News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by johncoltrane on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:31AM (#33285153)
Not to rain on your parade but Bluetooth has been solving that very problem across every OSes for _many_ years without having to install anything.
Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by alexstyl on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:03AM (#33285320)
if that was true, why do people keep sending files to themselves via email, whatsapp and telegram?
Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by johncoltrane on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:13AM (#33285744)
I think it has been demonstrably true for maybe a good decade and half. As to why some people use alternative methods… maybe because they like it like that? Or maybe because they can't use Bluetooth for some reason? Or maybe they don't know better? Ask them.

Select a file, tap on "share", tap on "bluetooth", choose a device, wait a few seconds, done.

Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by rock3r on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:29AM (#33285850)
Personally, I don't use Bluetooth for these reasons:

1. It's clunky 2. It's slow 3. It's unreliable

Anything that has a better UX than Bluetooth file sharing is a win for me.

Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by johncoltrane on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:35AM (#33286555)
Well, I use Bluetooth because it has been part of every "device" I've owned in the last 15 years or so. Is it good for moving large files? Nope. Is it good for moving a handful of pics or videos between two devices? Yep.

Hell, I'm even listening to my Mac's music on the TV via Bluetooth as I write this.

Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by izerik on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:44AM (#33285949)
Have you actually tried to send files via bluetooth from Android -> MacOS or Android -> iOS?

I can't make it work, the file just doesn't get through.

Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by johncoltrane on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:18AM (#33286451)
I do it relatively often, to make room on my Android phone. Did it no later than a couple days ago and the 17 pictures ended up in my Downloads folder as usual.
Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by Vibgyor5 on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:22AM (#33286167)
Literally just tried this and no, it doesn't work at all. Devices are connected but the sending fails (Android -> Mac)
Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by johncoltrane on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:20AM (#33286463)
Did you enable Bluetooth sharing on the Mac?
Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by Vibgyor5 on Friday October 21, 2022 @08:32AM (#33287320)
Yes
Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by jlokier on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:45AM (#33286620)
I just shared a photo using the sequence you described from Android -> MacOS.

Contrary to my sibling commenters, it did just work. A prompt appeared on MacOS asking if I wanted to accept the connection request, then asking if I wanted to accept a filee. I agreed, a download progress bar appeared until it was finished, and when it was done, the file was in the Downloads folder.

Wow, it was incredibly slow, though. Transfer rate ~50kB/s, about 500x slower than uploading the file to a cloud server somewhere and downloading it again. 2000x slower than local Wifi. Distance between devices: about 60cm. Time to transfer 1 photo: 10 seconds, after starting the download.

The Android UI was unhelpful for finding the Bluetooth option to share to. The Share icon showed 5 share methods (none of them Bluetooth, one of them "Quick Share" to "nearby Galaxy devices", it's even more specific than Android-only), plus 5 contacts-with-methods (none of them useful: SMS and WhatsApp, and I don't even have WhatsApp activated on this phone), plus a different kind of button for "Nearby Share" (something to do with nearby people in your Contacts, which doesn't explain how it does that so I assume some cloud service I'd rather not use). Finding "Bluetooth" involved some hardly discoverable horizontal scrolling with no visual affordance, using a different UI than the share options listed from other apps.

But it did work, extremely slowly.

It's not obvious, but some of the other share options use Bluetooth to set up the connection then Wifi to transfer the files, perhaps about ~2000x faster. Some supposedly use local Wifi alone, no Bluetooth required. Unfortunately I've never had success with any of them, so I can't confirm if any of them actually work as advertised. A few years ago I spent nearly an hour trying to all the different methods on the phone I had, to send a collection of photos from Android to MacOS without using an internet service, and nothing worked. Each built-in sharing method failed in some way, and standard Bluetooth file transfer was too slow. In the end I gave up and transferred just a few of the photos the slow way. It is striking (and absurd) that cloud services run much faster than local transfer - when both devices have access to a usable internet connection.

Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by Vibgyor5 on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:42AM (#33285930)
But there's no reliable and seamless way to transfer files from Android to Mac
Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by MisterSandman on Friday October 21, 2022 @10:59AM (#33288681)
Are you joking? Bluetooth takes 20-30 seconds for me to send a 5-page PDF of a scanned document. As someone in university who had to scan hand-written documents and submit them for exams during COVID, bluetooth was literally useless. I used WhatsApp instead to send it to myself.
Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by johncoltrane on Sunday October 23, 2022 @04:34AM (#33305482)
You are complaining about a 20-30 seconds upload time. I am not the one joking, here.
Re:Show HN: It's 2022 and sharing files from Android to Mac ... by MisterSandman on Monday October 24, 2022 @11:08AM (#33317704)
It's 2022, it should not take 20-30 seconds to transfer a small PDF between a phone and laptop.