Re:Texas Sues Google for Collecting Biometric Data Without C...
by r3trohack3r on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:30PM
(#33291428)
I love this train of thought and it aligns well with how I think about the world. You treat state actors differently than citizens and, living under a state, they are absolutely in your threat model for home security. Police get it wrong sometimes. Sometimes they act maliciously.
Counter point. My security system is not easily taken offline (where I live cutting the power isn’t unheard of even for citizens entering the home - and destroying footage is something I worry about for state actors). If the state enters my home COINTELPRO style, or gets the wrong house, I want footage of that encounter under my control when it’s time to go to court.
I think this line of thinking lines up well with my original comment. We shouldn’t look at this technology as an all encompassing shift towards centralization of power. There are uses that gives power back to individuals. This power is a good thing on an individual level and dangerous in aggregate.
> It’s one thing for a passing cop to memorize your license plate number and then have to thumb through paper files in order to know that’s you; it’s another for them to have a full map of every car and owner name on it.
Those are the exact same thing if you're a person who cops are following around already, memorizing your number trying to get you for any offense they can. The difference is for many people, particularly people overrepresented on HN, the police are not generally taking much interest in your routine activities and trying to use them against you. But this isn't a relationship with policing that everyone has.
All these abuses were already here, they just weren't applied to everyone. The expanding of these capabilities is what makes them devastating, you're right. But the earlier iterations weren't actually less bad, they were just less likely to be applied to us.