News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Twitter will be forming a content moderation council wit... by mytailorisrich on Friday October 28, 2022 @05:39PM (#33378271)
Well, to me it is simply shocking that so many think it is the 'correct way' to disallow what they don't agree with and that they are, like you, so aggressive about it.

It's a big regression from the heights of the enlightenment, or just the recent past, in my opinion.

Re:“Twitter will be forming a content moderation council wit... by FireBeyond on Friday October 28, 2022 @05:54PM (#33378442)
What is your opinion on Parler deleting anti-Trump messages? Or liberal viewpoints?

Or r/conservative banning people who have posted on any one of a number of other subreddits, sometimes before they've even posted in r/conservative?

Re:“Twitter will be forming a content moderation council wit... by mytailorisrich on Friday October 28, 2022 @06:00PM (#33378505)
Whataboutism...

Edit:

Not only that but also transparently disingenuous. I don't know r/conservative (my comments are not about liberal vs conservative and I find odd that you and others immediately frame them that way) but a dedicated 'conservative' subreddit is obviously not the same as Twitter, which, again as become the de facto standard for most political and news communication.

Re:“Twitter will be forming a content moderation council wit... by FireBeyond on Friday October 28, 2022 @06:09PM (#33378598)
Not even remotely. I didn't agree or disagree with your statement on Twitter allowing all legal posts. I expressly chose not to.

What I'm asking you is if you think that those forums should also be required to say "Legal (Y/N)?" and if not, why not?

Re:“Twitter will be forming a content moderation council wit... by sarlalian on Friday October 28, 2022 @06:59PM (#33379048)
It's a fair assumption. The free speech absolutist crowd very much tends to trend conservative.

I think most reasonable people would reject the assertion that twitter is the de facto standard. It isn't even in the top 10 for social media platforms by active monthly users, and usage and value of a platform varies way too much depending on age and gender. While twitter is possibly the de facto standard for gen-x + millennials and certain career groups such as politicians and journalists, it certainly won't be for 18-25 year olds. Facebook still has nearly 10x the monthly active users of twitter, in fact Twitter barely beats out Quora.

Ignoring the argument about it being the de facto standard, Twitter is a business. I expect that Elon would like to make money off of his $44B investment. In the battle between the free market and free speech, the free market will almost always win. If twitter goes the extreme free speech route, users who are often targeted by loud jerks, trolls and harassers will leave the platform. It will create bad press both in the form of people complaining about harassment as well as other businesses pulling ads where their customers or potential customers were harassed.

Re:“Twitter will be forming a content moderation council wit... by FireBeyond on Friday October 28, 2022 @07:07PM (#33379139)
> Not only that but also transparently disingenuous

I notice you didn't mention Parler, though. That one's a bit harder to dance around. The "Premier Global Free Speech App". Surely that should allow all legal speech, right?

Re:“Twitter will be forming a content moderation council wit... by fckgw on Friday October 28, 2022 @05:57PM (#33378476)
I disagree with your assertion that Twitter is a public utility then. There's plenty of ways to communication with other people on the internet. Twitter has less daily active users than Pinterest, if you want to shout out your opinion on the internet then play by Twitter's rules or find another platform.