Product requires commitment and continuity which Google has proven to be really, really poor at historically. Likely because it has the wrong culture for it, is likely organized with the wrong incentive structures in place, and has thus far been wildly successful in spite of it.
I think GCP would have bigger, but Azure is a different beast. Azure is based on Fortune500 sales. What GCP could have been is the de factor Serverless and Platform-as-a-Service for hobbyists, as App Engine was a pioneer in the space. App Engine actually preceded GCP. It could have subsumed the likes of Heroku, Twilio and various other APIs-as-a-service, and even logs / monitoring tools such as Datadog, which are billion dollar businesses in their own right.
It was a super cool tech demo and then they just stopped working on it. I guess it depends on what you consider "Alternatives" but it doesn't hold a candle to the Apple TV, Fire TV, or even a Roku stick IMHO. A remote is key to any TV-based device and no, a phone is not a valid remote (at least as the "only" remote). Watching my friends rave about the Chromecast and watching them have to pull out their phones to pause/play/etc is just mind boggling to me.
Agree about the remote. But the thing that's much better about Chromecast is that discovery on your phone is much quicker than with a remote and the fact you can simply cast any video on the internet that uses the protocol without any apps.
If they made it a box more like Apple TV then they'd capture both people.
Paging google product
[0] https://store.google.com/us/product/chromecast_google_tv?hl=...
First of all, let's look at the "truly great" things Google has done -- search, ads, Android, YouTube, Maps, Gmail, Apps/GSuite/Workspace, and so on. 100% commitment, 100% great.
You say Google is "rather uncommitted" to GCP, which is hilarious if you'd look at the billions they've sunk into it. They committed to competing with AWS and by god they're spending the money to do it, and they're almost at profitability after more than 10 years of staying the course. If that's not commitment, then I literally don't know what is.
The rest of what you're listing is just that it's very hard to achieve profitable product-market fit, even if you're Google. Hardware like Pixel is hard to turn into a series of reliable successes, consumers just didn't sign up for Stadia in the numbers needed, Hangouts is a complicated story but Google certainly keeps trying with messaging, and FB Messenger's popularity was not even remotely a result of Hangouts splitting.
And just checking -- you think the 4th largest company in the world has the worst business people in the world...? No amount of genius engineering is going to get you there without an awful lot of genius business and product people too...
Basically all these have just been coasting on network effects since the mid oughts.
It's just slightly disappointing because Google stuff works better than any other computing items I've ever used. Everything connects to the cloud and just works in a way MS' and Apple's cloud offerings don't. And they should be competing with Apple and MS but instead they're mostly selling ads...
To put that in perspective, Oracle a Fortune 50 company, with a market cap of 200 Billion, has Annual Revenue is $44 Billion.
GCP on it's own can easily be a Fortune 50 company
Reminds me of this unlikely verse, also applies to corporations: Romans 5:4
Chromecast - better than all the alternatives but they could have gone that extra distance to make a whole Google TV apparatus and didn't.
Pixel phones - when they had all the critical mass they fumbled and released an entire line of very mediocre hardware
Pixel laptop - one of the best laptops made, ever, but they didn't commit and it was a one-off...
Hangouts - could have been the messaging app for everything... Instead they split it into two and now FB Messenger is the messaging app everyone uses (outside the US anyway).
GCP - again, they had a chance to become what Azure is or bigger but just seemed rather uncommitted to it...
Stadia - if they had committed it could have been huge because it absolutely does work very well. The concept of it working with Chromecast was good so again, they could have again, just made the TV box, bundle a controller and it's a console for everything... But nope, cancelled right as gaming Chromebooks are coming onto the market...
It sucks because many Google products are absolutely best in class but there's this eerie feeling that even those could disappear. Google probably has the best engineering in the world but also probably the worst product managers and business people in the world it seems...