In other words, in this particular case, it's a wash.
For example the water could only get so expensive before desalinization becomes cost effective. Also all the things California grows and sells to the rest of the country would include the price of water.
I think that people forget that US States are States in a Union. The Federal Government is there to regulate commerce and provide for common defense, even if it gained some extra responsibilities post-New Deal. US states have their own laws, executive, market policies, constitutions, and all; they are not just departments of the federal government. So California<->Germany seems like the only fair comparison, just as it wouldn’t make sense to compare the United States to Germany, but the EU as a whole.
This sounds like a rather arbitrary measurement.
Wasn't there?
Or were athletes called "Russian Olympic Committee" not the Russian team?
ROC was an independent organization that didn't technically represent Russia.
Pretending that Russia actually faced punishment for doping is asine. Russia the country had total control over what athletes were sent by ROC as well as said athletes still had to be Russians and they wore the national colors of Russia and the athletes often (always?) sang the Russian anthem for their medal (regardless of w/e music was actually being played)
I would guess that almost none of the water that California gets from the Colorado falls in California. Coloradans sure feel that the down river states don't have the natural right to water that falls on their land.
The lack of information actually exacerbates the entire problem out west, as people give undue concern to, say, Los Angeles. While, say, Scottsdale sits oblivious to the precarious nature of it's situation vis-a-vis water.
Here are some other arbitrary subsets of the USA that would be interesting viewed as separate economies.
- The original thirteen states. - The Amtrak electrified rail corridor from DC to Boston - The Mississippi watershed - The great lakes watershed (include the relevant parts of Canada, why not?)