> “what footage do I have locally of this face?” which can be extremely helpful when securing a home.
How? What mechanism of security is strengthened here? Almost certainly your only use case for this data is handing it over to the police to apply their facial recognition systems to it. Which they have because of homeowners like you, I guess. It's the same surveillance apparatus as in your google case except more manual and less efficient. If it shouldn't exist at all, a bad version of it also shouldn't exist.
“Alarm if any face other than these 5 are detected on an indoor camera between the hours of 10pm and 8am”
“I want to review all footage of the nanny from the past week since they spend time alone with my children”
“Show me all footage of myself inside the house in the last 15 minutes because I have no idea where I set my keys down”
“I just heard a window break at 2am, which cameras are detecting motion so my wife can avoid them to get the kids out while I do the opposite to buy them some time”
It doesn't matter whether it's a paternalistic police state or literally you, dad, sitting in the seat of the panopticon. It's bad for the psyche of everyone surveilled in this way and it shouldn't be done. The fantasy that you'll use this in an emergency is the same one gun owners use to justify their decisions, and just as likely to come true.
> The fantasy that you’ll use this in an emergency
Knowing how many people are in my home and where they are at 2am seems like information that would be extremely helpful. You’ll need to share data to backup your stance that I’m doing home security wrong. I’d love to learn how to do it better.
Let’s not derail this into a conversation about guns, we can save that disagreement for another day.
All of my security cameras are isolated on my network. They do not exchange packets with the public internet. They can not phone home to the manufacturer.
If law enforcement has footage from my surveillance system, it’s because they have a warrant or because I willingly handed the footage over to them after someone made a bad decision on my property.
Yes, that was the assumption I had in mind while writing that.
While I’m on the side of less surveillance in general, I don’t think I like this logic: it seems to me that the crucial point that distinguishes the systems of the last couple of decades from what came before is convenience. “No expectation of privacy” means very different things when someone needs to physically follow you around or even make a lucky guess as to which CCTV to look at compared to making a query from the comfort of their desk. It’s one thing for a passing cop to memorize your license plate number and then have to thumb through paper files in order to know that’s you; it’s another for them to have a full map of every car and owner name on it. (I don’t think the latter extremes are available in most countries yet, FWIW.) The bland “expectation of privacy” wording seems to miss this sliding scale of effort for a given amount of tracking.
I actually half suspect that this argument is wrong for some dumb reason I’m missing, because I don’t have a source for it (even though it seems to be in the air somehow) and even supposed experts like EFF lawyers don’t seem to be making it. But I haven’t yet found that reason.
> It’s one thing for a passing cop to memorize your license plate number and then have to thumb through paper files in order to know that’s you; it’s another for them to have a full map of every car and owner name on it.
Those are the exact same thing if you're a person who cops are following around already, memorizing your number trying to get you for any offense they can. The difference is for many people, particularly people overrepresented on HN, the police are not generally taking much interest in your routine activities and trying to use them against you. But this isn't a relationship with policing that everyone has.
All these abuses were already here, they just weren't applied to everyone. The expanding of these capabilities is what makes them devastating, you're right. But the earlier iterations weren't actually less bad, they were just less likely to be applied to us.
Counter point. My security system is not easily taken offline (where I live cutting the power isn’t unheard of even for citizens entering the home - and destroying footage is something I worry about for state actors). If the state enters my home COINTELPRO style, or gets the wrong house, I want footage of that encounter under my control when it’s time to go to court.
I think this line of thinking lines up well with my original comment. We shouldn’t look at this technology as an all encompassing shift towards centralization of power. There are uses that gives power back to individuals. This power is a good thing on an individual level and dangerous in aggregate.
And I get how this comment will be taken, but it would be good for all the HN libertarians to introspect and think a bit on whether they really want to get their "stronger enforcement of personal internet privacy standards" via "extended use of state power against political enemies".
Seems like both of those are slippery slopes. I know which one I personally fear more.
https://about.fb.com/news/2021/11/update-on-use-of-face-reco...
So basically to prevent police being able to do this you have to prevent hosting non-end to end encrypted photos.
That’s a significantly reduced service capability.
Hopefully a court would reject that warrant as being too broad, but either way the compute to do this would be really expensive for any not-large company, or even a large company if they regularly get these requests.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/sep/16/geofence-war...
The police have already used such geo-fenced warrants before.
Building a local profile of faces observed on a single person’s property isn’t problematic for me. In order for the police to search it, they have to issue a very specific warrant for a specific addresses’ surveillance data. Its also anonymous by default - while you have the face, the data is local and isn’t attached to any “network” of facial recognition software. Its not being used to track people moving from house to house, or business to business, to build a “model” of their behavior to manipulate them. It’s specifically “what footage do I have locally of this face?” which can be extremely helpful when securing a home.
This is in stark contrast to what I worry companies like Google do (Facebook has been caught doing it): building shadow profiles of non-users that track behaviors across all places their face shows up (surveillance footage, personal photos of other users, etc.). This is a network of information consolidated into a single point. You have no reasonable expectation of privacy in public, but I do believe you should have a reasonable expectation that people aren’t stalking your every move across many properties and aggregating that data into a single source law enforcement can get access to with a single warrant.