Re:The Crunchpad is proof of obviousness in iPad design
by TechNewb on Friday December 09, 2011 @11:52AM
(#3334412)
I already said it was the overall design aesthetic, not one simple element, but that it's obvious that Apple is a leading innovator in the space of thin industrial design. iPhone, iPod, iMac, the Air, are all some of the thinest in class. Plus you can see how even the CrunchPad/JooJoo changed it's design aesthetic to match that of the iPad after the iPad was publicly announced.
And where/when did monopoly come up in this conversation? To my knowledge patents do not enable a company to a monopoly.
Re:The Crunchpad is proof of obviousness in iPad design
by drcube on Friday December 09, 2011 @03:46PM
(#3335537)
>And where/when did monopoly come up in this conversation? To my knowledge patents do not enable a company to a monopoly.
That's exactly what a patent IS. A temporary monopoly, granted by the government.
Getting on a monopoly on (or due to) the design trait "thin", however, is not acceptable, even if it were the case that Apple came up with the idea of thin devices, which is obviously not so.