I was riding during daytime, with many years experience, safely while going in a precisely straight line and not changing speed. Nice, 90% tires with rain tolerant tread and perfectly maintained vehicle. All drivers around me driving safely, me driving safely, rainy but good conditions. Hit a slippery patch on the road, that was somehow angled such that my rear tire slipped at an angle and I was almost instantaneously thrown high-side from the bike, at 70mph from an interstate.
Full body suit, helmet, gloves. I walked away without even a scratch (I still can't believe how). But almost died; only survived by the fact I was thrown towards the curb instead of towards the fast lane of traffic.
I'd been in lots of crashes before, but usually because I did dumb shit. This time really shocked my conscious because there was just no explanation, no bad drivers, no bad vehicles, no dumb shit, nothing remarkably bad with the road, nothing I can assign fault to anyone or anything. It was a solid week before I got back on the bike after that; usually after a crash I'm back on within minutes if it's still rideable. Impossible to prevent, and no way something like that can happen in a car.
I've totaled out a bike myself and gotten back on, but more and more I think maybe it's time to give it up. Especially because I think there's a non-zero (but small) chance we solve aging/death in my lifetime.
I don't think something like that can happen on an typical uniform slippery surface. I rode motorcycles exclusively for some time in seattle (rain capital of the US) and never had that happen. Rode motorcycles year round off and on for ~10 years before this happened, it was a freak occurrence. I think it requires a particularly nasty freak occurrence of the shape of a wet patch and the angle and entry point at which you hit it.
It's unclear to me after reading both the GP and your comment.
Another confounding, but obvious point, is that alcohol and risky driving is also more of a factor at night than it is during the day. People also might assume that a motorcycle rider is _less_ likely to commit a DUI, when it's actually the opposite.
Once you take risky single vehicle accidents out of the picture, the statistic that really starts to stand out is pedestrians. They go from 16% of all deaths to around 30% of the remaining deaths. These are also most likely to happen at night, and a surprising number happen outside of urban areas; and it wasn't clear from NHTSA data alone whether that was due to speed of the vehicle being higher or the distance to a hospital being greater.
One odd point that I didn't have time to chase down is it seems that elderly drivers and passengers are much safer in the front seat. There was a strong skew for their fatalities to be found in the rear seats of vehicles. The profile was something like 80 year olds in the rear, and 40 year olds in the front. This seemed like a particularly dangerous configuration for elderly passengers.
The other interesting data point I gathered is that Texas had a higher number of fatalities over California, even though it has a smaller population. It suggests that state laws and road design are also a large factor in fatalities.
Anyways.. NHTSA publishes the FARS database. Every fatality is recorded, and if it was investigated all of the data is reported in a standardized format. They even have a "sequence of events leading up to the fatality" coded in there. It's an amazing resource.
That's misleading. You can't cut those out and not also cut them out for car drivers. ~30% of US car crash fatalities involve drunk drivers, which is roughly the same as the motorcycle rate
On your specific claim, I don't know about US statistics, but when I looked in Aus (about 5 years ago), the proportion of deaths involving drunk/inexperience/unlicensed riders was much greater than for drivers. Individual choices and skill had a much bigger effect for motorcyclists.
Nonetheless I'm not remotely claiming that death rates are not greatly higher than for drivers. They absolutely are, in all categories. But the headline multiplier may not apply to any given individual.
Put this way, to my judgement a skilled driver should be much safer than an equally skilled motorcycle rider.
In the end though, you're right, and we don't even need anecdotes to prove it - the stats are voluminous and clear. Yes, you can reduce your risk somewhat with good bike and skills maintenance, but even with that, motorcycling is much more risky to life and limb than driving a car. If safety is higher in your valuation than whatever your reasons for riding (there are many possible), riding is never rational. Safety is fairly low in my evaluative framework, and my reasons for riding persuasive, so it's not a hard choice in my personal case.
Humans are quite fragile in relation to the things we do.
Not sure whether a graph of skill vs safety would show increasing or decreasing difference though.
50% of all motorcycle crashes involve the rider having a blood alcohol level above the legal limit.
A high percentage (not sure the exact number) are inexperienced riders who've been riding less than six months.
Another 50% of motorcycle crashes occur at night.
Obviously there's a lot of overlap in these statistics but by and large if you ride sober, learn how to negotiate corners, and don't ride late at night when the drunk drivers are on the road then your chances of being involved in an accident plummet.
Unfortunately, drunk riding is a thing. Where I live there are lots of planned rides, even charity rides, that ride from bar to bar. Group riding is already more dangerous than riding single and now let's add alcohol to the group! What could possibly go wrong?!
Which is not to say that motorcycling isn't far more dangerous than driving a car. Bikes are my sole source of transport, on poor potholed rural windy roads in an area with truly terrible standards of driving, and I'm extremely aware of the dangers every day. But the figures are hugely elevated by a few factors, all of which are trivial to eliminate (for an individual, less so for society at large).