News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by catiopatio on Sunday October 23, 2022 @09:32AM (#33306860)
This is paternalistic, overbearing, culturally-corrosive nonsense.

Substandard buildings, medical procedures, and cars maim and kill.

AI image generation is speech.

I won’t accept prior restraint on speech as being necessary or inevitable.

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by galangalalgol on Sunday October 23, 2022 @09:40AM (#33306919)
Also, I thought stable diffusion did release their models and methodology? You just need a 3080 with enough ram to do the inference with now boundaries, and if you have the money and time can train new models.

People are already making txt2porn sites. I'm sure they will get crazier and creepier (from my boring vanilla perspective, not judging people with eclectic tastes) as time goes by.

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by bbarnett on Sunday October 23, 2022 @09:45AM (#33306966)
People are already making txt2porn sites

Hi, asking for a friend. Where did you hear about this?

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by galangalalgol on Sunday October 23, 2022 @10:18AM (#33307213)
I saw it here a couple months ago. The results so far were quite odd but it's early days. I'm not sure what the ethics are. My understanding is that models/actors of consenting age are now well treated in the industry. I'm not sire what those people will do if replaced. But that is true of uber and truck drivers when they figure out self driving, or me when copilot gets a lot better.

As for those not considered capable of consent? Maybe this decreases the pressure to hurt more of those people? But the ethics of training seem hidiously evil to me.

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by throwaway049 on Sunday October 23, 2022 @10:32AM (#33307311)
"My understanding is that models/actors of consenting age are now well treated in the industry."

It's a spectrum, like most other industries.

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by scarby2 on Sunday October 23, 2022 @11:08AM (#33307567)
Totally, however as somebody who knows quite a few adult content creators and sex workers I would say the standard for the industry is actually pretty high.
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by imhoguy on Sunday October 23, 2022 @09:58AM (#33307061)
Damn, somebody just parked that dot com domain.
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by galangalalgol on Sunday October 23, 2022 @10:21AM (#33307226)
Close enough that they probably got the idea from my post? I should probably start checking
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by runlevel1 on Sunday October 23, 2022 @11:56AM (#33307886)
No, looks like it was just over a week ago: 2022-10-15T01:04:51Z
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by rubidium on Sunday October 23, 2022 @09:35AM (#33306879)
You’re free bud. You can make it and release. But you have no standing to just complain about it.
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by catiopatio on Sunday October 23, 2022 @09:39AM (#33306913)
The parent comment argues for the necessity and inevitability of legal regulation.

We all have standing to debate our shared culture and ethics.

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by tdehnel on Sunday October 23, 2022 @09:41AM (#33306934)
Your comment equates to “stop talking” as if talking and ideas were somehow not the basic unit of democracy.
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by zdragnar on Sunday October 23, 2022 @10:06AM (#33307105)
Ah yes, the classic democratic debate of "I don't like your justifications, you should give away all your work for free!"
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by tdehnel on Sunday October 23, 2022 @11:52PM (#33312780)
It’s a democracy bub
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by Turing_Machine on Sunday October 23, 2022 @04:26PM (#33309963)
You're allowed to complain about anything you want.

And others are allowed to either ignore your complants, or act on them.

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by kuramitropolis on Sunday October 23, 2022 @09:45AM (#33306964)
Speech can get people to maim and kill, too. Sometimes with surprising efficiency. And when a technology is outlawed, the power that it bestows upon humanity concentrates in the outlaws. For sure, information and communication technology are an interesting edge case of that general principle.
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by blfr on Sunday October 23, 2022 @09:52AM (#33307013)
Sure but the deplatforming isn't happening after we learned about German concentration camps or Russian gulags. The first amendment stood firm then, even got strengthened by the courts.

We are seeing widespread censorship efforts over misgendering.

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by ookdatnog on Sunday October 23, 2022 @10:15AM (#33307193)
If you believe the post-WW2 USA was a free speech paradise with no political persecution, you have some reading to do.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCarthyism

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lavender_scare

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by albatruss on Sunday October 23, 2022 @10:00AM (#33307070)
The USA threw 100k+ of its own citizens in concentration camps, stripping them of property and leaving them in poverty after the war. Not exactly a shining moment for principles.
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by themitigating on Sunday October 23, 2022 @10:09AM (#33307133)
Can you show me examples of widespread censorship due to misgendering?
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by concordDance on Sunday October 23, 2022 @10:21AM (#33307233)
Reddit is a good example.
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by themitigating on Sunday October 23, 2022 @10:26AM (#33307273)
Reddit is a website
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by dudeinjapan on Sunday October 23, 2022 @11:28AM (#33307708)
Literally all major platform websites--Youtube, Tiktok, Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, etc.--ban all posts which contain misgendering and deadnaming as part of their broader "hate speech" policies.

Agree or not, this is "censorship", and it is "widespread".

It is hard to show examples of censored content because it is, you know, censored. But you can try some posts for yourself on these platforms and see how it goes.

https://help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-policies/hateful-condu... https://decisionmagazine.com/facebook-says-misgendering-cons... https://www.npr.org/2022/02/09/1079643611/tiktok-bans-deadna...

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by themitigating on Sunday October 23, 2022 @01:01PM (#33308407)
I disagree, in my opinion censorship is when an authority, like the government, punishes speech.

If I uses the nword on twitter and get banned would that be censorship? It's listed with deadnaming in the TOS

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by dudeinjapan on Monday October 24, 2022 @05:25AM (#33314472)
So, you don't consider multi-trillion dollar valued companies, whose annual revenues are greater than the GDP of the majority of countries in the world, and who have sole control over platforms used by over 1/3 the world's entire population, to be "authorities" capable of censorship.

OK, well, good luck then.

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by themitigating on Monday October 24, 2022 @06:40PM (#33323593)
No, because you can use another product. The government can fine or send you to jail.
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by dudeinjapan on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @05:10AM (#33341351)
Literally all major products currently have similar censorship rules, no matter which one you choose.

Re: countries, "you can move to another country."

The cognitive dissonance is strong with this one.

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by TheCondor on Sunday October 23, 2022 @10:08AM (#33307124)
How has the first amendment been compromised?
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by pjc50 on Sunday October 23, 2022 @11:04AM (#33307531)
There is specific provision in German law precisely because of the concentration camps: https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/germanys-laws-ant...
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by oneplane on Sunday October 23, 2022 @11:05AM (#33307540)
You seem to forget that this AI doesn't really give a crap about your arbitrary borders, a document or an amendment to that document. You also seem forget that even if it did, most people don't live in the same country under the same jurisdiction, so even if everything you think and feel turns out to be true, it still doesn't help the conversation at all.

On top of that, you also seem to be trying to mix-and-match rules for institutions and rules for private entities as you see fit which is also not how any of this works.

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by nixpulvis on Sunday October 23, 2022 @09:48AM (#33306989)
One day we will crack the "platforming" issue. Until that day, free speech remains under attack, for reasons I cannot wrap my head around completely. It is pervasive though, to the point it feels like a gag at times.

But yea, if speech can become law, it can matter quite a bit. Do we really want DALL-E generated state laws?

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by dd36 on Sunday October 23, 2022 @11:14AM (#33307625)
What free speech was attacked?
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by thfuran on Sunday October 23, 2022 @10:20AM (#33307221)
Sometimes they just inconvenience one group of people or fail to sufficiently support local industry and those aspects are regulated too. Anything big enough is going to get regulatory scrutiny in one way or another because it's moving around a lot of money and affecting a lot of people.
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by riversflow on Sunday October 23, 2022 @10:39AM (#33307364)
> AI image generation is speech.

Sure, but I don’t think an AI model is speech, at least not one trained on billions of parameters and massive quantities of compute. Comparing it to regulated heavy machinery or architecture is apt.

You can’t create an AI model without huge, global industries working together to create the tools to produce said model. And baked in are all sorts of biases that if met with wide-spread adoption could likely have profound social consequences, particularly because these models aren’t easy to make, so the likelihood that they will see large amounts of adoption/use is likely, they are useful tools after all. Group prejudice in these models jumps off the page here, whether race, sex, religion, etc. but black box algorithms are fundamentally dangerous.

Speech is fundamental to the human experience, large ML models are not, and calling them speech is nuts.

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by hellojesus on Sunday October 23, 2022 @10:52AM (#33307455)
Aren't people allowed to release source code on free speech grounds? There's not much difference. One could publish a model with its weights, and that would qualify as free speech.
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by bumby on Sunday October 23, 2022 @10:57AM (#33307478)
I believe it depends. Free speech is not without limits. I think there's still a lot of discussion in the biomed community about the legality/ethics of releasing methods that can be used by bad actors to generate potentially harmful results.
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by extheat on Sunday October 23, 2022 @11:47AM (#33307822)
All sorts of software can be used to “generate potentially harmful results”. Think about an algorithm for displaying content on social media sites, a search engine, a piece of malware on a computer. Do we ban books on how to make bombs? It’s such a broad point to make that it’s practically meaningless. The computers job is to read a set of instructions and execute them. It’s abstractly no different to a human writing instructions for another human, with the adage that the computer is a much faster processor than a human. You can quite literally run these ML models (a collection of statistically weighted averages) with pen and paper and a calculator (or even none!). Things will be maliciously used, that means we don’t ban sharp forks (at the determent of legitimate users), we ban those that intentionally misuse those tools.
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by bumby on Sunday October 23, 2022 @02:04PM (#33308883)
You’re correct, and, yes, it can apply to virtually anything. But we don’t let that hold us hostage for properly mitigating risk.

I think the distinction is when a threat is “imminent”. To the point of this thread, I don’t think the dialogue has progressed enough to form a consensus on where that “imminent threshold” lies.

Teaching someone about DNA doesn’t constitute an imminent threat. But the equivalent of teaching the recipe for a biological weapon may be considered enough of an imminent risk to warrant regulation.

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by tikhonj on Sunday October 23, 2022 @11:20AM (#33307662)
You can't create Hollywood blockbusters or video games without huge, global industries working together to produce the tools and content. Popular media has biases and, clearly, social consequences as well—there's a reason people talk about how much "soft power" the US has!

And yet pop culture content is speech both in a casual and in a legal/policy sense.

AI models are not identical to movies or video games, but they're not different in any of the aspects you listed. On the other hand, there is a pretty clear difference between AI models and heavy machinery or architecture: AI models cannot directly hurt or kill people in the physical world. An AI model controlling a physical system could, which is a case to have strict regulations on things like self-driving cars, but doesn't apply to the text/image/etc generation models we're talking about here. Plans for heavy machinery or buildings are not regulated until somebody tries to create them in the real world (and are also very clearly speech, even if they took a lot of engineering effort to produce). At least in the US, nobody is going to stop you from publishing plans for arbitrarily dangerous tools or buildings with narrow exceptions for defense-critical technology.

Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by datavirtue on Sunday October 23, 2022 @11:05AM (#33307541)
It's not speech. It's data.
Re:Ask HN: Is Anyone Else Tired of the Self Enforced Limits ... by colinmhayes on Sunday October 23, 2022 @01:35PM (#33308652)
Well you're not the decision maker here. If the public gets sufficiently upset about ai generated lookalike porn these models will be regulated and maybe banned. And as you seem to realize that doesn't mean people will stop using them, it just means the companies that make them will stop getting paid. Obviously this is what they're trying to avoid, and the morality stuff is just because they don't want to say "we're worried about being regulated."