such12 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @11:43AM (#33385016)
Easily switching between two different software systems is a non trivial engineering problem that deeply constrains design.

This is terrible for consumers if it means software can’t be improved.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by mrtksn on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:15PM (#33385403)
Chemical Filtering systems are also not cheap, require serious engineering and constraint the designs and yet we are happy not having hazardous waste released into our environment.

I'm personally OK with requiring interoperability when the free market resorts to rent seeking when can't attract customers by offering compelling services.

Interoperability requirements can be easy as mandating documentation and legal permission for interaction with API and it can be up to the competitors to implement the easy switching experience.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by such12 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:20PM (#33385445)
> Interoperability requirements can be easy as mandating documentation and legal permission for interaction with API and it can be up to the competitors to implement the easy switching experience.

This is a misunderstanding of the problem. Once there is an API it can’t be changed without breaking the clients.

Therefore independent progress is no longer possible. This destroys innovation.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by mrtksn on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:25PM (#33385509)
Do you suggest that all the progress has come from the closed API software and open API stuff has stagnated?

Because that's not the case, it's just a fallacy. Close or open API, they all have legacy users and the solution to the legacy users is the same. Obviously, if the competitor fails to update it's software for the updated API they will fail to acquire new clients and that would be the competitors problem.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by such12 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:33PM (#33385598)
> Do you suggest that all the progress has come from the closed API software and open API stuff has stagnated?

No. Why would you think that?

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by mrtksn on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:35PM (#33385609)
Then why would you suggest that if the API is forced to be open the innovation will stall?
Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by such12 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:36PM (#33385627)
Because of the forced part. Normally API owners get to make their own choices about what to change and when. That goes away if they are forced.
Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by mrtksn on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:36PM (#33385630)
What about it? Why would you think that now they won't be able to?
Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by such12 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:40PM (#33385661)
Because the requirements of the APIs will be established by law and subject to litigation by competitors and api consumers.

That’s what forced means.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by mrtksn on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:50PM (#33385753)
That's hyperbole. The requirement would probably be something like document it and don't block it.
Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by such12 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @01:08PM (#33385949)
This is quite obviously wrong. Law doesn’t work like this.

Competitors and api consumers would be able to argue that any change they didn’t like was anticompetitive and request injunctive relief. It would be up to the courts to decide each time.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by jaburjak on Sunday October 30, 2022 @12:17PM (#33395732)
There already is a directive on open access to public sector data. It does not force any particular standard, protocol, let alone concrete data/interface schema. It just states data publishers must openly publish documentation, use industry standards, open data formats and protocols, and publish machine readable and processable data.

Of course there wonʼt be a mandate on exact API endpoints or data structures for every kind of service anyone could possibly create. That would be an impossible undertaking even for a bureaucracy like the EU.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by peoplefromibiza on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:11PM (#33385352)
> Easily switching between two different software systems is a non trivial engineering problem

Exactly!

because they are not interoperable.

If they were, it would be simple.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by majkinetor on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:36PM (#33385624)
That is not enough sympathy for FAANG companies. Lets make it trivial, they deserve that!
Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by such12 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:18PM (#33385426)
Once they are forced to become interoperable, they can’t change independently.

Do you not see the problem?

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by rakoo on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:24PM (#33385502)
It's a balance between a single company being able to lock its cattle because of proprietary shenanigans, and the users having leverage over how they are being used. The EU is fighting for the second one. Unless you are a big company I fail to see how you can honestly defend the first one.

You want innovation to be automatically compatible with competitors ? That's what Open Source is for.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by such12 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @04:05PM (#33387514)
cattle?
Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by rakoo on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:45PM (#33397325)
Yes, cattle. Those companies don't see you as humans with rights and wants and needs but as resources producing content and being milked for profit. Whatever happens on FB belongs to FB, whoever wrote it. Your attention is sold to announcers, your messages are examined to build a profile, your connections and friendships are vectors to optimize targeting, the content you see is decided by the company to maximize their revenues and their political views.

If they could capture your thoughts directly from your brain and leave you not even seeing the light of the day, they would.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by such12 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:43PM (#33398456)
This sounds like you are simply describing how advertising works. Cattle do not respond to advertising. People do.
Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by rakoo on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:33PM (#33400187)
Which is the mode of operations of the companies we're talking about, yes.
Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by peoplefromibiza on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:23PM (#33385485)
> Do you not see the problem?

the only problem I see is the fictional one you are creating.

Interoperability is a layer, not a feature.

Just like rails, the fact that they are the same almost everywhere in the world, hasn't stopped trains from improving and changing independently.

Italian high speed trains are different from Japanese ones.

They use the same rails.

Software is the only industry where interoperability is seen as an obstacle, but it's at the same time the industry that prides itself of being the most innovative. so innovative that they can't solve interoperability?

A single person developed pipewire that replaces pulseaudio entirely without a glitch and billion dollar companies can't do the same?

I don't believe it.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by such12 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:34PM (#33385603)
If you think software interoperability is like railway gauges, then you simply don’t understand software.
Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by peoplefromibiza on Saturday October 29, 2022 @02:31PM (#33386721)
I've been doing software for 27 years.

Thanks for the advice.

I'll humbly begin studying again how software works.

My fault for thinking that companies that sell the promise of self driving cars and colonizing Mars could solve the problem of making it possible to interoperate with other software products.

I clearly underestimated the challenge and overestimated the abilities of their 10x employees and of their visionaries CEOs.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by such12 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @03:50PM (#33387401)
Are you aware that self-driving cars don’t work yet, and mars hasn’t been colonized?

HTTP and Email are extremely narrow, have had vast amounts of work put into them over time, and are still deeply flawed. They have also developed at a glacial pace.

Your examples show that money can’t magically solve hard problems, and ironically, that even the narrowest forms of interoperability are extremely hard.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by peoplefromibiza on Saturday October 29, 2022 @04:05PM (#33387509)
> HTTP and Email are extremely narrow

HTTP is virtually running the World as it is.

I wouldn't call its scope narrow.

But probably I wasn't clear enough: we just need a way to access data and documentation.

You don't need to know what kind of web server is running when you send a request and the WEB server don't need to know what kind of client is sending the request to answer.

Interoperability is easy, if there is the will.

If there is no will, let's mandate it by law.

I don't see the problem.

Your argument is: the perfect solution is impossible so it's pointless to even try.

Which is provably false.

Even more so because software interoperability existed, before companies started to lock everything down, to push their proprietary tracking soft... ehm apps.

same reason they killed RSS

I could connect to Goggle or Facebook chat with any XMPP client back then.

WhatsApp protocol started as a a modified version of ejabberd (XMPP server).

etc.

Nobody asked for perfect.

Flawed is still better than no solution.

Human body is deeply flawed too, we don't renounce to live because we have to die anyway.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by such12 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @04:39PM (#33387747)
> You don't need to know what kind of web server is running when you send a request and the WEB server don't need to know what kind of client is sending the request to answer.

Exactly. It’s not an API - it’s a way to transfer arbitrary blocks of data.

That’s why it’s not even close to a valid comparison, and yet it has still become extremely complex over time.

> Flawed is still better than no solution.

This not the case. In many cases flawed solutions simply fail.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by peoplefromibiza on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:49AM (#33392163)
> It’s not an API - it’s a way to transfer arbitrary blocks of data

Uh?

API cannot transfer blocks of data?

Again: this is not new, it's tedious, it's bureaucratic, it can be hairy, but it's not difficult.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by such12 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:13PM (#33397588)
> API cannot transfer blocks of data?

This seems like a deliberate and silly misunderstand on your part.

If you don’t realize that most API’s generally do more than simply transfer arbitrary blocks of data, then you have lied about your experience as a developer.

HTTP is just a transfer protocol. It’s in the name.

Re:Europe prepares to rewrite the rules of the Internet by peoplefromibiza on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @08:13AM (#33420131)
> If you don’t realize that most API’s generally do more than simply transfer arbitrary blocks of data

where did I say it?

> HTTP is just a transfer protocol

that's been hardly true since forever.

POST, PUT, DELETE, PATCH etc ever heard of these verbs before?