News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by basilgohar on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:36PM (#33325497)
> I’m amazed a car manufacturer could resort to these games. If they want to increase profits, why not just focus on customers and give customers what they want?

The name of the game now in more and more industries is rent-seeking and extracting money long term, on a regular basis. This new business practice disincentivizes building quality products because then you can sell a shoddy product and include "maintenance" and "updates" into your subscription plan.

If it's not stopped legally, it'll only get worse.

Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by xbar on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:41PM (#33325537)
Precisely. This is the kind of legislation that benefits all the residents of a state.

Subscription predation is poorly regulated. Starting with cars seems like an obvious target.

Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by splistud on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:48PM (#33325575)
Considering the volume, why not start with software?
Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by domador on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @12:32AM (#33326271)
The kind of software that truly depends on a server or some live resource that must be actively maintained and kept running can genuinely make a claim to charge a reasonable recurring fee to use said software. But for software that is essentially a standalone product which needs no upgrades, one should be able to buy the current version of the software and keep using that specific version of that software indefinitely, just as if one had bought a hammer or some other tool that will permanently belong to you, with no monthly subscription.
Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by JamesianP on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @02:24AM (#33326936)
That just creates a loophole. Perhaps it is a "smart" heated seat. You can make anything need a live internet connection by putting some adaptive "benefits" in it. Now they'll just monetize your minute-to-minute-butt-temperature data too.
Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by sneak on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:40PM (#33325523)
That’s mostly in industries without meaningful competition.

In competitive industries, customer-hostile choices are much less common.

Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by Spooky23 on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:59PM (#33325651)
That’s the party line. In reality cars are one of the most heavily competitive consumer markets, and guess what? They still behave like assholes.
Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by BurningFrog on Monday October 24, 2022 @11:09PM (#33325716)
The brands compete. The dealers are local monopolies. Usually by law.
Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by elihu on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @12:03AM (#33326070)
The brands compete on the kinds of cars they want to sell. When it comes to less profitable kinds of vehicles, that's where lobbying and regulatory capture comes in to kill competition. Thus we have the chicken tax, much stricter fuel economy standards for small trucks than big trucks, and the extreme protectionism in the inflation reduction act when it comes to EV tax credits.
Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by menage on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @12:08AM (#33326097)
But the locality is typically only a town. Emailing all the dealers in the area for a quote and driving a bit out of your way to pick up the car isn't that hard.
Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by tsimionescu on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @01:53AM (#33326739)
It's the brands trying so sell you subscription seat warming, not the local dealers.
Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by BurningFrog on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @02:05PM (#33334114)
Interesting point!
Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by Spooky23 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @03:00PM (#33334755)
There’s a dozen GM brand dealers within 15 miles of where I’m sitting right now. They absolutely compete.
Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by Silhouette on Monday October 24, 2022 @11:17PM (#33325769)
In competitive industries, customer-hostile choices are much less common.

How many brands of TV are there? How many of those brands still make even one consumer model that isn't "smart" in user-hostile ways?

Having lots of suppliers doesn't necessarily create effective competition in the customer interest. If there's a customer-hostile practice that makes lots of money and is sufficiently obvious that all suppliers can adopt it without any need for legally questionable forms of cooperation then what is going to happen?

Effectively forcing subscriptions or other after-purchase limitations and costs on customers when there is nothing in it for those customer to balance what they lose is exactly the kind of predatory behaviour that government regulation should protect against.

Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by fsckboy on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @12:53AM (#33326390)
> rent-seeking and extracting money long term, on a regular basis

recurring revenue is what you're talking about, it's a financially desirable thing for them, but it's not the same thing as rent seeking. Rent seeking is not receiving payments over and over on a regular basis, rather it's a term economists use to mean making money from your position in the market without contributing anything of value to the market (without putting in any work, so to speak). "Monopoly rents" are the extra parts of the prices that monopolies can charge because they face not competition.

add-ons to a major expense like an automobile can qualify as rents because once you buy the car, you are essentially trapped into buying the add-ons from the one manufacturer.

Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by amatecha on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @01:06AM (#33326462)
hrm, interesting... by that definition I would argue that the business model of car dealerships is specifically rent-seeking. They not only don't contribute anything of value, they actively detract from the value proposition by marking up far over MSRP and, like someone posted in another comment, engaging in shady tactics like selling your vehicle to someone else after waiting for 3mo because your bank isn't open until tomorrow. Just to scratch the surface.
Re:Car feature subscriptions should be illegal, New Jersey L... by JamesianP on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @01:58AM (#33326772)
The vendor still had to invest money to put the feature there, so it's a legit business transaction, even if it sounds silly. Presumably the monthly cost will be a lot less than the hundreds it would cost to buy the feature outright. Or are they charging people twice?