News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by jbarham on Thursday December 08, 2011 @07:11PM (#3331826)
Having moved from California to Australia a year ago, the main thing we're finding exceptional about Australia is the high cost of living. IMO the Australian economy is currently being squeezed in a vice between the insane property bubble and the resources boom and high Australian dollar making other sectors of the economy uncompetitive. Western Australia and Queensland (i.e., the two minerals states) are the only two states showing any significant growth.

Australian retail, especially e-commerce, is completely uncompetitive compared to the U.S. Try picking a product at random from www.toysrus.com.au and compare the price on Amazon and even after international shipping it will almost always be much cheaper to just buy from Amazon.

E.g., Megatron Transformers toy: $70 in Australia (http://www.toysrus.com.au/popular-boys-toys/kre-o-transforme...) vs. $25 at Amazon (http://www.amazon.com/KRE-O-30688-Transformers-MEGATRON-SET/...). It's almost as if Australian e-commerce sites depend on their customers not having heard of the internet...

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by brc on Thursday December 08, 2011 @08:14PM (#3332029)
>It's almost as if Australian e-commerce sites depend on their customers not having heard of the internet..

That's exactly what it is. They pretend they don't exist, or that somehow what you get is inferior.

Historically, it's because the Australian dollar was weaker (after the last minerals boom bust) and therefore imported goods were more expensive. The retailers built their business models on higher margins, and now are struggling to compete with the disruptive influence of international e-commerce.

I'm not expert on retail but I suspect the problem is with too many middlemen - importers, wholesalers, and the like. But instead of trying to work out why/how to compete, they are starting to run to the government looking for intervention.

One of the few retail chains doing well is Supercheap, which has BCF and Goldcross bicycles (and probably some others). They seem to be able to be cost-competitive with international prices on many things and are still profitable.

To me, there is no reason why an Australian e-commerce site couldn't be more successful. ebay is wildly successful in Australia, so it's not like people are averse to purchasing online. It's more to do with woeful range and prices.

If Amazon ever decides to open up an Australian subsidiary with warehouses located in Australia they will wipe out entire retail chains. As it is, they're already knocking them about badly even with inflated international shipping and long lead times.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by jacques_chester on Thursday December 08, 2011 @09:31PM (#3332244)
> If Amazon ever decides to open up an Australian subsidiary with warehouses located in Australia they will wipe out entire retail chains.

Amazon, IIRC, refuse to do so because of the ban on parallel importation of books.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by brc on Thursday December 08, 2011 @10:31PM (#3332407)
Yes, that's correct as far as I understand. But there's nothing to stop them selling all the other stuff they sell and wait for the inevitable change on books. A pile of it comes from China, anyway. They will end up being asked to come - because as it is, the local book industry is collapsing and there won't be anywhere to actually purchase books.

The same thing happened with music - there was a push to stop parallel import of CDs which cost about $25 for an album. But iTunes rendered that argument completely meaningless anyway.

I have one local bookstore left in my area but it appears to be existing on lots of big tables full of discounted merchandise sitting outside. The range is woeful and the prices are criminal. I doubt they'll be there in another 12 months.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by jbarham on Thursday December 08, 2011 @09:37PM (#3332258)
And we all know how well that worked out for Borders Australia.

E-books obviously make import regulations of books irrelevant so I don't think Amazon would bother setting up a retail operation in Australia.

But if Amazon Web Services set up shop down under, well now, that would be quite disruptive!

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by jacques_chester on Thursday December 08, 2011 @09:40PM (#3332271)
> E-books obviously make import regulations of books irrelevant so I don't think Amazon would bother setting up a retail operation in Australia.

I have a Kindle for this exact reason.

> But if Amazon Web Services set up shop down under, well now, that would be quite disruptive!

I don't see why they would. In terms of global traffic, Australia is a minnow. But in terms of cost-per-bit, we're one of the most expensive locations in the world.

It makes more sense for Amazon to sit offshore and send bits in, where they'll be paid for by the end user with an ISP account.

About as close as you'll get is Singapore, I think.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by jbarham on Thursday December 08, 2011 @10:00PM (#3332322)
I meant AWS opening up in Australia would create severe problems for a lot of local high-cost hosting providers. But Amazon may not bother as US west coast latency is often good enough. (Keep in mind that Australian ISPs might route traffic to Singapore via the US, so although it may be closer as the crow flies, it's not necessarily closer on the internet.)
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by dam0 on Thursday December 08, 2011 @10:15PM (#3332364)
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by jacques_chester on Thursday December 08, 2011 @11:18PM (#3332531)
I would love to be wrong.
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by jacques_chester on Thursday December 08, 2011 @11:18PM (#3332530)
There's a pipe to Singapore out of Darwin, I believe. One of the old OTC lines I'm guessing, so probably not very high bandwidth.
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by nl on Friday December 09, 2011 @12:41AM (#3332741)
It's not just the bandwidth - it's the cost.

Bandwidth to the US is cheaper, and some ISP (TGP cough) route based on price rather than latency.

I'd dig up the link from the Amazon forums, but I've got a feeling we've had this discussion on here before?

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by daemin on Thursday December 08, 2011 @10:04PM (#3332333)
Even with a Kindle (or Kindle software) you still can't get the same books (in ebook format) as you can overseas. There are several fiction books that I just cannot get in Kindle e-book format because the local distributor hasn't authorised it or some such.
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by brc on Thursday December 08, 2011 @10:27PM (#3332395)
This frustrated me so much I took the time to setup proper drm cracking.

So the answer is: 1) set up US proxy so you appear as US browser (ie openproxy or similar) 2) open up US-sepcific account using US address (any will do, you're not getting anything shipped, I used a postal service). 3) purchase gift voucher for amount covering the books you wish to purchase with 'regular' amazon account 4) use US account via proxy to make purchase, and use gift voucher to pay for them. 5) use Kindle cloud reader to download purchased ebooks to your local machine (you have no Kindle registered to this account, so you can't download to your kindle). 6) install calibre open source e-book management (this is a good tool for managing your ebook collection anyway) 7) google for amazon DRM book plug in for calibre 8) load purchased ebooks up, run drm cracking plugin 9) connect kindle and upload cracked books 10) open beer and laugh openly at futile attempts to use DRM to control industry

It sounds complicated but it's not really that hard. Amazing how you have to act like a criminal to do something that would seem logical to everyone but a publishing lawyer.

You can also use this tool to share ebooks between kindles, ie, yours and your partner - as you would with a book purchased from a store.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by someperson on Thursday December 08, 2011 @11:04PM (#3332491)
Which postal redirection services do you use/recommend?
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by brc on Thursday December 08, 2011 @11:39PM (#3332586)
I use a service called MyUS.com - they've been good on a couple of occasions, so I'll give a qualified support to them. You pay some cash ($10 I think) and they give you a permanent US address to get stuff sent to.
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by lazyeye on Thursday December 08, 2011 @11:14PM (#3332512)
This is very easy to get around. Amazon allows you to register multiple addresses. Just register a US address against your Kindle. All your other Amazon services can be registered against your AU address(es). This will give you full access to the US ebook catalogues from AU. As you would expect Amazon only puts up a minimal, token resistance to you buying their stuff.
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by nl on Friday December 09, 2011 @12:38AM (#3332734)
This is no longer the case.

Now they check the address on your credit card, and check you are coming from a US IP address. I've heard you can work around this using pre-paid credit cards (and possibly gift cards) and a US based proxy.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by lazyeye on Friday December 09, 2011 @02:11AM (#3332932)
If this is true then they must be only location testing new Kindle subscribers. I purchased my first-gen Kindle a few years ago and have been purchasing US books without a problem since registering a US address soon afterwards. There is an option under "Manage your kindle" -> Country Settings where you can select your country. Mine is currently set to US and I dont have a US credit card or IP proxy etc.
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by nl on Friday December 09, 2011 @06:34AM (#3333379)
It is possible they use different forms. I think I had the most trouble when trying to buy an MP3 via Amazon.
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by brc on Friday December 09, 2011 @01:36AM (#3332864)
No, you need a US IP address and a US credit card, and a US postal address on your account. See my comment further up.
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by jbarham on Thursday December 08, 2011 @10:23PM (#3332383)
Have you tried the trick of buying yourself am Amazon.com gift certificate?
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by angusgr on Thursday December 08, 2011 @10:07PM (#3332338)
This is something that might change soon, given recommendations made last month by the Book Industry Strategy Group: http://beattiesbookblog.blogspot.com/2011/11/australian-book...
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by Nick_C on Saturday December 10, 2011 @09:39PM (#3339132)
If you want one number that tells why Australian retail is more expensive than U.S., it is retail rents.

Aust. retail rents are (among?) the highest in the world, higher than London and New York. This is mainly due to poor short-sighted planning authorities in local councils which over-manage commercial planning. The result is that, except perhaps Melbourne, all large retail is in malls instead of spread among the suburbs. Almost all the malls are owned by one or two parties, Westfield being the major. As monopoly owner, they have squeezed retail rents for decades.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by thmcmahon on Thursday December 08, 2011 @07:48PM (#3331942)
Yes Australia has a higher cost of living than the United States, and recent high commodity prices have pushed up our exchange rate. However, if you are comparing prices across currency, then a lot of what you are seeing is due to a higher exchange rate. If you had moved to Australia in the early 2000s, you would've felt rich. Inflation is not currently a problem in Australia.

See: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=aud+to+usd

Re: the property bubble. House prices in Australia are high compared to historical levels. However, as this article from Crikey describes, Australian wages have risen too. While median house prices are still at a higher level compared to median wages (see: http://economics.hia.com.au/media/House%20price%20to%20incom...), they have been soft and in some cases reducing this year. They haven't 'burst' in the way the US housing bubble did.

The differences between Australia and the US where you had a massive house bubble are numerous.

* Australian banks are more heavily regulated and haven't lent 'sub-prime' mortgages.

* Australian housing market has good fundamentals - our population growth has been quite high (due to overseas migration, like yourself!), and in most areas there is an undersupply of housing (with exceptions like the gold coast).

I think you are overplaying the negatives in Australia, in general everything is working quite well as this convincing piece from Crikey shows.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by brc on Thursday December 08, 2011 @07:59PM (#3331983)
* Australian banks are more heavily regulated and haven't lent 'sub-prime' mortgages.

This is completely untrue. The extent of sub-prime mortgages isn't the same, but it exists nonetheless. As does the existence of RBMS, which the government continues to purchase from the banks.

All of that looks over the fact that the big 4 banks in Australia are massively overexposed to residential mortgages and small business loans underpinned by residential property. In some ways it's worse than the USA because the mortgages are still on the books rather than being sold off into the secondary market.

The differences between the Irish housing bubble and the Australian housing bubble are actually much less. So you're right to say that there the parallells between the USA and Australia are less, but the parallells between Ireland and Australia are few. Ireland has full-recourse mortgages like Australia. Ireland had a massive overinvestment in property, like Australia. Ireland had high immigration, like Australia.

As I've said elsewhere in this thread, I don't think there is ever a time when you take your eyes off the negative.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by thmcmahon on Thursday December 08, 2011 @09:11PM (#3332187)
I agree that Australia shouldn't become complacent, and I agree that housing is historically highly priced in Australia, I just don't agree that we are looking at a catastrophic bubble.

Ireland and Australias' levels of net migration aren't comparable either. See:

http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=ireland+net+migration%2...

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by Nick_C on Saturday December 10, 2011 @09:34PM (#3339121)
> banks in Australia are massively overexposed to residential mortgages and small business loans underpinned by residential property

As opposed to what, though? Historically housing and small business loans were the raison d'etre for being a bank. It is only the last few decades where they have been allowed to invest in other areas.

I think you are overplaying the exposure to housing. Our tier capital requirements were and are much more onerous than in the U.S. We (our central bank and treasury) have been telling the U.S. for two decades that their banking system was broken, and we were proven right. You can't compare a U.S. bank to an Australian one, they are very different beasts.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by jacques_chester on Thursday December 08, 2011 @09:20PM (#3332213)
The reason our housing is so expensive is largely due to supply issues. Australia has some of the most complex land release and use laws in the world. The incentives to liberalise these rules are weak because State governments, who hold the legal power to do so, get higher revenues from stamp duty if land prices are higher.

The high cost of property runs the risk of slowly strangling the middle class. Not a good idea.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by brc on Thursday December 08, 2011 @10:42PM (#3332430)
We don't always agree jacques, but I'm totally with you on this.

Stamp duty is the most regressive, unfair tax around.

Paying $15,000 or more in tax to move houses? Madness. How on earth is that considered fair, or a good thing for economic development? Particularly when the states agreed to drop stamp duty in return for the GST incomes.

If you take it that demand for housing is pretty much unlimited (everyone wants their own dwelling, and everyone wants as much space as possible) then you must look at supply.

Sure, cities like Sydney are geographically constrained, but this doesn't explain the high cost of housing places where there are no geographic constraints, only planning constraints.

Historically, in Australia, the cost of the land was well below the cost of building a house on it. Now it easily exceeds 50% of the cost in some cases.

The block of dirt under my feet cost 1500 pounds in the mid 1960's. Converted to a modern value, that is about $30,000. That value is out by a factor of probably 15-20 times. Which means, in rough terms, the land is 20 times more valuable now than it was back then. While some of this is attributable to improvement in services, population increase, etc etc, there isn't anywhere where you can buy a house block for $30,000 which is the inflation-adjusted price of the land as it was originally when the subdivision was opened.

The high value of land can only have one factor - restriction in supply. Restriction of supply is caused by a combination of large land-holders drip-feeding blocks on to the market and in collusion with the state government putting major restrictions on the ability to release land for sale.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by nl on Friday December 09, 2011 @12:44AM (#3332754)
We don't always agree jacques, but I'm totally with you on this. Stamp duty is the most regressive, unfair tax around

I think everyone agrees with that. Getting it fixed is hard though.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by scythe on Thursday December 08, 2011 @07:46PM (#3331939)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PPP_per_capita

When comparing income by country, you need to take into account cost of living, yes. This index I've linked does that; Australia is at parity with the richer countries in Europe, but behind the US, Switzerland and Norway.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by nikatwork on Thursday December 08, 2011 @08:36PM (#3332093)
Oz retail imports are controlled by a bloc who artificially inflate prices to line their own pockets.

Which is why Oz online (overseas) shopping has exploded over the past two years. I sincerely hope it forces the local market to become competitive.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by vacri on Thursday December 08, 2011 @11:07PM (#3332501)
One thing to keep in mind when comparing cost of living: minimum wage.

In the US, minimum waqe is about US$7.50. In Australia, it's about US$15. Your McValue meal is $1-2 cheaper in the US, but the minimum/low wage worker (the bulk of the workforce) has to work for less time to get that meal in Aus.

Until the e-commerce boom of the last 5-10 years, this disparity wasn't much of a problem, as economies were much more localised.

I'm not saying it's the complete answer (thankfully, I'm not an economist), but it's one of the most overlooked factors in all these analyses: the buying power of the poor.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by keeperofdakeys on Friday December 09, 2011 @12:42AM (#3332748)
If you think about those who work in the food industry in the US, they depend on tips to get back the rest of that money. Unlike the US, you aren't obliged to tip in Australia.
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by vacri on Friday December 09, 2011 @01:57AM (#3332909)
$7.50 is just the straight minimum wage, regardless of industry (varies from state to state). Hospitality workers in the US earn less than that (think I heard one say it was about $2.50).

US Dept of Labour says federal min wage is $7.25: http://www.dol.gov/dol/topic/wages/minimumwage.htm

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by robryan on Thursday December 08, 2011 @07:49PM (#3331946)
I don't think it is really a fair comparison to compare a traditional retailer dabbling in online to what else is available online. The traditional retailers play on Australians traditionally expecting to pay more for the same products. As the internet has opened up commerce these kind of companies wouldn't survive for long.
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by twelvechairs on Thursday December 08, 2011 @09:15PM (#3332203)
What you miss is that because Amazon is not in Australia, you have to pay a significant price for shipping and currency transfer to USD, then wait weeks (in my experience up to over a month!) for the thing to arrive....

This is what holds back Australians from not ordering more online, especially at Amazon...

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by jbarham on Thursday December 08, 2011 @09:32PM (#3332246)
I didn't miss anything: my most recent purchase from Amazon cost $11 in shipping and arrived in less than a week. I have a USD credit card, but even if you pay w/ a AUD card the currency conversion is instantaneous and costs maybe a couple of percentage points.

Shipping is often cheaper from outside of Australia than it is within Australia (http://www.malcolmturnbull.com.au/blogs/malcolms-blog/barrie...) which creates more of an incentive to shop internationally.

Where goods are purely digital (e.g., Amazon Kindle or O'Reilly e-books) the whole discussion around shipping costs is obviously moot.

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by daemin on Thursday December 08, 2011 @10:09PM (#3332341)
In addition (I've done many orders from Amazon) I find that even though Amazon estimates 4-6 weeks for delivery, the package(s) are here in 2 weeks.
Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by twelvechairs on Friday December 09, 2011 @06:50AM (#3333414)
Okay - I cant argue with that. My last experience with amazon Aus was 5 years ago, but that was terrible (V. expensive shipping, and item arriving long after 'estimated' arrival time). Perhaps they have picked up their game now, but I know there are others like me with a negative experience that has discouraged future use of Amazon in Aus...

Shipping costs may have been reduced too, but Im sure they are still much greater than other countries...

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by nl on Friday December 09, 2011 @12:46AM (#3332757)
What you miss is that because Amazon is not in Australia, you have to pay a significant price for shipping and currency transfer to USD, then wait weeks (in my experience up to over a month!) for the thing to arrive

http://www.bookdepository.co.uk/

Free (and pretty fast) shipping to Australia, better prices than Amazon, and a good catalogue (No association other than a happy customer).

Re:"Australian Exceptionalism": best performing and fairest ... by yardie on Friday December 09, 2011 @05:17AM (#3333248)
They were bought by Amazon a few months ago. I'm not sure if their business model will have an effect on Amazon or Amazon's business model will have an effect on TBD.