Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance
by mistrial9 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @05:38PM
(#33364391)
strong agree -- federated Identity is still possible, and political speech with anonymity too
Not that I'm in favor of it, but India, with its ~1.3 billion pop and Aadhaar hasn't fallen over just yet.
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance
by motohagiography on Thursday October 27, 2022 @06:10PM
(#33364711)
Arguably, the caste system maintains social order in India, and so digital ID for castes who are educated to be treated poorly isn't a change. The change would be for westernized countries where everyone used to be taught they have freedom and human dignity.
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance
by inquirerGeneral on Thursday October 27, 2022 @07:38PM
(#33365544)
I cannot disagree more.
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance
by null0pointer on Friday October 28, 2022 @12:28AM
(#33367678)
Why?
Could you elaborate more?
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance
by maroonblazer on Thursday October 27, 2022 @08:45PM
(#33366075)
> they are not a consumer product anybody actually wants because their use cases are all about enforcing rules against the identity subject. The only way the tech survives is it must be mandated, and then it's a question of whose problem does it solve?
Doesn't the CLEAR example in the article's opening paragraph contradict your claim?
One could argue that the problem CLEAR solves for regular consumers is a problem manufactured by those administering it. Depends on how one feels about the TSA…
This person gets it. No argument here.
I'm in tears. So blissful to have understanding people among tech enthusiasts! Usually such topics as surveillance, biometry, privacy, control of people, digital currencies, dangers of wireless, etc. rise immediate skepticism and hate. I'm glad more and more people around are shifting from indifference.
There is zero hyperbole in this. I've worked on digital identity solutions, and fundamentally, they are not a consumer product anybody actually wants because their use cases are all about enforcing rules against the identity subject. The only way the tech survives is it must be mandated, and then it's a question of whose problem does it solve?
The only people that a global digital identity solves a problem for are the people administering it, literally against the whole world. The survivors will ask, "how did it all happen so fast, what were the warnings?" and this obscure comment will be the hunger stone and harbinger. I'm literally saying millions of people will die, partially because of my inability to be persuasive, but mostly because of your misunderstanding of what this technology does and of what it is the effect.