Genuine question,seriously, not an attack, is it you who decides this for everyone or is this a personal decision kind of thing ?
> ad blocking is unethical.
If we are solely going by personal ethics then almost all big ad-tech is unethical in it's implementation, tracking, carbon footprint, extensive profiling with no opt-out.
Even if you adhere to your idea of not going back if it doesn't suit you the damage is already done privacy-wise.
You're assuming they don't want the general public accessing the website, perhaps they do and would also like the revenue that comes with the ad's served on the site, because that is, broadly speaking, how the ad funded model works.
I personally think ads are a terrible model but a paywall is an entirely different business model with different considerations.
This includes links to tracker filled javascripts and images hosted on ad servers.
Rather than gimping the browser stack for everyone, websites should use the tech they already have. Like rendering ads directly into the page contents.
Why does this need to be a “right”? Let’s assume I allow advertisements but I ignore them completely. Am I likewise costing that website money without anything in exchange?
What if I hated advertisements so much that I had someone place post-it notes on my screen so the banners were not visible, ensuring that at no point in time my attention would given to the ad spaces - would that be unethical?
Ad impressions is what counts, you can place as many post-it notes as you want.
It is a fascinating concept. If I put a blog up, I have a right to demand that people pay me one way or the other. But then as a person that visits that site, that person has no right to say nope. Sold. Pay me about $3.50 for this nugget.
<You don't like it? Don't ever go (back?) to that website again, I'm sure there's some blacklist extensions out there.
It is more and more what I do. If the paywall gets too obtrusive, I don't even try to spend time fiddling too much ( I mostly browse with noscript on by default these days).
edit: removed tangent about corps and moved pay me bit to the front to make a point
When ads are blocked the protocol is working exactly as designed. If you don’t like me blocking your ads, you should block me. When I encounter sites that block adblock users, I simply write them off and never return. If you don’t block me? Clearly you see the ads as optional too.
It is as ethical as:
1. politely declining a marketing leaflet
2. switching to a different TV channel when there is a commercial
3. looking away from the newspaper ads or roadside billboards
etc.
Hilarious. They should be glad I'm running uBlock Origin and not AdNauseam.
A website chooses to serve ads. You don't like it? Don't ever go (back?) to that website again, I'm sure there's some blacklist extensions out there.
Just because you don't like ads or tracking (neither illegal) you don't have the right to cost that website money (bandwidth, etc.) without anything in exchange.
Actually it's good that some sites are ad-funded. E.g. news sites. Ideally that kind of site would offer a paid, ad-free, tracking-free option for people with cushy jobs like the HN crowd. But Mr. and Ms. Can't Make Ends Meet can still access the news in exchange of seeing some (or a lot of) ads here and there.
At the very least, if there's an ad-funded website you like and visit frequently then disable ad blocking for them.