News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft team submits Redis patch to enable Windows support by chimeracoder on Thursday December 08, 2011 @05:29PM (#3331481)
They might be doing other things you don't like, but at least give credit where credit is due.

Submitting code upstream to Redis is completely independent of their patent decisions regarding Android. I'm not a fan of their overall stance with respect to FOSS/Linux/Android, and they may be earning the snark there, but not in this case.

These discussions become a lot more valuable when we stop characterizing any organization, especially one as complex as a large corporation, as universally 'good' or 'bad'.

Re:Microsoft team submits Redis patch to enable Windows support by rbanffy on Thursday December 08, 2011 @05:38PM (#3331510)
> give credit where credit is due

Sure. Just don't forget they profit from Windows sales and, thus, will do anything to justify the deployment of a Windows server instead of a Linux one. Including contributing to a Unix-native product. If, in the end, Redis' codebase becomes cluttered and performance and maintenance suffer, we all lose. I mean, all of us except Microsoft, who wins both by us losing and from gaining space for their own future offerings in this segment.

There is no good or bad. It's self interest. When their self-interest coincides with the society's, I'm for them. OTOH, it's been a long time since it last did. It certainly never happened after the mid 90's.

Re:Microsoft team submits Redis patch to enable Windows support by mythz on Thursday December 08, 2011 @06:49PM (#3331777)
Of course they're selfishly motivated - everyone is. The point is this time Redis/NoSQL stands to benefit as well.
Re:Microsoft team submits Redis patch to enable Windows support by d0mine on Thursday December 08, 2011 @08:08PM (#3332016)
It seems you've skipped the sentence:

If, in the end, Redis' codebase becomes cluttered and performance and maintenance suffer, we all lose. </quote>

Re:Microsoft team submits Redis patch to enable Windows support by mythz on Thursday December 08, 2011 @08:41PM (#3332108)
That's a case for not merging, not for a parallel win32-based project - which this implementation could serve either of.
Re:Microsoft team submits Redis patch to enable Windows support by rbanffy on Thursday December 08, 2011 @10:33PM (#3332410)
It would risk diverting attention from the Unix port to the Win32 one. Even if the Redis developers don't pay attention to this distraction, its mere existence fragments the codebase and creates two semi-compatible versions.

And if the Windows version sucks badly, any Windows user who tries to install it on Windows will end up blaming Redis and try something else. On Windows.

Microsoft wins and we lose on all scenarios.

Re:Microsoft team submits Redis patch to enable Windows support by mythz on Friday December 09, 2011 @03:42AM (#3333081)
This is a very pessimistic view of the world and future events (which I don't share). I'd get that looked at.

A bad Redis port by Microsoft makes them look bad, whilst their endorsement of Redis makes Redis looks good.

The 'pro developers' that Redis attracts are going to be more than capable of identifying the culprit behind a shitty port.

Re:Microsoft team submits Redis patch to enable Windows support by beagle3 on Thursday December 08, 2011 @06:27PM (#3331694)
> These discussions become a lot more valuable when we stop characterizing any organization, especially one as complex as a large corporation, as universally 'good' or 'bad'.

That is true. But it is also foolish to ignore over 20 years of Microsoft's strategy, the mostly successful "embrace, extend and extinguish".

This patch is purely out of self interest: people might install a unix server if they want Redis and can't have it on Windows. There is no "good will" (and no "bad will").

If it harms performance on linux? Well, they are likely not to care at this point, or at least one second after the patch is accepted.

Microsoft has a history of co-operating with the rest of the world only when they are at a disadvantage, and ignoring standards and conventions when they have the advantage.

Excuse me if I'm not enthusiastic about a patch they send to a project I like.

Re:Microsoft team submits Redis patch to enable Windows support by beagle3 on Friday December 09, 2011 @12:29PM (#3334569)
Missed this first time I commented:

> Submitting code upstream to Redis is completely independent of their patent decisions regarding Android. I'm not a fan of their overall stance with respect to FOSS/Linux/Android, and they may be earning the snark there, but not in this case.

Wrong. They are both cleared by the same legal department, guided by the same company vision. They are not being a useful member of the community. They're trying to give people less reason to leave Windows. Pure self interest, completely in line with everything else they do.