News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by jedberg on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:32AM (#33328647)
As long as the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) exists, yes.

https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2017/09/29/554603161/epis...

tl;dl: They are the insurer of last resort. They have paid out 10x the value of some houses that are constantly flooding.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by zzleeper on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:39AM (#33328701)
I find it insane how the US govt constantly subsidizes certain activities without many people realizing. NFIP, the implicit guarantees on FHLBs, and a bunch of others just lead to misaligned incentives all over the place :/
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by chiefalchemist on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:47AM (#33328769)
And yet we're told Uncle Sam believes in the free market? We don't have Capitalism. We have Crony Capitalism. The latter has little to do with the former.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by pyrale on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:19AM (#33329024)
I would say they're deeply related: the former is the fable we use to justify that we keep letting the latter happen.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by codyb on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:56AM (#33328842)
There's also the fact that if we don't subsidize places where natural disasters occur millions of people are going to start moving rather quickly.

Everywhere's a disaster zone now, we need to account for that, do our best to warn people, and do our best to help people get back to it. This is true here, and around the globe.

Mass migrations are _destabilizing_. It's not crony capitalism, it's common sense for stability.

And there are certainly places that are absolutely irredeemable and shouldn't have insurance. But this idea that letting people whose homes are destroyed in natural disasters need to be hung out to dry won't be worse than helping them get back onto their feet both for them and most likely for you is a bit odd.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by FartyMcFarter on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:17AM (#33328999)
There is a middle ground though.

If a specific area floods very frequently, it seems silly to keep bailing it out.

At some point we have to cut our losses and face reality and just stop investing there.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by plasticchris on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:15AM (#33329465)
Agreed, and the regular insurance companies figured out the solution a long time ago: raise premiums until their expected value exceeds the payouts over the average duration of this type of policy.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by aperson_hello on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @09:27AM (#33330175)
And most of the places that have major recurring flooding issues are hyper local (for now at least). We're talking neighborhoods or parts of neighborhoods, not full cities (yet). The number of affected properties is relatively small, but they make up a large portion of overall claims. Stop covering those locations (even if it's a coordinated buyout program of sorts) and the problem sorts itself out...

Edit: and then install retaining infrastructure in place of those houses and you stop future issues too for neighbors

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by astura on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @09:51AM (#33330452)
>The number of affected properties is relatively small, but they make up a large portion of overall claims.

Specifically, 1% of properties make up 25% of all claims.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by codyb on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @09:28AM (#33330190)
Yea... but... wouldn't the Fort Myers area count as part of the middle ground that's fine? They don't get hit hard consistently.

Should we say that NYC should be abandoned cause Sandy hit 10 years ago and another might hit again one day?

And also I actually said in my post "there are areas we shouldn't".

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by NickC25 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @10:40AM (#33331063)
Ft. Myers has been hit a few times, but you're right - it's not constant. But Florida in general gets hit pretty hard every year - it's just that it happens to different parts of Florida. The Keys get battered every few years, so does Miami, so does Tampa. Even Orlando is not safe.

However, Ft Myers is different from NYC in that sea level rises affect South Florida a hell of a lot more than Manhattan. A 10 foot sea level rise would only affect a small (but definitely not insignificant) part of Manhattan. That same rise would render all of Florida's coastlines (on both sides) uninhabitable. See link below:

https://coast.noaa.gov/slr/

NYC doesn't get hit anywhere close to as often as Florida's coasts do. It's not even comparable.

The insurers are leaving Florida in droves because their risk assessment teams understand that sea level rises and climate change is a significant financial risk to their operations in Florida, no matter how much Governor DeSantis wants to pretend otherwise.

It makes zero sense to insure areas that are going to be uninhabitable in our lifetimes, much less spend billions rebuilding them time and time again.

Disclaimer: I live in South Florida.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by gaadd33 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @10:54AM (#33331319)
Are you sure it's due to risk assessment for climate change and not the huge amount of fraud and litigation? I've heard that something like 80% of all homeowners insurance lawsuits have been from Florida despite only having 9% of claims. When I looked into the issue that was the driving cause I found, it would be good to read some info about the climate change assessment making it into their decision to pull out.

Disclaimer: Also in South Florida

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by NickC25 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:42AM (#33332109)
I'm sure it's a mix of both. Yes, there's a ton of home insurance lawsuits here, and yes, the amount of fraud here is mind-boggling.

However, the rapid rise in sea level and the fact that the state legislature is bound by law to not discuss it at all is also a factor. South Florida's coasts will be uninhabitable within 50 years, and if I'm an insurer, that's also on my mind.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by HonestOp001 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @03:32PM (#33335088)
Incorrect. Florida is currently undergoing a massive effort to identify resiliency options across the state. There are lots of efforts in the state at the city, county, and state level to address this.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by NickC25 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @09:26AM (#33343333)
Source?

Also, the efforts that I've seen are sub-par at best. Miami wants to build barrier islands that are a few feet above sea level in order to create a basin-type barrier around Brickell (the financial district where Ken Griffin is building a tower). Those are still in the early stages of bureaucratic hell and won't likely be built until it's way too late.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by knodi123 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:18AM (#33331755)
> floods very frequently [...] keep bailing it out

pun intended?

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by FartyMcFarter on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @12:17PM (#33332640)
Nope, I didn't even know that meaning of "bailing out", TIL :)
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by causi on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:45AM (#33329226)
Mass migrations are _destabilizing_.

Then do it over a period of time. Reduce it to zero over, say, thirty years.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by themitigating on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:47AM (#33329243)
What about people with 2nd homes? Why just flood insurance?
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by nerdponx on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:02AM (#33329363)
I'll believe it when there's an income-based phase-out, exceptions for multiple homeowners, and tapering with a firm expiration date built into the legislation.

Just because something superficially resembles a good idea, doesn't make it a good idea. See also: corn subsidies.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by chiefalchemist on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:17AM (#33329489)
> Mass migrations are _destabilizing_. It's not crony capitalism, it's common sense for stability.

Insanity is not stability.

It's one thing to maintain some status quo (e.g., a small town / neighborhood is already established). It's another to encourage and reward bad decisions.

There's no reasonable justification for maintaining a pattern that is destined to fail. Again and again and again.

Is this what we considered smart and effective government?

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by krapp on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:54AM (#33328816)
>We don't have Capitalism. We have Crony Capitalism. The latter has little to do with the former.

As any true Scotsman knows.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by refurb on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:19AM (#33329502)
Calling it crony capitalism is kind of silly. Do you expect the US to just abandon vast swaths of the country that are at risk of natural disasters? No homes along the Gulf coast, no homes in tornado alley, no homes along the earthquake faults along the West coast?
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by kasey_junk on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:25AM (#33329560)
There is no equivalent to NFIP for tornado or earth quake insurance. We leave that to private insurers (and sometimes the states have programs).

That is one of the biggest arguments against the NFIP. It’s a specific subsidy that benefits some areas more than others (it’s also a deeply regressive policy).

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by refurb on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @09:50AM (#33330424)
If an massive earthquake levels SF the government will most certainly come in and rescue homeowners.

So it’s either subsidy upfront or on the backend?

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by kasey_junk on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @10:09AM (#33330659)
They didn’t in 1989. The relief bill was entirely for repairing damaged infrastructure.

FEMA specifically mentions that you can’t expect replacement housing costs to be paid in many of their documents: https://www.fema.gov/fact-sheet/earthquake-survivors-apply-f...

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by refurb on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:55PM (#33339628)
‘89 saw minimal damage save for a few neighborhoods like the Marina.

If SF sees 50% of houses uninhabitable and 12% have earthquake insurance you think the govt will struggle and say “too bad”

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by kasey_junk on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @08:29AM (#33342653)
In 2020 the house passed a supplemental bill to enable funds that can go to home replacement for Puerto Rican earthquake victims because the existing law doesn’t allow it.

The Senate never passed it and the President promised to veto it.

I have no crystal ball to know what might happen in the future but right now there is no earthquake equivalent to national flood insurance and recent history suggests the federal government doesn’t have the appetite to add it.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by scarface74 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @09:10AM (#33329991)
Yes
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by chiefalchemist on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @10:56AM (#33331360)
I didn't say this instance was Crony Capitalism per se. It's the idea that Uncle Sam gets too deep into too many things and yet the masses of voters believe we have free markets, Capitalism, etc.

What I expect is less insanity. Sure, help the people that were there. But for others to be coming in from the outside and exploiting the gov's offers, that's hardly reasonable and smart.

Furthermore, it's hypocritical - and costly - for the gov to say "climate change is coming it's going to raise the oceans..." and then in the next breath "here's taxpayer money to rebuild in a low-lying area because this isn't going to happen again." If we want people to take climate change seriously, then mixed signals like this aren't helping.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by iwillbenice on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:31AM (#33329617)
Ah there it is. The usual doomer mentality that is so common I want to vomit when I see it. A mixed-market economy is not "Crony Capitalism". Stop exaggerating for upvotes.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by freen on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:40AM (#33329681)
50 cents of every dollar earned by farmers in the US is paid by tax dollars buying excess food at fixed, over market prices. Lookup the strategic cheese reserve.

Does the government pay half your salary? They take half of mine.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by iwillbenice on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @09:39AM (#33330304)
Nothing of what you said changes my original point: We live in a mixed-market economy. The government manages some buffers (food, oil).

And I'd really like to understand how the government "takes half" of your salary. Either you're super rich (probably not), or you're exaggerating.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by chiefalchemist on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:03AM (#33331485)
At first, half sounds like hyperbole, I'll give you that.

But then think about all the various taxes we pay directly (e.g., gasoline, internet and phone services, etc.). Then add on the taxes that are embedded in the costs of any of the other goods we buy. It adds up.

Finally, if you consider The Fed a government agency, any time The Fed devalues your money (i.e., "prints" money and creates inflation) that's also all but a tax. That is, we have less to spend.

It might not be half, but it's certainly significantly more than your income tax rate.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by freen on Friday October 28, 2022 @04:14PM (#33377225)
Exactly.

If you live in a major metropolitan area, or own a home that has rapidly appreciated, well, it all adds up quickly.

Also consider: import taxes raise the price of goods, and thus are a wealth transfer from consumers to producers. Sugar is the classic example: import tariffs increase the effective tax burden of the lowest income quartile substantially, as they spend a larger percentage of their income on food. Anything with high fructose corn syrup, sweetener, or sugar is more expensive. And the corn farmers get that money.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by chiefalchemist on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:08AM (#33331586)
Doomer? When did being honest and realistic become doomer?

It's as if you missed the college debt forgiveness. What was that? First, the gov stepped in, manipulated a market, increased demand, etc., and that eventuallyt went sideways.

And then it stepped in to pull the plug in that mistake. The POTUS promises the forgiveness program will make buying a home more afford...because the demand he created won't result in higher prices. Huh?

The only doom comes from those who can't face facts and keep their heads buried in the sand.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by iwillbenice on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:10AM (#33331623)
> It's as if you missed the college debt forgiveness. What was that? First, the gov stepped in, manipulated a market, increased demand, etc., and that eventuallyt went sideways.

No one with a fucking brain thinks that was a good idea. But that's what Democrats do.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by JustSomeNobody on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:31AM (#33329618)
Homeowners insurance in FL is a mess. The number 2 insurer is the state of FL (Citizens Property Insurance Corporation). I have no doubt they'll be the largest (and possibly only) in the years ahead.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by FuriouslyAdrift on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:44AM (#33329725)
The Florida CPIC is backed by re-insurance companies and they are bailing on Florida due to the high risk. https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/southeast/2022/10/25/6...
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:48AM (#33329758)
I read that this was not due to flood losses, but rather excessive fraud that the state is not policing causing untenable losses.

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/roofing-scams-florida-p...

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by FuriouslyAdrift on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:41AM (#33329694)
Congress passed a bill seting the rates to be risk-adjusted in 2012, causing a 10x increase in rates in some areas. Congress then passed another bill in 2013 bringing back the 1968 rates under Obama. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeowner_Flood_Insurance_Affo...
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by eloff on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @09:29AM (#33330199)
Yup, government coming in and distorting the free market in all kinds of ways is very wasteful.

However, there are cases where the benefits outweigh the drawbacks.

For example, it's nice to get your energy, metals, computers, industrial machines domestically instead of being at the mercy of a foreign country. Especially if the foreign country isn't ideologically aligned with yours.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by LeanderK on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @09:34AM (#33330254)
in this example it is wasteful but it also decreases risks in the long term. The free market does not have to produce the most efficient solution, it just often does.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by Sakos on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:01AM (#33331462)
The free market is only able to optimize towards local maxima. That maxima might have plenty of downsides that don't affect its performance, but have negative effects on human beings and society that aren't captured by market mechanisms.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by bcrl on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @12:27PM (#33332775)
Privatize the profits, have the government cover the loses. Looks just like corporate welfare.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by yieldcrv on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:36AM (#33328685)
wow, pays to read federal legislation... and who are we kidding, pays even more to write it!

I'm a master of my areas of the federal code, I was not aware of this area!

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by jquery on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:07AM (#33328913)
Is earthquake insurance in California comparable to this? Am I a fool if I don't buy earthquake insurance?
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:29AM (#33329098)
No, because federal taxpayers may or may not bail out Californians for earthquake losses.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by gfhgfdhgdfhgdf on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:57AM (#33329323)
They do bail out California homes for wildfire losses though.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by shagmin on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:21AM (#33329524)
Is there a citation from this? From a quick search I can only find re-imbursements for state & local firefighters working on federal property. Typical homeowner's insurance covers fire already in most places at least.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by astura on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @09:17AM (#33330063)
Fire loss should be covered by the homeowners/business insurance.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by Tepix on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:09AM (#33328932)
So, why does it still cover these areas? Does the government really want to incentivize building there again and again?
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:26AM (#33329069)
Because Florida has a lot of electoral college votes, and used to be a swing state in the recent past.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by gfhgfdhgdfhgdf on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:56AM (#33329315)
What about California's wildfires and their federal relief subsidies?
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by ethanbond on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:06AM (#33329391)
Federal disaster relief has completely different economic dynamics from backstop, risk-agnostic insurance. I don’t think anyone in this thread is suggesting we don’t give federal aid to Florida.

But to your point, yes we should also stop subsidizing water in the US southwest including California.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:28AM (#33329588)
What about them? They do not seem comparable in scope to an explicit subsidy approved and funded by Congress before the loss even occurs.

No California homeowner is paying less for homeowner’s insurance because it is sold at below cost by the federal government. They may or may not get bailed out when a loss occurs, which is different from knowing that you will.

Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by thatguy0900 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:14AM (#33328974)
Do you want your party in the news for shutting multiple whole cities down and forcing all of the poor people there to move from their ancestral homes? Regardless of the reality of it that's the kind of personal stories the news salivates over
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by NickC25 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:37AM (#33329661)
Yeah, I would. An actual conservative would probably also like this, because the flip side to your point is "government stops spending massive (and wasteful) amounts of money supporting the rebuilding of an area constantly hit by massive hurricanes that's also due to be completely underwater within the next 50 years"
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by thatguy0900 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:35AM (#33332010)
Republicans won't even agree that the climate change is happening much less agree that Florida will be underwater. They would probably be fine with getting rid of loss leading govt insurance programs in general though. I don't think any Democrat is going to go for the optics of pushing poor minorities out of their neighborhoods no matter what nature's plans are.
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by jedberg on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:51AM (#33329280)
They don't, and I think they've changed the program recently to stop making repeated payouts on the same property. I'm not sure what they do instead, maybe pay you to move?
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by plasticchris on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:20AM (#33329514)
That’s what we’ve been doing in Missouri since the big flood in 93: https://www.fema.gov/case-study/missouri-flood-buyout-saves-...
Re:Home Buyers Flock to Florida Cities Devastated by Hurrica... by js2 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @12:06PM (#33332469)
Despite that, most people in flood zones do NOT have flood insurance.

> A 2020 survey conducted by the group found that 27% of all American homeowners insurance policyholders said they had flood insurance. And Wharton’s Risk Management and Decision Processes Center similarly found that, on average, 30% of homes in the highest-risk areas nationwide have flood coverage. [...] About 56% of consumers incorrectly assumed floods would be covered by their homeowners’ policies, according to a 2021 survey by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners.

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/hundreds-thousands-flor...

> President Joe Biden declared nine counties disaster areas Thursday, making residents eligible for federal aid to pay for minor home repairs, short-term housing and other emergency costs. But of the 1.8 million households in those nine counties, only 29 percent have federal flood insurance, according to an analysis of government records by POLITICO’s E&E News. That leaves 1.3 million households at ground zero without federal flood coverage.

https://www.politico.com/news/2022/10/01/hurricane-ian-will-...